The North Jersey Country Club course is an early 1920s Walter Travis design, located in the township of Wayne in Passaic County.
Writing in The Confidential Guide to Golf Courses, Tom Doak commented as follows: “The membership here seems to be stuck in a dilemma of their own making. The course they have is full of blind shots, and Travis’s wild greens are a good fit for the hilly property, but not with the sensibilities of the younger members. So they’ve been slowly chipping away at the course’s most distinguished features, one hole at a time. About a dozen of Travis’s greens are left; go see it before they tear up any more of them.”
The original pedigree of North Jersey CC was clearly a work of art from the extremely talented golfer and architect Walter Travis. The portfolio of top tier courses under his handiwork still carries weight with the likes of Scranton, Westchester, Hollywood and Ekwanok, to name just a few. The issue with North Jersey is that the club saw the need to "update" matters and the consequences meant that a number of the original Travis greens were completely altered. There's still a number of them remaining but the juxtaposition between the original and new makes for a combination that simply do not match. The same thing also applies to various fairway features that were simply eliminated.
The club has seen fit to spend considerable dollars in updating the famed Clifford Wendehack clubhouse and the turf condition are quite good. The qualities of a number of holes still standout with the likes of the par-4 holes at the 5th, 8th and 9th. The inward half as a few with the likes of the par-4 12th and the fascinating topography it provides. However, the original green has been altered to one that is considerably more vanilla in character. The par-3 13th went through major surgery -- the original green was devilish in its presentation with no bunkers but a long narrow green that proved a worthy challenge. The existing hole bears more of a modern appearance and is not a bad replacement but it relies more on adding elements whereas the original hole provided less but delivered more. The one major change that truly added a good deal to the course came with the par-4 16th. Originally, a non-descript short hole -- the new version plays 428 yards to an uphill green that is keenly sloped and requires a solid approach and steady stroke to leave with par. The ending provides for a quality par-5 and a fine mid-length par-4.
Overall, Travis provided North Jersey with a range of design elements that if still provided would have truly added to the overall golf experience. The course has its moments but the back and forth between old and new makes for an unnecessary and hard to fathom final product. Going back to all the original features is likely not going to happen. A pity.
by M. James Ward