Scottish immigrant, John A. Forster, arrived in the US literally down on his uppers, but he went from rags to riches, becoming the chairman of Crum & Forster Insurance Company. He purchased 50 acres of land in Monroe Township just before the First World War and built a dairy farm which he named Forsgate – an amalgam of his surname and his wife’s maiden name of Gatenby.
Forster was a keen golfer, so he continued to acquire new land adjoining the farm with the objective of creating a golf and country club. In the late 1920s he commissioned Charles Banks to fashion the golf course and Clifford Wendehack to design the clubhouse.
Charles Banks, an associate of C.B. Macdonald and Seth Raynor in the 1920s, was nicknamed “Steam Shovel” and the former school teacher turned architect had an affection for constructing replica holes with deep greenside bunkers. Sadly Banks died aged 49 in 1931, just before Forsgate was finished.
Highlight holes on the Banks course include the 216-yard Eden at the 3rd; the reverse Redan at the 217-yard 7th; the 163-yard Short at the 12th (with wonderful horseshoe-shaped interior contouring on the raised putting surface); and the 239-yard 17th with its fabulous Biarritz green. This group of par three holes is as good as you will find anywhere in New Jersey outwith Pine Valley.
This Golden Age design is complemented at a highly contrasting 36-hole facility by the Palmer course, which Hal Purdy set out as 9-hole track in 1961. The architect returned a decade later to add another nine then this 18-hole layout was named in honour of Arnold Palmer after he renovated the course in 1995.
My most recent visit to Forsgate happened during the annual Writer's Cup event this summer and while the overall layout remains a joy to behold there is a major concern that needs attention.
Overzealous tree plantings from years ago have now become a clear issue. More specifically, the species of pine trees has now become an irritant when playing. These pine trees have spread their canopies and worse yet -- the branches have not been trimmed at the extreme lowest levels thereby causing players whose ball gets stuck beneath them to take an unplayable lie in many instances.
The issue of trees is not related simply to Forsgate but to a number of courses throughout the USA. However, in the northeast the issue still resonates with proponents of both removal and in retaining their presence.
The canvass for the Banks Course would be considerably enhanced with the pines being removed. The property contains eye-catching vistas with fairways moving in all sort of directions. The pines obscure these views and detract from the standout architecture which Banks provided.
Removing the trees is no small issue since local laws may impact the speed and process to be followed. But a clear trimming of pesky branches that extend to just a few feet above ground need to be expedited.
The Banks Course is rightly cited for the delicious internal contours of the putting surfaces and the range of holes is quite engaging. A comprehensive plan that deals with the invasive and non-indigenous pines is certainly in order now.
On a secondary level -- the Banks Course is blessed with superior greens but a few of them could be expanded to fit the original character of the layout.
The issue of the size of the greens is not on the same level as the impact caused by the pines but for the full grandeur of the Banks Course to reach its maximum potential these specific areas of emphasis are flashpoints for concern.
For those who have not been to the Banks Course I still wholeheartedly recommend playing the course if the opportunity arises. The layout was the last 18-hole design by Banks and the sum total of the holes and the overall flow of the routing and strategic elements encountered still has plenty of gusto.
However, golf courses are living entities and proactive decisions are crucial because they can set in motion an even greater overall product for golfers to enjoy in the years ahead.
We shall see.
M. James Ward
Forsgate the Banks course is part of 36 holes here. I have been fortunate to play here often as numerous friends were members. The outstanding characteristic of this course is it's outstanding green complexes. Some of the very best I have ever played. Conditioning is always good and it is a joy to play. It's better than the rating here.
Forsgate is a below the radar course in the style of Macdonald-Raynor with really good prototype holes. This shouldn’t be surprising since the course was designed by one of their protégés, Charles Banks. The par three holes really shine at Forsgate. The most outstanding hole on the course is the 17th, a prototype Biarritz hole with a massive swale through the middle of the green. The 3rd is a demanding Eden style hole that plays from an elevated tee over a large gully to a big, tough, elevated green. The Redan 7th is no pushover and the 12th has a large putting surface with large raised contours in the middle in the shape of a giant horseshoe, ensuring that balls on the putting surface don’t guarantee a par. My favorite hole is the “Long” hole, one of the best renditions I have ever played, it is a difficult par five at 600 yards, which typically plays into the wind with a fairway that slopes down a hill from right to left the entire way and to a green that is elevated with sharp falloffs. There are a couple holes that are good but not great, such as the first, fourth, and sixteenth that keep the course from being rated higher. In a state chocked full of abundant choices for the golfer, the Banks course at Forsgate sometimes gets overlooked, but it is a classic course that I highly recommend.
In today's "connected" world it's hard to imagine any "sleeper" courses escaping view. Especially when such courses are in an immediate core area where other courses of distinction exist.
Such is the case with a particular facility located halfway between the large cities of New York and Philadelphia.
