Palmeraie Rotana - Morocco

The Palmeraie resort had 27 holes in play when I was last here in 2012 but they’ve now relinquished the newest nine holes, contracting the operation to the original 18-hole setup which was laid out by Robert Trent Jones Sr. thirty years ago. I played the more recently installed Tensift nine ten years ago so I was pleased to play the original Jbilettes nine this time around.

These holes (1 to 9) head west from the clubhouse, skirting the hotel accommodation to the left of the fairways before the routing loops back at the short par three 4th and runs in the opposite direction for five holes. The par four 9th then turns back to dogleg right around water, returning players close to where they started out earlier.

Holes are spacious and mildly undulating, with the only cause for concern occurring on the tee at the par four 3rd, where an ugly high net protects hotel accommodation intruding badly to the left of the tee box. The par three 8th looks pretty bland on the tee the hole is so much better when you reach the green to find out the shallow putting surface is shared with the par four 10th, making it one of the more interesting green complexes on the property.

Water comes into play more frequently on the back nine as golfers play around the “Secret Garden” residential complex at holes 13 and 14. A new raised tee on the short par four 15th gives a better view of what lies ahead when playing this right doglegging hole around another small lake. Like last time, I really liked the final par three at the 17th, with lovely water hazards protecting the front right and left of the green.

Caddie master Rachid has worked at Palmeraie for more than 20 years so he’s the person to watch out for if you need any help around the clubhouse – all clubs need somebody of experience like him to operate smoothly and he’s just the very man for the job!

Jim McCann

Ranked 19th in Morocco designed by Robert Trent Jones three nines Jibilettes, Atlas and Tensift.

We played (in February 2017) the J/A as the new nine was a bit new looking. Overall a good course; if you hit the fairways you get run and if in the rough it slows quickly but is findable making it a pleasure to play. Not spectacular views where the course circled around the hotel where we stayed. Many holes are dog-legs and more of them a semi-circle around a lake making the amount you want to bite-off interesting and challenging. Greens were good and fast and yet will check up a good shot. As a links players we struggled to pitch from the ’cotton-wool’ rough. Beware of 17th par 3- be long. A bit of a mystery playing for the first time as my sat-nav. nor the buggy nav. did not work and made it more difficult clubbing than it was. Recommend play and enjoy ahead of the Royal.

Tempted by unlimited Golf for five days and four nights for under £500 we found ourselves at the Grand Palmerai Resort. It is situated ten minutes from the bedlam of downtown Marrakech, but happily, oh so far away, at least as far as I am concerned. You can take the boy out of the country club but you can’t take the country club out of the boy. I am afraid I am a cultural philistine and a bit of a Luddite when it comes to appreciating peeling paint and dilapidation described as “shabby chic”. The Hotel was pleasant enough, Good enough for the British ambassador and his retinue it would appear…… and you would be hard pushed to complain about the food. Maybe a little expensive? The Weather is perfect for Golf 24-28 Degrees and being slightly above sea level you notice the difference in how far you are hitting it. Happy Days! The first time you play this course you will no doubt come off the course slightly underwhelmed, we did. You will think it featureless, bland and maybe a little bit samey. However, I put a rather sizeable hole in the unlimited golf (8 rounds) and I can tell you that the course really grows on you. It is an easy walk on springy bermuda grass over flat ground, you can easily walk 36 here. Condition of fringe areas could be better, A bit scruffy and G.U.R had me taking a couple of drops but that was okay. You will have to have a caddie for £10 or a buggy for £40. We chose Abdul every time. All Good. If you want great weather, fine facilities and perfectly playable and enjoyable bit of Holiday Golf then this is going to suit you perfectly. The other Nine were excellent too. Very enjoyable then. Other tourists I spoke to enjoyed the other courses in the area too. And the culture, but like I said, I can’t comment. JCB Lay

A flatter course than Amelkis or Al Maaden but it has enough about it in terms of design for it not to be too much an issue. What does let down Palmeraie is the placement of tee markers near the edges of its crowned teeing areas, which made getting a flat lie for teeing off nearly impossible on half of the holes. Getting away a good tee shot is vital to attacking the fast paced greens from the best position and ideally with a short club in order to avoid the water hazards. Having played only 18 of the 27 holes on site I preferred holes 10-18 instead of 1-9. In my view the first nine is less inspired from the tee with three weak, medium-length par fours (1st, 5th, 6th) but has some solid green complexes with undulating greens (2,3,4,7,8). This nine finishes with a bang, with a difficult par four dogleg right, hugged by a water hazard for all of its right hand side, with the putting surface overhanging the water. The second nine is stronger with only the 10th and 11th being slightly weak. The driving lines are tighter and the lack of definition on a hole such as the 12th appears to be a deliberate design ploy to make players question the best line to take. The line on the 14th is anywhere but left and into the ample pond, or further left into the plush course-side villas. Water is again present on the 15th and 17th with no real bail-out option on the long par 3 17th. The 15th is all about risk-reward and is one of the few such holes in Marrakech where the good player may be tempted to take the risk (of driving the green in this instance) balanced against dunking their ball in the hazard on the right. The 400 yard 18th is a good finish with a short iron all that is required after a good drive. Made easier if you don’t realize, and caddy doesn’t remind you there is water short left. The clubhouse is a let down in my view with food and drink prices wholly out of proportion with the rest of Marrakech and more expensive than prices found in London or world class golf ‘resorts’ like Turnberry. The service is not particularly world class either. The course itself though is well worth a round of holiday golf.

As I found at Amelkis the day before, when I played one of the original nines along with a newer nine, I much preferred the older, established Atlas course here (holes 10 to 18) to the newer Tensift (holes 19 to 27).

Of course, it’s resort golf all the way – minus the buggies, but with a caddie (for a very reasonable fee) – where fairways wind around a number of fountained lakes that were teeming with all sorts of exotic birdlife.

I liked in particular the two par threes on the Atlas course, especially the second (at hole 17) which calls for an all carry tee shot across water.

The new nine is located a bit to the north west of the property, requiring a buggy transfer, but the club has one of those elongated versions that can comfortably take four golfers plus caddies in one go.

This loop is wider and less tree-lined than the old course so I felt a lot of the holes lacked definition but I’m sure that will change in time as the vegetation flourishes naturally. The greens have been sown with a different type of grass so they were, if anything, slightly better than the (excellent) putting surfaces that we played on our front nine.

I enjoyed the playing experience at Palmeraie more than I did at either Amelkis or Al Maaden – not that the other two are bad courses, they aren’t; they just didn’t match the layout and conditioning of this more established place.

Jim McCann.