Founded in 1911, the Country Club of Orlando is one of the oldest country clubs in Florida and their old Donald Ross-designed course has undergone a number of renovations down the years... But was Donald Ross really the architect?
Overall rating
4.5



The Country Club of Orlando
Founded in 1911, the Country Club of Orlando is one of the oldest country clubs in Florida and their old Donald Ross-designed course has undergone a number of renovations down the years... But was Donald Ross really the architect?



Course Architect
View ProfileCourse Architect
Donald Ross worked with Old Tom Morris at St Andrews in 1893 then spent part of the following season at Carnoustie before returning to serve under the Dornoch club secretary John Sutherland.
Donald James Ross was born in 1872 to Murdoch Ross, a stone mason by trade, and his wife Lillian Campbell. Their first child had died soon after birth that same year so Donald became the eldest in the family, followed in subsequent years by three brothers and two sisters.
Course Architect
View ProfileCourse Architect
Robert Trent Jones arrived in New York aboard the steamship Caronia from Liverpool on Monday, 29th April 1912, exactly two weeks after the Titanic had sunk on her maiden voyage across the Atlantic.
Robert Trent Jones arrived in New York harbor aboard the steamship Caronia from the port of Liverpool on Monday, 29th April 1912, exactly two weeks after the Titanic had sunk on her maiden voyage across the Atlantic. He, along with his mother and younger brother, was soon reunited with his father who had arrived nine months earlier to work as a carpenter with the New York Central Railroad building freight cars in Rochester.
Course Architect
View ProfileCourse Architect
Bendelow worked with A.G. Spalding designing inexpensive golf courses to build and maintain, thus enabling Spalding’s golf equipment business to rapidly expand nationally.
Tom Bendelow was raised in Aberdeen, one of nine children born to John Bendelow and Mary Edwards, and he learned how to play the game with his father on the old Kings Links near the city centre. He trained as a typesetter and worked on the Aberdeen Free Press before marrying the daughter of a local farmer, Mary Ann Nicol, then emigrating to America in 1892, with his wife and daughter following a year later.
Course Architect
The latest ranking of the Top 100 Golf Courses in the World serves as the ultimate global golf bucket list. Most members of our World Top 100 Panel are seasoned golfers, each playing 20-30 of these courses annually while travelling extensively over decades to form their opinions on others. We recognise that opinions vary—even among our panel members. Rankings are subjective, and there are undoubtedly 50 or more courses in the UK and USA alone that could easily fit onto this list. Links Golf Pilgrimages The rankings
California, United States
New Jersey, United States
Northern Ireland, United Kingdom
New York, United States
New York, United States

While some of the world's most famous courses command eye-watering green fees, there are often excellent alternatives just a short drive away. From celebrated links venues to championship layouts, we've picked out 10 famous golf courses and their more affordable neighbours, where you can still enjoy a quality round without paying quite so much. Pebble Beach Golf Links vs Pacific Grove Golf Links (California, USA) Pebble Beach Golf Links | World Ranking: 27th | California Ranking: 3rd | Green Fees: US$755 (including mandatory cart fee) Pacific Grove Golf Links | California Ranking: 71st | Green Fees: US$66–89 Few golf courses command the same level of recognition as Pebble Beach Golf Links. Ranked 27th in the world, it has hosted multiple US Opens and is a regular fixture on the PGA Tour, with its spectacular Pacific coastline making it one of the game's most recognisable settings. At US$755 for a visitor round, however, it comes at a considerable price. Just five miles away, Pacific Grove Golf Links offers a much more affordable way to enjoy the same stretch of California coastline. Often nicknamed the 'Poor Man's Pebble Beach', this municipal course has plenty of character of its own, with its history closely connected