Although not far away in terms of actual mileage from either of the aforementioned metro areas -- Forsgate Country Club in Jamesburg, New Jersey is a top tier quality facility that is known to locals but rarely is mentioned by those living outside a 100-mile radius. It is particularly shocking that many self-proclaimed golf cognoscenti often gloss over the qualities found at Forsgate.
In 1931 -- at the height of The Great Depression -- Forsgate Country Club opened. The vision of a successful Scottish immigrant who brought his vision to life in the farmlands of rural central New Jersey.
The brainchild was John Forster -- co-founder of the Crum & Forster insurance company. As someone who spent a good deal of time in Manhattan, Forster wanted to create a paradise away from the constant drumbeat of The Big Apple. Purchased in 1913 -- his getaway included 50 acres of land -- an outpost to rejuvenate the mind and body. Within a short time -- additional land was purchased and the decision to include a golf club was born.
The name Forsgate is actually a combination of the first few letters of Forster's last name and that of his wife's family name Gatenby. Forster's dream included creating a most active and highly successful farm. One that developed a considerable reputation over the years in producing a range of crops and various successful food items -- promoting the healthy elements of pasteurized milk and its by product high quality ice cream. For many people throughout the immediate region the food production side of things resonated most clearly.
Forster's love for the golf he knew in Scotland became driving force for him -- in creating a golf club equal to that of any other in New Jersey.
Despite the deepening impact of The Great Depression Forster moved ahead. He hired the noted clubhouse designer -- Clifford C. Wendehack -- to design the colonial clubhouse. Wendehack was the man responsible for such renown structures at Winged Foot in New York, along with The Ridgewood Country, Mountain Ridge and North Jersey in the Garden State along with alterations and additions he added at Baltusrol Golf Club.
The man chosen for the golf side was no less rich in his own pedigree. Charles H. Banks was a schoolteacher in Connecticut assigned to liaison with the golf architect hired at the school to improve the golf course on campus. That architect was Seth Raynor, considered one of the best in his field at the time, and when he completed the project he asked Banks to join his firm.
Raynor learned his skills as a course designer from American golf pioneer Charles Blair Macdonald. It was Macdonald -- the "founding father" of American golf -- who spearheaded the creation of iconic venues such as The National Golf Links of America and the Chicago Golf Club.
By the time he was contacted by Forster, Charles Banks was in his late 40’s and had his own firm. His designs in New Jersey alone include Rock Spring Club, Essex County Country Club, Hackensack Golf Club and Knoll West. Although many tout his design at Whippoorwill Club in Armonk, NY to be his finest -- his work at Forsgate has rightly earned more awareness as more have become exposed to its recent course restorations and renovations.
Nicknamed “Steam Shovel” for his favorite piece of golf course design equipment, Charles Banks built large, steep dramatic green-side bunkers -- providing unmistakable risk/reward options for most approach shots with a wide range of pin-placement options from accessible to devilish. This was complimented by large greens, many with pronounced shelves, mounds and bowls.
Forsgate was to be the last golf course Charles Banks designed in the United States, he died just before Forsgate was completed in 1931, at the age of 49.
When you arrive at Forsgate the beauty of the colonial clubhouse seizes your attention immediately. The 1st and 2nd holes allows the muscles to unwind and while the fairways at both are sufficiently wide -- you come to realize that being in the right position is central to scoring well.
The bunkers at Forsgate clearly catch your attention - primarily for the player to avoid them. They are set extremely deep and low and any ball entering will require the surest of strokes to escape. The greensites at Forsgate are also especially noteworthy because of their immense size and innumerable contours.
This becomes especially apparent when you arrive at the par-3 3rd. At 215 yards -- the tee shot on this Eden-like hole is played to an elusive elevated target split by a center spine dividing the left and right hand sides of the putting surface. When the pin is placed on the far right the wherewithal to hit a high fade with sufficient carry and height is an absolute essentiality.
Banks also created a fun short hole on the outward side -- the 6th is nicknamed "The Knoll" and while only 350 yards in length the hole can prove exasperating when the pin is set hard left with a high knoll protecting that entire side.
The second par-3 on the front is of equal quality to that of the 3rd. This reverse Redan is sculptured superbly. Players hit from an elevated tee pad to a green that has a high left side which runs diagonally to the right and slightly downhill. Protecting nearly the entire right side is a massive bunker that beckons players in the same seductive manner as the alluring sirens that lured sailors to their eternal rest.. While many rightly feast the original Redan at North Berwick's 15th hole and the replicas at the 4th at The National Golf Links of America and the 2nd at Somerset Hills in Bernardsville, NJ -- the 7th at Forsgate is no less sterling in its overall strategic qualities.
Once you conclude play at the 7th Banks brilliantly concludes the front side with two splendid par-5 holes -- both vastly different from one another in design and challenge. The long par-5 8th plays just over 600 yards and is usually into the prevailing south / southwest wind during the playing season. The hole continues to climb uphill and the fairway tilts ever so to the left -- hooking a ball off the tee can mean a most trying circumstances to secure a par. The green is also magnificently done -- elevated and sloped from right-to-left with a menacing left side bunker waiting for the hapless play.
