Sunningdale, Wentworth and Walton Heath are the only clubs in the whole of the British Isles other than the Berkshire Golf Club that can boast about having two heathland golf courses positioned in the British Top 100. It’s an amazing surprise that so few people know how charming the Berkshire experience really is.
The Blue course is the Red’s more conventional and slightly shorter sister. A more standard four par 3s, three par 5s and eleven par 4s make up the configuration for this delightful par 71 course. In Bernard Darwin’s book, Golf Between Two Wars, he wrote: “The other, the Blue, which some people prefer, a little less ‘big’, but by no means a secondary course. The country is essentially undulating and interesting and full of natural beauty…The Berkshire courses have more of charm perhaps and less of austere grandeur than Walton Heath.”
Herbert Fowler was the Berkshire’s architect and the Blue course opened for play in 1928. Fowler was actually very good at designing excellent twin golf courses. Not only did Fowler design both courses here at the Berkshire, but he also designed the superb intertwined courses at Walton Heath, the Old and the New.
Both the Berkshire courses have the same natural hazards, although the Blue plays over flatter ground than the Red. Cruelly, the Blue opens up with an exceptionally tough par 3, with the tee directly in front of the clubhouse window. The green sits on a distant plateau. Not the easiest hole on which to start a round of golf – play the Red course in the morning to prepare for it!
There are many other notable holes on the Blue course but it’s the closing sequence of five holes that makes this a tough but special course. All five are par 4s and three of them are more than 400 yards long. It could be argued that the Blue has a similar but less acute weakness than her brother the Red – the three par 5s on the Blue course are very short indeed, the longest measures only 477 yards.
However, short par fives aside, the Berkshire is the most delightful place to play 36 holes of golf, perhaps only surpassed by the pairing of Sunningdale’s Old and New courses.
I love The Berkshire. If you've read my review on the red you'll be able to tell that it is my favourite. However, the blue is not to be sniffed at.
The 1st is a wonderful long par 3 infront of the clubhouse over heather. 2 and 3 provide good birdie chances.
4 is one of the best par 3s in England. A beautiful short uphill hole, with the green guarded by bunkers and heather.
7 is a very underrated hole IMO. A lovely dogleg left around heather and pine trees, which only requires a 3 wood and wedge. 9 also flies under the radar, being a short uphill par 4 with great angles and options off the tee.
11, 12 and 13 is a fantastic stretch. 11 is a double dogleg par 5 with a huge tier in the green. 12 is a very straightforward par 4 with one of my favourite bunkers in golf - a trench bunker all the way down the left of the green - and a crazy punchbowl back half of the green. 13 is similar to 4. A beautiful short par 3 with fantastic bunkers, and great views over 11 and 12.
Other strong holes coming in are 14, 15, 16. 18 is a very tough finishing hole, after which you will deserve a drink in the clubhouse.
36 at the Berkshire is the perfect day of golf
I will begin this review of the Blue course by copying the first three paragraphs and final paragraph of my review of the Red course, which I wrote first.
A day spent playing both courses at The Berkshire is in my top ten list of private clubs with two courses. This excludes resorts such as Pebble Beach, Bandon Dunes, Barnbougle Dunes, Trump Turnberry, Gleneagles, Streamsong, etc. While The Berkshire is not at the level of Sunningdale, Baltusrol, Winged Foot, or Walton Heath, it is in the conversation due to the joy one has with the walk and variety of golf holes placed in front of you from both courses. The beauty of the golf courses are also at the same level of some inland courses in England due to the trees, flowering bushes, and heather.
I narrowly prefer the Blue course over the Red, which is contrary to what I read or hear. The reason is that the Red is quirkier with six pars of 3/4/5’s while the Blue is more standard. I also find the Blue course to have a few more “better” holes than the Red and the best nine. Both courses have a weakness in most of their par 5’s lack sufficient challenge. Both courses succumb to a few too many short par 4’s as well. Both the Red and Blue have very good par 3’s. One of the best debates I have had is which course is the superior as one can be easily convinced for one course but then suddenly remember something else about the other course that changes the winner of the debate.