to its famous neighbour. Chandler Egan, who helped redesign Pebble Beach alongside Alister MacKenzie, laid out Pacific Grove's original nine holes in 1932, before Jack Neville, one of Pebble Beach's original designers, extended it to 18. The front nine winds through gardens and trees, while the back nine opens up towards the Pacific Ocean and Point Pinos Lighthouse. With green fees from US$66, it's a considerably cheaper way to enjoy golf on the Monterey Peninsula. Distance apart: 5 miles Price difference: US$666–689 (88–91% cheaper at Pacific Grove) St Andrews Links – Old Course vs St Andrews Links – Eden Course (Scotland) St Andrews Links (Old) | World Ranking: 7th | Scotland Ranking: 1st | Green Fees: £380 St Andrews Links (Eden) | Scotland Ranking: 62nd | Green Fees: £85 Few golf courses carry the reputation of the Old Course at St Andrews. Ranked seventh in the world, it is the Home of Golf and one of the most recognisable venues in the game, but securing a tee time can be just as challenging as finding the money for its £380 high-season green fee in 2027. A much more affordable option is the Eden Course, just west of the Old Course and ranked 62nd in Scotland. Designed by Harry Colt and opened in 1914, it offers a genuine links experience for a fraction of the price. Its wide fairways provide some room off the tee, but deep bunkers, undulating greens and several challenging par fours ensure there is plenty to think about. At £85 for a high-season round in 2027, the Eden is an appealing way to enjoy the Home of Golf without paying Old Course prices. Distance apart: Approximately 1 mile Price difference: £295 (around 78% cheaper at the Eden) Royal County Down – Championship Course vs Ardglass Golf Club (Northern Ireland) Royal County Down (Championship) | World Ranking: 3rd | Northern Ireland Ranking: 1st | Green Fees: £495 Ardglass Golf Club | Northern Ireland Ranking: 8th | Green Fees: £275 Royal County Down is a bucket-list destination for golfers, ranked third in the world and set against the spectacular backdrop of the Mountains of Mourne. Its Championship course is a formidable links test, with rugged dunes, blind drives and some of the most memorable holes in the game. A visitor round costs £495 in 2027, and tee-time availability is exceptionally limited. Around 11 miles away, Ardglass offers a different but equally memorable experience along the County Down coastline. The opening five holes hug the cliffs above the Irish Sea, with the second a particularly striking par three played across a rocky inlet. The course also has a clubhouse with a rather unusual history: it occupies a 14th-century castle. Ardglass may not have the same global reputation as its famous neighbour, but its dramatic coastal setting and enjoyable links test make it well worth adding to a trip to the area. At £275, it also represents a sizeable saving. Distance apart: Approximately 11 miles (straight-line) Price difference: £220 (44% cheaper at Ardglass) Royal Portrush Golf Club – Dunluce Course vs Castlerock Golf Club – Mussenden Course (Northern Ireland) Royal Portrush Golf Club (Dunluce) | World Ranking: 9th | Northern Ireland Ranking: 2nd | Green Fees: £475 Castlerock Golf Club (Mussenden) | Northern Ireland Ranking: 5th | Green Fees: £250 Royal Portrush is one of the biggest names in Irish golf, ranked ninth in the world and twice the host of The Open Championship, most recently in 2025. The Dunluce Links is a spectacular test, with its dramatic coastal setting and memorable holes, including the famous par-three 16th, Calamity. At £475 for a visitor round, it is also one of the more expensive places to play in Northern Ireland. Around 13 miles along the coast, Castlerock's Mussenden Course offers an excellent alternative for £250. It may live in the shadow of its more famous neighbours, but it is a highly regarded links in its own right, with a strong reputation among golfers who have made the trip to the Causeway Coast. The standout is the fourth, known as Leg O’Mutton, a 200-yard par three with a railway line running alongside one side and a burn guarding the other. Castlerock also has views across the Atlantic towards Donegal and, on a clear day, Scotland. Distance