Unbeknownst to most, hard-hitting Max Schmeling was a golfer and he even prepared for the first Joe Louis fight at French Lick, bemoaning the fact that he had left his clubs in Germany. At the time he lived in Bad Saarow, a glamorous spa town near Berlin, where he rubbed shoulders with the likes of Winston Churchill and Maxim Gorki. His home course was called Golfclub Saarow-Scharmützelsee, a 9-holer dating from 1930. It was designed by Colt, Alison & Morrison and built by Bernhard von Limburger, but unfortunately did not survive the turmoils of World War II and communism.
However, in the 1990s a push to restore former glory to the area got underway. A modern golf resort was opened on the shores of beautiful Lake Scharmützel and not far from the old site. Only now there are golf holes to spare at Sporting Club Berlin Scharmützelsee – 63 in total – of which Arnold Palmer laid out the first 18 in 1995 and Nick Faldo followed suit in 1997 with his first Continental European design. Sir Nick hit just about as hard as Max Schmeling, so they actually had to soften his creation somewhat to make it palatable for average golfers.
But it is still a big championship course; it has been part of the German Ryder Cup bid and hosted the German Open and other professional events in the past. Day-to-day it fulfils its flagship duties for the resort, although it's not the most popular track there. That accolade belongs to the more playful and visually attractive Arnold Palmer course. The Faldo was never meant to be pretty, it was supposed to model an austere Scottish links, and between the bunkering, the burn, the brownish rough and the absence of trees, ponds and doglegs it does make an admirable effort at looking the part.
The sand traps are its marquee feature; they are all of the same basic shape, small, round and of varying depth. With a generous spattering of these pots all over the property and the sharply defined cuts of grass, it's an unfamiliar playing experience for the German golfer. But the mustachioed Stan Eby (the architect working with Faldo at Bad Saarow) did not go all the way, it’s still a green course and doesn’t play as firm as, for example, Faldo’s first European design at Chart Hills. However, compared to his Kentish brainchild, the more restrained bunkering in Berlin will be to the tastes of traditionalists, who probably won't even notice that the 11th hole has fourteen pits in play.
Walkability is also an asset; few courses are easier to navigate on foot. Which is just as well, because the fairly long layout entirely passes on the categories of “reachable par 5", "drive and pitch par 4" and "tiddler par 3”. To be fair though, there are enough medium-length holes that can entertain a bogey golfer and the maintenance as well as the service standards are high.
The Faldo course is indeed a joy to walk, although this is less than true for the pre-round journey from the car to the office, back to the car and across the parking lot and the access road to the first tee. And don't forget to validate your ticket at the office or else you'll embark on another post-round walk to the parking meter.
The round itself starts off with a drive into the semi-rough, because you'll stay away from the ominous bunkers on the left and think there's a bit of fairway on the right side. Not so. But why not? There's a lot of real estate to the sides and beyond some of the bunkers that could be maintained as fairway to create additional options. And while we're on the topic of short grass, it must be said that this "inland links" design has the playing characteristics of target golf. There is no ground game to speak of and the rough isn't especially wispy either. Bomb and gouge will work here, putting from 80 yards out or any other type of links shot won't. The soil is simply not conducive to that.
The design of the holes is ok, nothing spectacular, but no failures either. A few more fairway and green undulations would make the course more interesting, if it could also play a bit firmer. I've added a picture of the approach to green 7, which illustrates the point. However, it's more or less the only hole in that style. So except for the Faldo name and perhaps the bunkering there isn't anything unique here that would justify a triple-digit greenfee. Nevertheless, it's a competent layout, so if money is no objective and the Palmer course is booked solid, why not have a quick zip around the Faldo to keep your game sharp? (UM)