Both courses are cutting back the trees which make the fairways seem wider although they are not. But the beauty of the course is more evident. I would like to come back when it has completed the process….so much golf, so little time.
The Blue hits you right away with one of the best par 3’s in the UK. The first hole would fit into any of the nearby more highly thought of courses and one would still go, “wow.” The heather goes from the tee stopping short of the green and makes for a visual delight. This long par 3 of 217 yards has a green that is well guarded with fronting bunkers on either side and a fall-off on the right that one must carry as it is very punitive. One wishes this hole came much later in the round.
The short par 4 second is again visually pretty but despite having three bunkers at the green, it is too easy of a hole. The short par 5 third is also too easy for the better player and perhaps at 475/460 needs to be converted to a par 4 (shortened by ten yards if one wants), add similar bunkering to the second hole to make the green even more interesting as it slopes front to back, or add at least forty yards. While I do not know who owns the land behind the green, it certainly appeared to have plenty of land available.
The mid-length par 3 fourth hole is a gem. It is the right length due to the defense of the green with three bunkers and a nice slope from the right to the back left. After playing this hole, I wanted to walk back and play it again.
If the short par 4 fifth hole of 330/306 was the only short par 4 on the course, it would be a good hole due to the strategy involved for the better player. This dogleg left has a bunker on the left corner, and three bunkers fronting the green. For the average player, there is no decision here; play out to the right off the tee and wedge on. For the better player it is a true risk:reward hole. However, given there are numerous short par 4’s on the course, it becomes a bit “lost.” Once again, it appeared that one could take the tee back to where the fourth tee is and not change the character of the hole for the better player. I would think it would be fine to have a 420/330 par 4.
I like the sixth hole, a medium length par 5 bending to the left that has a stream winding its way across and along the fairway. The longer player has to consider it for the tee shot while the average player has to think about it more for their second shot. I also liked the green a lot; long and skinny and different to the previous green shapes.
The seventh, a short but sharp dogleg left par 4 at 364/345 has a nice green complex, but I did not think much of the hole and felt there should be a fairway bunker on one side for visual purposes. I thought there should have been a more interesting green for the length of the hole.
Eight is a mid-length par 4 with no bunkers but a nicely sloped green. I wish a similar green had been on the seventh. There is room to lengthen this hole by as much as the club might want.
The short par 4 ninth at 310/298 would be a better hole if it did not remind one of the fourth. However, the rise in the fairway is noticeable and there is another nice green at the end. One almost wonders with today’s technology whether Mr. Fowler would have shortened the hole by 80 yards and made it a splendid long par 3. There is no room to lengthen this hole due to the road behind it.
My summation of the front nine is one fabulous hole which is the first and one really fun hole which is the other par 3, the fourth. The greens are very nice. There is room to lengthen three holes which I think should be considered or lower the par.
The inward half is the better nine as it has better land than the front nine.
Another long par 3 kicks off the back nine at 232/191 although it plays a bit shorter as it is downhill. There is a pond on the right that should not be in play and two bunkers fronting the green. The more difficult recovery is missing to the left. I liked the hole.
The short par 5 eleventh once again has a stream that crosses the fairway and parallels it on the left. This 477/465 hole again should be considered for conversion to a par 4 or more fairway bunkering added. The only true interesting feature to it is the double dogleg.
Another short par 4 of 355/345 dogleg right with a fairway sloped to the right is enhanced by perhaps the best green on the course due to the two-tiers. I still felt it needed another bunker.
Another mid-length par 3 with an excellent tilted green follows. Much like four, I wished I could play this more than once. The bunkering around the green is very good and visually this is another attractive hole.
The fourteenth is another short par 4 of 363/353 going to the left but with trees blocking the line into the green if one goes too far right. It is a better hole than many of the other short par 4’s due to the trees cutting into the fairway as well as a left to right sloped green.
Finally, another mid-length par 4 of 406/392 dogleg left to an uphill green with two fronting bunkers. I felt this to be the second-best non-par 3 on the golf course.