apart: Approximately 13 miles by road Price difference: £225 (47% cheaper at Castlerock) Carnoustie Golf Links – Championship Course vs Panmure Golf Club (Scotland) Carnoustie Golf Links (Championship) | World Ranking: 34th | Scotland Ranking: 5th | Green Fees: £450 Panmure Golf Club | Scotland Ranking: 35th | Green Fees: £195 Carnoustie is one of the most famous and demanding tests in Scottish golf. Ranked fifth in Scotland and 34th in the world, its Championship course has hosted The Open eight times, most recently in 2018, when Francesco Molinari lifted the Claret Jug. A peak-season visitor round in 2027 costs £450. Just a short drive away, Panmure provides a similarly challenging links experience for considerably less. Ranked 35th in Scotland, it has plenty of history of its own, having hosted Open Qualifying and played a part in Ben Hogan's preparation for his 1953 Open Championship victory at Carnoustie. Hogan spent two weeks practising at Panmure before winning at his neighbouring course, and the club still celebrates that connection. The layout features plenty of traditional links character, with heather, hillocks and demanding approach shots. At £195 during the 2026 peak season, it is an appealing option for anyone planning a golf trip to Angus & Dundee. Distance apart: Approximately 5 miles by road Price difference: £255 (57% cheaper at Panmure) Pinehurst No. 2 vs Southern Pines Golf Club (North Carolina, USA) Pinehurst No. 2 | World Ranking: 57th | North Carolina Ranking: 2nd | Green Fees: Not published Southern Pines Golf Club | North Carolina Ranking: 11th | Green Fees: US$225–245 Pinehurst No. 2 is one of American golf's most celebrated courses. Ranked 57th in the world and second in North Carolina, the Donald Ross design has hosted multiple US Opens, most recently in 2024, and will welcome the championship back in 2029. Playing it, however, requires more than simply booking a tee time. Access is reserved for resort guests and members, with a minimum two-night stay required for those booking through the resort. Around five miles away, Southern Pines Golf Club offers a more accessible way to experience the area's golfing heritage. Another Donald Ross design, it opened in 1906 and has retained much of its traditional character, with rolling fairways, sandy waste areas and greens that demand careful approach play. It is ranked 11th in North Carolina and welcomes public play, with visitor fees ranging from US$225 to US$245. It may not carry the same prestige as Pinehurst No. 2, but it is a worthwhile addition to any trip to the Sandhills. Distance apart: Approximately 5 miles Price difference: Not directly comparable – Pinehurst No. 2 requires a resort stay or membership, while Southern Pines has a published visitor green fee. TPC Sawgrass – Stadium Course vs St Johns Golf Club (Florida, USA) TPC Sawgrass (Stadium) | USA Ranking: 66th | Florida Ranking: 2nd | Green Fees: From US$775 St Johns Golf Club | Green Fees: US$41–53.50 TPC Sawgrass is one of the most recognisable venues in American golf. Ranked 66th in the United States and second in Florida, its Stadium Course has hosted THE PLAYERS Championship since 1982 and is best known for the island green 17th. Designed by Pete and Alice Dye, it is a bucket-list round for many golfers, but visitor fees start at US$775 during the September-to-May season. Around 27 miles away, St Johns Golf Club provides a far more affordable alternative. This public, county-owned course in Elkton offers 18 holes of golf for out-of-state visitors at $53.50 in the morning, with afternoon rates dropping to $41. It is a different proposition to the Stadium Course, but the layout has recently benefited from a redesign by Erik Larsen and offers a varied test for golfers of all abilities. For anyone visiting the Jacksonville area, it is a practical option for fitting in a round without paying the premium associated with TPC Sawgrass. Distance apart: Approximately 27 miles by road Price difference: US$721.50–734 (93–95% cheaper at St Johns, comparing TPC's September–May starting rate with St Johns' 2026 out-of-state rates) Royal St George's Golf Club vs Prince's Golf Club – Dunes & Himalayas (England) Royal St George's Golf Club | World Ranking: 19th | England Ranking: 1st | Green Fees: £430 Prince's Golf Club (Dunes & Himalayas) | England Ranking: 32nd | Green Fees: £180–230 Royal St George's is one of the most recognisable names in English golf. Ranked 19th in the world and first in England, the Sandwich links has hosted The Open 15 times, most recently in 2021. Its undulating fairways, towering dunes and famously deep bunkers make it a formidable test, with peak-season visitor fees reaching £430 in 2027. Almost next door, Prince's offers a more affordable way to enjoy links golf on the same stretch of Kent coastline. It hosted The Open in 1932, when Gene Sarazen claimed victory, and remains a highly regarded venue in its own right. The Himalayas nine is particularly varied, with wetland carries, a driveable par four and a double green among its features. Prince's has 27 holes across three nine-hole loops, allowing visitors to combine the Himalayas with either the Dunes or Shore to make an 18-hole round. At £180–230 in 2027, it costs considerably less than its famous neighbour. Distance apart: Approximately 1 mile Price difference: £200–250 (47–58% cheaper at Prince's) Bandon Dunes Golf Resort – Pacific Dunes vs Bandon Crossings (Oregon, USA) Bandon Dunes (Pacific Dunes) | World Ranking: 26th | Oregon Ranking: 1st | Green Fees: US$425 Bandon Crossings | Oregon Ranking: 21st | Green Fees: US$70–96 Pacific Dunes is one of the standout courses at Bandon Dunes Golf Resort, ranked 26th in the world and among the most celebrated public-access layouts in the United States. Tom Doak's design opened in 2001 and makes full use of its rugged Pacific coastline, with several holes playing directly alongside the ocean. It is an unforgettable experience, but a peak-season round for a day guest costs US$425 in 2027. Around 10 miles south, Bandon Crossings offers a much more affordable alternative. Built on an old cattle and sheep ranch, the course was designed by Oregon architect Dan Hixson and takes a different approach to the area's golf, with a heathland-style layout rather than a traditional coastal links. It is not trying to compete directly with the resort's famous courses, but provides an enjoyable and considerably cheaper round, with the added option of taking a cart. Its 2026 standard-time walking rate is US$70, rising to US$96 during daylight-saving time. Distance apart: Approximately 10 miles Price difference: US$329–355 (77–84% cheaper at Bandon Crossings, comparing Pacific Dunes' 2027 peak-season day-guest rate with Bandon Crossings' 2026 walking rates) Royal Melbourne Golf Club – West Course vs Sandy Golf Links (Melbourne, Australia) Royal Melbourne Golf Club (West) | World Ranking: 6th | Australia Ranking: 1st | Green Fees: Not published (Last indicative international visitor rate AU$850) Sandy Golf Links | Australia Ranking: 82nd | Green Fees: AU$70–76 Royal Melbourne's West Course is ranked sixth in the world and first in Australia, and is widely regarded as one of Alister MacKenzie's finest designs. It is a private members' club, although international golfers who belong to a recognised golf club can apply for visitor tee times. The indicative overseas visitor fee is around A$850, although the club does not publish its rates publicly. Less than a mile away, Sandy Golf Links provides an opportunity to experience Melbourne's famous Sandbelt without the same price tag or access restrictions. Formerly known as Sandringham Golf Course, the public facility was extensively redesigned by OCM Golf, the team of Geoff Ogilvy, Mike Cocking and Ashley Mead, and reopened in its current form in 2020. The par-65 layout features firm greens, strategic bunkering and the sandy terrain associated with the region. It is ranked 82nd in Australia and welcomes public bookings, with 18 holes costing A$70 on weekdays and A$76 at weekends. Distance apart: Approximately 1km Price difference: A$774–780 (91–92% cheaper at Sandy, based on Royal Melbourne's indicative A$850 visitor fee) Green fees reflect published high-season visitor rates for 2027 where available. Where 2027 rates have not yet been released, the latest available published rates are provided. Prices and visitor access are subject to change.

