Grand Saint-Emilionnais - South West France - France

Having played Tom Doak’s Pacific Dunes in Oregon many times, I was excited to play Grand Saint-Emilionnais. On non-golf vacation with my wife, I did not have my golf shoes or clubs. Playing with a borrowed set, I still had a phenomenal time. The Mourgue d’Algue Family could not have been more hospitable.

I was provided with a course layout guide, but never even had to refer to it. There is wonderful signage on the course and the vistas are incredible. Even without a range finder, the colored fairway markers were sufficient. Each tee shot has you hitting to a wide fairway, but Doak gives you a very good indication of where best to hit your tee shot by using strategically placed bunkers or trees. With the exception of the par 3’s, most of the sloping greens are very small, with well-defined sections. Approach shots need to be hit from the correct side of the fairway to give you the best chance of hitting the greens. Many greens, including holes 2 and 3 have creeks fronting or alongside the sloping putting surfaces, requiring you to miss on the correct side of the hole.

There is a wonderful collection of par 5 holes. Many are reachable in two, but you could find yourself with an awkward chip if you short-side yourself. If played as a three shot hole, a strategically placed second shot is required. I really enjoyed the strategy required on the 561 meter, par 5 15th. With large mounds guarding the entrance to the green, place your second shot on the extreme right hand side of the fairway for the best approach.

The short par 4’s, requiring pinpoint approach shots, are really challenging. If you are really good from 80-100 yards away, you can score on this memorable course. There are six holes of about 360 meters or less, but all are fun. The others are mostly mid-length, but play a bit uphill or downhill. Many move slightly one way or the other, so if you like working the ball, you will never be bored.

The par 3’s offer a nice variety. Two are mid-length. The 9th hole, playing downhill over a lake, is almost 200 meters. From off the green, consider a bump and run shot. The wonderful 12th, plays 225 meters in length, uphill with a yawning bunker protecting the left side. From a tight lie, short of the green, bumping the ball with a 5 wood or hybrid is the perfect shot, especially to a front pin.

This gorgeous golf course is very playable for a middle handicap golfer, but if you play to a single digit, you will really enjoy the variety of shots required to put you in a position for birdie. The putting surfaces are a bit slow right now, but as the course matures, like the fine wines in the area, it will get even better with age.

Donn Levine, San Francisco, CA

Author, “Outwit the Yips”

Review of the month July 2017

I have mixed feelings about this course, and surely not as enthusiastic as the previous reviewer. Surroundings are very nice, a great feeling of isolation. As for the course, few obstacles from the tee, but well placed. Fairways wide enough. The greens have a good variety of size but their shape is borderline silly in places, at least for the first timer. Some of the greens decently only have 2-3 pin positions. I also thought they didn't look good, although they putted ok (despite variation of speed across the 18 greens). Then there are the numerous blind tee shots which is odd on such a new course. And the elevated greens, which I have never liked. Probably the type of course that needs to be played more than once, I didn't enjoy all of it on that first visit....

It’s always a special thing to play a newly designed course. It gets even more special when it’s a Tom Doak course.

And even more when playing with the course owner who during the 18 holes keeps giving you the insight of how the course was designed, the inner secrets of working with Doak, the subtleties of creating a course over a 10 year period.

As a golf enthusiast this was an amazing experience.

As a golf traditionalist I was playing with Andre Mourgue d’Algue, France’s most prized golfing family, and a scratch golfer himself.

The course opened in late 2015 and I went to play the course December 27th 2016. So needless to say, it probably not the best period – a new course during the winter period. But the opportunity arose …

The course itself :

I was never the 100% Doak enthusiast … that is until now. What he has done at St Emilion is fantastic. Simple as that !

It’s a course which is playable at all levels, with very traditional Bordeaux area scenery (vines and forest), using the natural contours and subtle shaping to create something that looks as though it’s been here for a long time. The greens may be a bit too undulated, but I suppose the family is knowledgeable enough not to get the greens that fast that it would be a problem.

The tradition of golf :

Andre’s vision for the course, is to get back to a rather minimalist English golf tradition. Play the course as it is ... The tee boxes are next to the greens ... The driving is rather large and it starts to get tricky on the approach to the green ... Play the bump and run or putt from the fringe on most greens… nothing too fancy, but at the end of the day, you have played a great course in a very special environment, with a 13th century church that one can use as for direction on the attack to the green on 16th, Montaigne’s Mansion on 15th, the Saint Emilion vines on 5th…

The one thing I love about the course : most tee boxes open up the course to see 2-3 other holes, but once on the fairway, you are on that hole and see nothing else, which strengthens your focus but at the same enables you to get a feel for this unique place… a bit like Augusta.

This course will climb the rankings as the course settles in in the coming months, and as golf connaisseurs/rankers discover the course … that’s a given !