A dogleg left par 4 follows but this is a longer one at 452/439 which plays at least a club longer due to the uphill green. It is an excellent green sloping back to front. I found this to be the best and hardest hole on the golf course other than the first.
Seventeen is a dogleg right at 378/368 with a large tree. This is another uphill hole so it requires at least a club more into the green.
The Blue ends with a lovely dogleg left par 4 of 418/383 with yet another uphill green. It completes an excellent stretch of holes on the back nine from thirteen into the finish.
Two holes could be lengthened on the back nine. The fifteenth could have the tee placed between the sixth green and fourteenth green. However, doing so would change the nature of the hole and it would play straight and the hole is already 400 yards. Perhaps the tenth tee could be shifted to make the twelfth longer. However, on the back nine, as many of the holes play uphill, the short total yardage is not as noticeable. Yet one cannot help but notice how many short par 4’s there are on both courses.
Between the Red and Blue courses, I felt the back nine of the Blue to be the best nine holes.
I have mixed feelings about The Berkshire. I wish both courses could find another 250-400 yards of additional length and add a few bunkers both at the some of the greens and in the fairways. Perhaps both courses need to convert two of the par 5’s into par 4’s. I really like both courses and recommend them to Americans who are looking for another course to play in the London area without moving hotels. I think so highly of both courses that I wish I could consider them in the same league as Sunningdale, Walton Heath, Swinley Forest, etc. I enjoy the day so much at The Berkshire that I want to discuss these courses in the same breath as the other nearby greats. But I cannot because for the better players or for a player of average length but with a good short game, they lack adequate challenge. A player does not have enough holes where one considers alternatives as to how to best play the hole. The lack of length and inadequate defense makes the holes straightforward and do not do enough justice to the greens. I would like to see more holes with a chance for more decision-making to get from the tee to the green.
On the other hand, if both courses were more compelling, the club might be overwhelmed with additional visitor play. Both courses certainly are good as they are and the members can be very proud of both courses.
I read other reviews that stated that one should play here before the three “W” courses (I am assuming Worplesdon, Woking and West Hill), but I would add to that Wentworth as well. For me, playing both of these courses at The Berkshire on the same day is a superior day to one round at those courses, or two rounds on the West and East at Wentworth, even if those courses might be superior. In sum, The Berkshire is never a grind: it is always fun. Mr. Fowler created yet again two wonderful golf courses. He is often an under-appreciated golf course architect.
As I said, a day at The Berkshire is a splendid day of golf.
Golf courses have to cater for their members: they aren’t always designed to be as hard as possible. Maybe, just maybe, the club and its members don’t want a couple more 450 yd par 4s. Maybe they are happy with the current mix.
The Berkshire for me is nothing short of golfing heaven. Perhaps especially now with the tree and undergrowth clearance the views on the blue have really been opened up so that there are stunning heathland backdrops everywhere you look. This stunning and natural look feels completely undisturbed and gives that otherworldly peaceful feeling to The Berkshire. In this respect I personally rank it as superior to Sunningdale. Sunningdale old for instance, the famous stretch from 4-7 has a bit of an English Garden feel to it, especially with houses on looking on 6,2,1 and 7, plus is intersected by roads and public footpaths. It doesn't have to my eye quite the same effect as The Berkshire. The Blue is short but easily tough enough, except to scratch long hitters, and a great test for short game with small well protected greens which take great pleasure in kicking balls off them! There are some great short holes such as 7 where unless you really place your first shot very well you will have a devil of a second shot... much tougher than the short yardage dogleg suggests on first viewing. It is stunning hole after stunning hole - difficult to pick highlights. The par 3 4th and 13th are amazing short holes. As a recent reviewer said the Par 5 11th whilst short does not feel it because going for green in 2 is risky but laying up can get you in to trouble too and leave you with an awkward yardage for your 3rd. I played it after an extremely wet month and a half and the greens were still hard fast and true and the course spongy. Golfing heaven is The Berkshire!
Very little difference between Red and Blue, (Red shades it as there is more variety through its unusual configuration of 6 of each of par 3s, 4s and 5s.). In terms of which is the best 36 hole offering in the area (excluding Wentorth), I would say that both courses at Walton Heath and comfortably the 2 Sunningdale courses are superior. In saying that however, it is a lovely course and worth a trip.