Florida is one of the world's great golf destinations, but its reputation for championship courses and high-end resorts can make it seem like a difficult place for beginners to start. It doesn't have to be. Across the state, you'll find short municipal layouts, forgiving designs, affordable daily-fee courses and practice facilities that make it easier to learn the game without being overwhelmed. Some offer a gentle introduction to 18 holes, while others provide a chance to experience famous golf venues from more manageable tees. We've picked some of the best options for beginners, looking at factors including length, difficulty, green fees, accessibility and the overall experience. Whether you're playing your first full round or simply looking for a Florida course where you can enjoy the game without needing a low handicap, these are the courses worth putting on your list. The Park West Palm Why play it: Golf for everyone, with plenty of ways to learn and practice Difficulty: ★★☆☆☆ Price: From $95 Best for: Beginners looking to learn and improve The Park is a particularly good introduction to golf for beginners because it offers plenty of ways to learn the game before committing to 18 holes. Alongside the full-length course is a Toptracer driving range, putting course and the Lit 9, a nine-hole par-three layout that can be played with little more than a wedge and putter. The 18-hole course itself was completely rebuilt by Hanse Golf Course Design, replacing Dick Wilson's original 1947 West Palm Beach layout with a new routing. The real appeal, however, is the club's approach to growing the game. Green fees for juniors registered as West Palm Beach city residents are just $20, while carts are not permitted before noon and caddies are actively encouraged. The Lit 9 costs $30 for adults and is free for children aged 12 and under, providing an inexpensive way to get on the course without tackling 18 holes. The Park has even hosted The Match IX, but despite welcoming stars such as Rory McIlroy, Max Homa, Lexi Thompson and Rose Zhang, its focus remains firmly on making golf accessible to everyone. Southern Dunes Golf & Country Club Why play it: A links-inspired layout where everything is laid out in front of you Length: 6,220 yards - Par 72 Difficulty: ★★★☆☆ Price: From $49 Best for: Beginners ready for a full-length challenge Southern Dunes offers a gentler introduction to championship-style golf than its 7,227-yard black-tee length might suggest. Designed by Steve Smyers in 1993, the course uses a sandy, undulating site and extensive mounding to create a links-like feel, with huge traditional bunkers, wispy waste areas and occasional water hazards shaping the holes. There are five sets of tees, with the shortest full course measuring 5,633 yards, giving beginners the option to leave the driver in the bag and play a manageable yardage. The appeal is that there are few surprises around Southern Dunes. The fairways, hazards and greens are generally laid out in front of you, allowing beginners to see the challenge and plot their way around rather than having to guess what lies ahead. The large, fast greens and rolling fairways still demand good putting and accuracy, but choose the right tees and Southern Dunes becomes a fair test rather than an intimidating one. Located in Haines City, just south of Orlando, it also offers an unusual taste of links-style golf in Central Florida. Orange County National – Panther Lake Course Why play it: A huge golf facility where beginners can build confidence before tackling 18 holes Length: 6,002 yards - Par 72 Difficulty: ★★★☆☆ Price: From $75 Best for: Beginners who want a full golf experience Orange County National is built around golf, with 45 holes, a 42-acre circular driving range, a 36-hole putting course and the nine-hole Tooth course all on the same sprawling property. For beginners, that means there are plenty of ways to practice before taking on Panther Lake, whether that means working on the range, spending time on the putting course or starting with nine holes. Panther Lake itself opened in 1997 and was designed by Phil Ritson, Isao Aoki and David Harman, with the rolling site providing some of the elevation change that is unusual for Florida. At more than 7,400 yards from the tips, Panther Lake is certainly not short, but the multiple tee options allow beginners to choose a yardage suited to their game. The course is set across more than 900 acres with no surrounding housing, creating a remarkably open and