The concluding par-5 9th plays 529 yards as the stated distance but here again you face an uphill tee shot to a blind rise. Stronger players can propel their tee shots to get within range in going for the green in two blows. But do reap such a bonanza -- the shots must be played with the surest of executions. The green, like the others, is well guarded on the left side and even played with a wedge approach must be thoughtfully executed.
The inward nine at Forsgate begins with what is one of the best holes on the course. The 416-yard par-4 10th starts from an elevated. Two bunkers on the left squeeze the fairway from that side at nearly 290 yards. The terrain is akin to a rollercoaster -- heaving about like a troubled stormy ocean. The green is elevated above the fairway with a large bunker on the right side that must be carried should the pin be placed on that side.
The par-3 12th is dubbed "Horseshoe" -- literally an upside down "C" rings the green. Pin placements can be placed in numerous spots -- either inside the Horseshoe or to the outer perimeter areas. At 163 yards -- many who play it the first time are thinking a quick and easy birdie awaits -- the reality is that bogeys or more are more readily attained if even the slightest of careless plays occurs.
The 13th is a functional par-5 but not compelling design wise. The long par-4 14th at 438 yards is a capable hole but when played with a helping wind -- which is typical during the playing season -- is not especially demanding. The short par-4 15th provides a good opportunity to make birdie before the concluding fine troika of holes to complete the round.
The par-4 16th at 445 yards provides a generous landing area but it is the approach shot that is tested well. The green is shaped like the letter "L" and has three distinct areas. Be mindful of the pin location because failure to gauge the appropriate length to the desired landing area can mean taxing putts of all types. When the pin is placed in the deepest part of the green -- the narrow pinch from both right and left sides makes for sweaty palms for the unsure golfer. A grand hole for sure but with two equally outstanding ones to follow.
The long par-3 17th at 240 yards is a long narrow green with a major dip in its center section. Forsgate's 17th is patterned after a par-3 at Biarritz in France. Over the course of time the original length of the green at 73 yards was shortened. When architect Stephen Kay was brought on board to restore many of the old-time features -- the focus on bringing back to life the inherent qualities of the original par-3 17th was on his immediate agenda. The hole is a marvel because of the utter elasticity it provides for all handicap types. Generally the hole plays with a helping breeze from the south but there can no half-hearted play at any time. Much is rightly made of the Biarritz hole at Yale's par-3 9th but the 17th at Forsgate is no lesser version by any means.
The closing hole at Forsgate is appropriately named "Purgatory." A new championship tee was added a number of years ago -- bringing the length to 450 yards -- the longest of the two-shot holes at the course. The fairway has a rolling quality to it -- similar to what one played at the 10th which adjoins the closing hole. The prevailing wind is generally in on the player and for those who opt for the bold aggressive play it's possible to ascend the hill and get to the other side but if one fails to reach the bottom the approach will be played from a difficult downhill stance to an elevated target. The key is avoiding woods flanking both sides. In years past recovering from those woods would have been unlikely as grass and tree branches were too thick. They have been smartly pruned in recent times but there's no automatic "get out of jail card" provided.
The approach is a glorious site to behold. The clubhouse sits majestically behind the green. The putting surface is especially sloped from back to front with a left-to right slant. The right hand bunker is where "Purgatory" got its name. Once you enter the bunker you may get the feeling of utter hopelessness -- never being able to conclude the hole.
My first round at Forsgate came 45 years ago as a teen playing in a major junior qualifier. I have seen the different cycles of how the course has gone through various ups and downs. In the most recent of years the course has come under the watchful stewardship of Chris Schiavone and it has been through his dedication to the property and love of the game that Forsgate has clearly made herculean strides.
The quarter of par-3 holes is as good as any in NJ -- only a slightly behind the four stellar par-3 holes found at Pine Valley. The terrain is walkable but it also provides for sufficient movement -- the player must know how to hit from uneven lies and be able to hit to elevated targets with proper distance control and loft. The greens offer an array of shapes and sizes. Green speeds are kept at reasonable levels but should they be cut and rolled for maximum effect -- the demands on the player can increase significantly.
In this era when courses have been stretched to unseemly distances and the virtues of discerning design details can be flattened or outright eliminated -- it is clearly refreshing to see the magical nature of what Banks envisioned carry on to this day. For anyone coming to New Jersey be sure to get on the NJ Turnpike and head to Exit 8A -- you'll find a very fun and entertaining course that's happy to oblige a finely played shot but will never accept the foolish or reckless play. Is Forsgate a top ten course in a very competitive golf state like NJ? It is most certainly in that discussion.
As a postscript -- many may not realize that before Peter Oosterhuis went on to success as an television golf announcer for Sky, BBC and CBS-Sports - he served as Director of Golf for several year at Forsgate and later at Riviera. Playing such a richly detailed course and having the opportunity to chat with such a fine gentleman is something I will always remember.
By M. James Ward - images courtesy of Forsgate Country Club