The Blue course is again a fantastic heathland golf course at the Berkshire but I can't say its quite as good as the Red. Despite that, its far from shabby and still deservedly finds its way in the top 100 courses in GB&I. This is truly a great 36 hole venue and I think members here should count themselves extremely lucky and be grateful to have 2 such cracking golf courses right in front of them. The blue just like the red is maintained very well, the greens were rolling well although were a bit slower and sandier than the red, but the bunkers and fairways were equally as good.
The 1st is a great but tough starting hole and a beautiful par 3 with heather all the way up to the green. The 4th is a much easier par 3 being much shorter and equally as beautiful with bunkers short and right and heather all short of the green. This hole made me very reminiscent of the great par 3s at West Sussex and the sharp design of the bunkers. To be honest other than the 1st and 4th holes, the front nine wasn't quite as exciting as the red course and although all the holes were still great, I wouldn't label them as outstanding.
The back nine of the blue gets a lot better and really picks up the pace as you start out with a beautiful short downhill par 3 with water on the right. The 11th then goes towards the red course and I felt that the holes were better when we were closer to the red course. The 11th was a great par 5, very much a risk and reward hole where you could go for it in 2 but risk hitting driver into the ditch or going into the bunkers surrounded by the green. The 12th is then a 350 yard par 4 with a lovely look to it and is parallel to the par 3 7th on the red course. The 13th is probably my favourite hole on the blue course as its a spectacular short par 3. Don't go left on this hole as it then becomes a very challenging up and down. The 14th and 15th are 2 par 4s that are both fairly difficult. On 14 the drive is difficult but important as right leaves you with no shot into the green. The 15th requires a good approach shot as its easy to miss the green and get into trouble that way. The 16th is probably the toughest hole on the course, a 450 yard par 4 with a fairway bunker on the left as well plenty of heather and a ditch further up. The last 2 holes are fairly straight forward on the blue but a nice way to finish.
Overall I would say the blue is slightly harder as there are less par 5s which makes it harder to score. I would also say its harder due to the fact that there seems to be more trouble and there are more fairway bunkers to go in on this course. Either way the blue course is still a joy to play and The Berkshire truly is a special place. A 36 hole day is nothing short of special at this place. The blue course is definitely a respectable 5 ball rating.
It’s been said before, and will no doubt be again, but the Berkshire experience is only in part about the golf courses. The other part is about the 18 hole putting green, a net with a slope to bring your ball back to your feet, a rather pleasant chipping green. And the food. 18 in the morning, a three course lunch, with wine or beer and then the worry of what the opening shot on the 1st on the Blue course will do. Mine sailed over the heather, over the gully and trickled onto the green. All was good in the world.
The courses are of course good. After an apparently difficult summer and autumn they are getting back to what they should be. It’s also worth noting that neither course is what I’d describe as heroic; I’m not sure they can be and keep a membership happy. Thus while getting a good score requires some big carries there’s generally an escape route for the shorter hitters. But do be straight, the heather, though not horribly woody is still a challenge. Go beyond the heather at your peril.
Apart from a few holes around the turn where the now dual carriageway A322 intrudes with noise, though not really visually, the Berkshire is a peaceful experience. You play many holes in glorious solitude. And as another bit of class the halfway house, sensibly provided at a point where the two courses meet, has proper toilets. While male golfers may wish to add to the areas acidity, I suspect female ones don’t.
So do go, but go for the day.
Like its sister course is in great condition . Plays very fair but beware of the heather again . Superb tree lined course well worth a visit although it's not particularly cheap.
A full day of golf (and lunch) at The Berkshire is one of life’s little luxuries and definitely worth saving up for.
I played both courses on the European Amateur Golf Tour so not only did I get to experience both courses in their best condition but also under competitive conditions.
I had previously played the Blue course many years ago so it was nice to be reacquainted with this excellent layout that enjoys some delightful holes, especially on the back nine, and makes a more than solid partner for the superior Red course.