peaceful setting despite being a short drive from Orlando. With its extensive practice facilities and two championship courses, Orange County National gives beginners plenty of room to practise before working their way up to Panther Lake. Juliette Falls Golf Course Why play it: A scenic, strategic course with plenty of tee options Length: 6,269 yards - Par 72 Difficulty: ★★★☆☆ Price: From $70 Best for: Beginners ready to step up to a full-length course Juliette Falls proves that beginner-friendly golf doesn't have to mean giving up on scenery or ambition. John Sanford's 2007 design stretches to more than 7,200 yards from the back tees, but five sets of tees allow newer golfers to choose a more manageable distance. The layout winds through mature oak trees and the former phosphate-mining site, with generous corridors and clear angles of play making it possible to see the strategy of each hole before deciding how aggressively to play it. The course becomes particularly dramatic from the sixth hole, where the par five requires a tee shot over Reflection Lake, followed by the tropical landscaping and waterfall at the par-three seventh. Water is a recurring feature, but the hazards are generally visible rather than hidden, rewarding beginners who take the sensible route rather than chasing distance. With its rolling terrain, mature trees and four waterfalls, Juliette Falls offers a more substantial challenge while remaining accessible to golfers who choose the right tees. North Palm Beach Country Club Why play it: A forgiving Nicklaus design with plenty of room off the tee Length: 5,932 yards - Par 71 Difficulty: ★★☆☆☆ Price: From $60 Best for: Beginners who want a forgiving 18-hole course North Palm Beach Country Club is a good option for beginners who want to play a proper 18-hole course without being punished for every wayward drive. Redesigned by Jack Nicklaus in 2006, the course measures just under 7,100 yards from the back tees, but Nicklaus specifically designed it to be user-friendly from the member and senior tees. The first 180 to 200 yards from those tees are particularly wide, giving newer golfers plenty of room to find the fairway and build confidence off the tee. The course sits on a sandy site of less than 125 acres, with several lakes adding strategy without overwhelming the layout. Nicklaus also described the greens as having plenty of movement, giving beginners a chance to work on their short game as they progress. There is some history here, too: the original course dates to the late 1920s and was one of the final designs by Seth Raynor before Nicklaus gave the layout a new lease of life. In 2006, it became only the second Nicklaus Signature municipal course in the USA. Dye’s Valley at TPC Sawgrass Why play it: A chance to experience TPC Sawgrass without taking on the Stadium Course Length: 6,079 yards - Par 72 Difficulty: ★★★☆☆ Price: From $350 Best for: Beginners ready for a taste of championship golf Dye’s Valley offers beginners a chance to experience the TPC Sawgrass setting without immediately throwing them into the deep end of the Stadium Course. Designed by Pete Dye with Bobby Weed and player consultant Jerry Pate, the course stretches to around 6,850 yards but is less demanding from the forward tees. Water remains a major part of the challenge, lining many holes, although there are fewer forced carries than on its famous neighbour. The course opened in 1987, five years after Pate won The Players Championship and famously celebrated by dunking Dye in a nearby lake. There is still plenty of Dye’s trademark strategy here, with water, bunkering and demanding greens requiring golfers to think their way around the course. For beginners, however, the shorter length and variety of tee options make Dye’s Valley a more approachable way to experience one of American golf’s best-known venues. Winter Park Pines Golf Club Why play it: A short, affordable 18-hole course where beginners can leave the driver in the bag Length: 5,107 yards - Par 70 Difficulty: ★★☆☆☆ Price: From $45 Best for: Beginners looking for an affordable full round Winter Park Pines is a reminder that beginners don't need 7,000 yards to get a proper 18-hole golf experience. The Lloyd Clifton-designed course opened in 1968 and measures just 5,354 yards from the back tees, with forward tees bringing it down to 4,336 yards. The layout features five par threes and three par fives, while the relatively short par fours give newer golfers plenty of opportunities to reach the greens