More and more golfers are discovering the great modern courses to be found on either side of the Atlantic border between Portugal and Spain. On the Portuguese side, there are three top notch tracks – Monte Rei, Quinta da Ria and Quinta de Cima – that can more than match any of the Algarve courses west of Faro whilst the Spanish complexes at 27-hole Islantilla and 36-hole El Rompido offer the discerning golfer a further 63 holes of great, value for money, golf.
Situated close to a lovely fishing village and surrounded by the “Paraje Natural Protegido,” the El Rompido golf complex on the Costa de la Luz was opened in 2003 with a highly original, modern and minimalist clubhouse designed by Juan Antonio Foraster and Ana Calderón and an initial 18-hole layout (now called the South course) built to USGA specification.
Three years later, the second 18-hole course at El Rompido came along and this Álvaro Arana creation has surpassed even the very high standards set by its predecessor. Located on more elevated property, the new North course is a fine test, with fairways that are wider and longer than the South course.
On the front nine, the first seven holes skirt the coastal marshland area and there are two tough par fives to tackle at holes 5 and 8, each of which are in excess of 565 yards. The majority of holes on the inward half play a little more inland, but the 153-yard, par three 16th is an exception. Located on the edge of the marsh, the long, narrow green is protected on either side by a pair of coffin bunkers – just be careful this hole doesn’t bring a premature end to a good score on the North course!
A return visit, this time with a regular group of golf tourists. We all thoroughly enjoyed the North course, which was in terrific condition. I disagree with the previous review which described the front 9 as bland. The 1st is a really good stiff start. reachable in two, but with a risky second to a green which is much flatter than most. The 2nd is a bit regulation holiday course, but the 3rd, which looks like a straightforward par 3 from the tee, has a really nasty tricky green, which requires a very pure strike to hold. 4 and 5 are good sweeping driving holes, 6 is a terrific uphill par 3, with a blind green, 7 a good uphill par 4, and 8, which is the SI1 is a really difficult but interesting dogleg par 5. 9 and 10 are a bit of relief, shortish par 4s, then 11 is a classic risk and reward short par 4. You can take on the green, if you fancy your chances over a dogleg right guarded by pretty tall trees. 12 is the very short par 3, which is hit the green or you are dead. 13 is a great downhill drive, followed by a very tough shot into a domed green, 14 a very uphill shortish par 5, 15 is almost a shorter rerun of 13, with another very difficult domed green. 16 is a brute of a par 3, again a very difficult green. 17 is a weakish down and up par 4 with OB very close to the left hand side. 18 is decent par 5 into a very heavily guarded green.
After all the detail, how about an overall impression? Well, this is a good test of golf in very pretty surroundings. There are no houses on the entire North course, which is mostly bounded by a salt marsh. In the main, it is a very fair course, although the domed greens between 13 to 16 are borderline unfair. As an overall design it is a good open driving course, with a requirement for much more accuracy to tight and well protected greens.
In February it was in very good condition, but it is a golf resort, and you just have to accept rounds which take 4.5 to 5 hours.
The clubhouse has a decent menu, the pro shop is well run and the hotel is excellent.
One last point - the South Course at El Rompido is a very good course, yet it doesn't get a mention in the Top100. Tighter, but with terrific greens, it a stern test, and in my view, it is a much better course than many others in Spain and Portugal featured on this website, including Islantilla, just down the road. In my view it is well worth a visit on its own merits.
I played the North Course on a very breezy but warm day in September, it’s part of a wider hotel and apartment complex and it appears almost everyone staying was there to play golf. I feel it’s a case of two very contrasting 9’s, the front is rather pedestrian albeit with some very long par 4’s (1st hole being SI 1!) and typical of any Spanish golf resort, not much to generate interest. However coming back is a much more exciting proposition with dramatic changes in elevation (13 being a highlight), some fine views to take in and considerably better architecture, 13-18 being a great run of holes . The course is set up to be generous from the tee with little rough and wide fairways, the only ball I lost was trying to drive the green on 11. Bunkering was well positioned to collect loose tee shots or badly hit approaches, the courses main test is to place your ball onto the large and undulating greens to avoid 3 putting or worse. I found them very difficult to read even though they were in recovery mode after summer maintenance and were not mowed to normal length they were fast, I dread to think how they would play once recovered! I found the overall course condition disappointing though, large areas of the fairways lacking any grass with scruffy and bumpy tee boxes on many holes. It was also a lottery whether the ball got any roll or bounce, seems to depend on the species of grass you land on rather than the shot you executed, fair to say no two holes were the same in that regard. By far the most disappointing element was the pace of play, expect a 5 hour+ round even though most players use a buggy, there’s no evidence of marshals or management of players and both the South and North suffer the same curse. I’ll admit that speed of play did colour my judgement and I certainly wouldn’t want to play it again unless that issue was addressed, the North is a good course despite its at times tired demeanour, worth playing for the back 9 alone.
A long and interesting course. Contrary to other reviewers, I though that the very short par 3 was a welcome relief! Greens are very true, but difficult to read. Fairways were excellent, especially considering the number of golfers they get onto this course (of which more later). The course gets off to a punishing start with a very stiff par 4 opener, with a particularly tight approach to a shallow green - anything left is dead in the marshland. I liked all of the par 3s, and the par 5s are open enough to allow a good thrash a fairway wood. The weak hole, in my opinion is the 17th, with a downhill layup at about 230-240 yards. My only problem with El Rompido was too many people, playing too slowly. It is most definitely a golf resort, not a hotel with a golf course, so almost everyone in the very large hotel and apartment complex is there to play golf. They get a huge number of people through, but rounds are inevitably protracted, over 5 hours in our case.
The South course is less crowded and is a very good test.
The thing that strikes you upon arrival is the scale of this place – it’s absolutely enormous so a buggy is almost essential if you want to get round all eighteen holes in a decent timeframe. The second thing to catch the eye is the lack of housing on any of the holes, which was a real bonus after visiting the courses at nearby Isla Canela and Islantilla. In fact, a substantial portion of the North course is bounded by a vast wetland area and this thick green carpet of impenetrable vegetation gives the place a somewhat isolated feel.
The best hole on the front nine is probably the par four 4th, which sweeps left and uphill to an elevated green. Holes 8 to 10 are located more inland before the 11th returns to the routing next to the extensive marshland area, doglegging right and uphill to a green with a back to front tilt. The only really disappointing hole for me was the very short par three 12th, measuring only 112 yards from the back tees, which just seemed so out of scale with all the other holes on the course – I never thought I’d ever criticise a par three for not being long enough but this hole really didn’t fit in with what had gone before or what was to follow.
Compared against the other par three on the back nine at the 16th (played uphill and across the edge of the wetland area to an offset green that’s flanked by two coffin bunkers) it’s easily the weakest of the two short holes on the inward half. But I shouldn’t dwell upon a minor criticism such as this because the overall package on the North course is very good.
The previously mentioned Isla Canela and Islantilla courses are decent resort layouts in the local area (albeit a little rough around the edges in places) but if you like your golf to be a bit more challenging then this is the course for you. If only I’d had time for a look round the South course at El Rompido as it too looked rather tasty. That’s always an excuse for a return visit in the future, I suppose.