The best holes on the front nine of the Blue are the opening par three, played over a heroic carry of heather, and the tricky short par four ninth where an approach from 100 yards is often preferable to one from much closer to the lofty green. The holes in between are all solid and require plenty of thought and positional play but lack the undulating ground that the rest of the course has and which brings it alive.
The run of holes from the 11th onwards are really what define the Blue in my eye. They are all energetic holes and there is more going on over this closing stretch than what has gone before it. The 11th is a lovely s-shaped par five whilst the next is one of few holes on the entire property that is played across a side slope and also has a fascinating two-tiered green; high at the front and low at the back.
Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.
Having taken my society there for the past 2 years playing at the Berkshire can only be described as a golfers paradise. The greens are pure, the heather is thick but forgiving, the fairways are cut to perfection and most importantly, you feel like you in a world of your own for the day. Playing as part of a society we are looked after as good as we could hope for and the 3 course carvary, keeps my mouth salivating for the 12 months in between rounds.
In my opinion this rates above all three Wentworth courses and Sunningdale, I can't wait to get back again this July.
The beauty of this site is all about opinions. This is an interesting view expressed and one that I am very curious to know how it was reached. The Berkshire is a fine club with two very good golf courses but I struggle to see that it rates above Wentworth or Sunningdale. I don't like the changes to the West but the East (hopefully one day renovated so everyone can enjoy the Colt gem it is) and the Edinburgh are excellent courses - one long, one shortish ; one old-school design, one new etc. Sunningdale - Old and New have all the qualities you ascribe to the Berkshire in spades (conditioning, beauty , playability) and no road intruding behind a green. Curious to know whether this reviewer has ever played Swinley Forest and how he/she would rate it against the Blue. Sunningdale being a Surrey club, Swinley Forest is no 1 in Berkshire in my view.
I respect the opinion offered here, but beg to differ. This is one of two fine courses on the property, but the challenge and variety here could not, for me, remotely match that at Sunningdale, let alone rate above it. To take two examples, can you really rate the appalling redesign of the 10th here above the 5th on the New at Sunningdale, as brilliant a short hole as exists in the UK? Is the 17th here, where perhaps a third of the fairway is in play, really a hole to remotely match the outstanding dogleg right 15th on the New, with the wickedly positioned pond for the slightest cut? Can't see it myself.
James, you point about the 10th is spot on. When it was built a couple of years ago, the club went to great lengths to boast about how it was a wonderful addition to the course but it has ruined the place. It has absolutely no respect for Fowler's architecture. The green is completely alien. The swales are straight out of a Pittsburgh municipal. The bunker is even worse than that. I played there a month ago whilst in the U.K. They have removed the tacky heather beds on the hills but that is a tweak of the look whilst the core architecture is horrific. I always thought the Blue to be a wonderful test of strategic golf. To add to this mistake, they have added in a back tee on 18 that defies belief. I don't know of any Fowler strategy that includes only being able to see half the fairway and they have forgotten that there is a big cross ditch at the point of landing (for mortals like me anyway). i asked a few questions when I was there and bumped into a member who knew a huge amount about Fowler and the history of the place. Turns out that they fired the architect that screwed up 10 but have brought in a guy called Lobb, who is a new build guy.
As the original reviewer, I appreciate all of the comments on the above, maybe i had been slightly Naive in my comments after returning last year. Whilst no doubt I cannot wait to return again this year, we had a small problem with the members last year, being put out behind a couple of 4-balls of members, we ended up having a 5 and a half hour round.
I stand by my comments about this in comparison to Wentworth, but would retract my Sunningdale comments. I was fortunate to play Swinley last September and completely fell in love as that sits on a different level to The Berkshire.
This is still without a doubt, one of the countries elite establishments for a day of golf in luxury, and anyone who get's the chance should take it in a heartbeat. Once the stuffiness of the older members disappears, this will be on my target list for membership.
A bit harsh, but I agree with all that. The problem on the 10th was thinned shots from the (late lamented) front-right bunker ending up on the A322 - a calamity and a big lawsuit were waiting to happen. But it's a very good golf course.