without relying on their longest clubs. Water is a recurring feature, including a creek that runs through the property, so there are still hazards to negotiate despite the modest yardage. But the course is designed to provide a test for both novices and more experienced golfers, with a driving range and practice greens available before the round. Best of all, non-resident green fees start at just $45 on weekdays during the summer, making Winter Park Pines one of the more affordable ways to play 18 holes in the Orlando area. Palm Beach Par 3 Golf Course Why play it: A spectacular 18-hole introduction to golf with every hole within reach Length: 2,572 yards - Par 54 Difficulty: ★★☆☆☆ Price: From $35 Best for: Beginners who want to learn the game without a full-length course Palm Beach Par 3 strips golf back to its essentials, with 18 holes ranging from just 81 to 211 yards. Set between the Atlantic Ocean and Intracoastal Waterway, the course gives beginners a chance to experience a full round without needing the distance or consistency required on a traditional par 72. Each hole has three sets of tees, while water hazards and sand bunkers provide plenty of challenges without turning every missed shot into a lost ball. The course dates back to 1961, when it was designed by Dick Wilson and his apprentice Joe Lee, before being completely redesigned by Hall of Famer Raymond Floyd in 2009. Alongside the ocean views, golfers have access to a full-length driving range, putting green and practice bunker, making it possible to work on the basics before taking on the course. For beginners, it is an affordable and unusually scenic way to get 18 holes under the belt.

I is for ISLAND THE ORIGINAL A green surrounded by water is not a new concept. In fact, even the denizens of the Golden Age of golf course architecture occasionally surrounded the putting area with liquid hazard. The truest grasp on the concept of the “Island” template begins with No. 9 at Ponte Vedra (what is now known as the Ocean Course at Ponte Vedra Inn & Club). Herbert Strong completed the Ponte Vedra Club in 1928, and it was apparent he intended to test the mettle of the game’s best with dramatic greens and demanding hero shots... much like a nearby course to-be-named-soon. Like that other course, Ponte Vedra featured a Par 3 green set upon an island in a lagoon, 145 yards from the tee. The hole was originally No. 18, and upon walking off, Bobby Jones commented that Ponte Vedra “[is] a course to challenge professionals.” Ponte Vedra Ocean course 9th hole - photo courtesy of Ponte Vedra Inn & Club This original island held far more than a green; three pot bunkers (more were added later) fitted along the back of the putting surface, and a larger one sat front-right. There was even an apron of fairway...but too much spin could easily bring a short shot back down into the water. It seems like a generous target today, but after the shell-shock of playing one of America’s then-toughest courses, it may have intimidated even the best. OTHER INTERPRETATIONS We have already alluded to another Florida course that would become the standard for the “Island” template, the infamous No. 17 on the Stadium course at TPC Sawgrass. Pete Dye had a pit to fill, and legend claims his wife and frequent contributor, Alice Dye, suggested just placing a green in the middle of the future lake. No doubt the pair took inspiration from Strong’s work at the nearby coastal course. The Stadium course was created with the intention of hosting The Players Championship, and players immediately set upon its design for its over-the-top greens. TPC Sawgrass Stadium course 17th hole - photo courtesy of TPC Sawgrass No. 17, however, was not a challenge because of its size or slopes. It plays at 137 yards, a simple wedge for most players. At 78 feet in length, the green is much smaller than Ponte Vedra’s version, but hardly a tiny target. The challenge is solely of the nerves, knowing the lake will take all misses. Based on its 7% double-bogey percentage at The Players, this factor impacts pros almost as much as everyday players. It is perhaps the most pure rendition of “target golf.” The island is not quite a black-or-white equation, however. As with many penal holes, there is an element of matchplay risk/reward: Playing to the center of the green is always safe, and attacking the pin is—more often than not—dangerous. A strong backbone goes a long way in saving par, but strong conviction goes a long way in winning the hole. Granted, the “Island” concept is still rather binary for the mid-handicapper, which alienates some critics. Not helping the template’s cause is its appeal for the tourist crowd, a group that instantly appreciates the visual appeal of an island, versus the more subtle strategic pleasures of, say, a Double Plateau. In some cases, this leads to kitschy entries, à la the fruit-shaped No. 17 green at Apple Tree Golf Course. Although the Coeur D’Alene Resort built some tourist appeal (and excess round lengths) into its Island Par 3, via the necessary boat taxi to the green, it also created an interesting element for potential multi-day tournaments. The No. 14 green floats, and can be maneuvered to land for maintenance purposes, which suggests they could also alter its placement in the lake to change the hole’s identity from day-to-day. It’s essentially the putting surface version of runway tees. Coeur D'Alene 14th hole - photo courtesy of Coeur D'Alene Resort One hole that often gets overlooked in the “Island” conversation is The Creek Club’s 11th hole. The only real expectation of the modern “Island” template is a relatively short length, to emphasize nerve and accuracy over power. Geographically, however, the only real requirement of an “Island,” is that the green be surrounded almost entirely by water. Seth Raynor’s No. 11 is indisputably a Biarritz (200 yards and a signature swale), but there’s no reason why it can’t be an “Island” as well. Any template Par 3 could theoretically be adapted to “Island” form. The Creek 11th hole - photo courtesy of The Creek We’re honestly not trying to force MacRaynor into every conversation on templates! MAYBE... MAYBE NOT We stated earlier that many island greens debuted prior to Ponte Vedra’s (including the aforementioned Creek Club). Baltusrol’s Old Course featured one as early as 1910 (it was in play for the 1915 U.S. Open) and A.W. Tillinghast created an island green at Aronimink's No. 13 when he was the first to tweak Donald Ross's original design. The difference between Baltusrol and Aronimink’s entries from that era is that they are not Par 3s. It’s a “simple” distinction, but one that drastically alters the mindset during play. In these cases, the player must eventually cross the water, but they have an option of when to do it. Feeling bold? Go for two. Not so sure, or your tee shot was poor? Lay up. It is a viable risk/reward strategy, allowing players to choose how much distance is included with their forced carry. An “Island” Par 3 is a more predetermined test… ”do or die.” Every player is given the same basic task, even during matchplay. The options that a player may flex on a Par 5 with an island green, or even a Par 4, make the formula different. Famous short Par 5s with island greens—such as No. 17 at Cherry Hills or No. 15 at TPC Scottsdale’s Stadium course—make for exciting play, but they do not fit within our definition of the “Island” as a template. Cherry Hills 17th hole - photo courtesy of Cherry Hills Country Club Interestingly, Tillinghast may have also created the first Par 3 surrounded by water. His “Moat” hole at Galen Hall is a beast: 190 yards to a raised green, which is surrounded by the aforementioned moat, dug by Tillinghast for the purpose. We would argue, however, that despite its Par 3 status, the 15th hole doesn’t quite live up to the “Island” standard, even with the watery surrounds. Because the moat is so thin (compared to a lake), the option exists to lay up short of the moat, and play for par with a short pitch over the hazard. This makes it a shorter version of the Par 4s and 5s we described in the previous paragraph, versus a true “Island” hole in the Strong / Dye sense. Galen Hall 15th hole - photo courtesy of Galen Hall Golf Club David McLay Kidd gave the Ponte Vedra version a spin at Sand Valley’s Mammoth Dunes No. 8, in that there is additional short grass around the green for players to land upon... the catch being that the green itself is about half the size of Mammoth’s other elephantine putting surfaces. The major difference between this and the Strong / Dye version is, of course, the water being replaced with sand. This will surely make for a tough recovery, but it does not result in an automatic loss of a stroke, which dramatically alters the psyches of those teeing off. McLay Kidd intended Mammoth to be the more playable than the Sand Valley course, so we’re sure he won’t mind if that means sacrificing true “Island” status. Mammoth Dunes 8th hole - photo courtesy of Sand Valley