Patrick McGarey

While this course doesn't compare to the likes of Rosapenna, Ballyliffin or Narin & Portnoo, it does offer a pleasant and challenging round featuring a number of interesting holes. Most of these occurred near the turn and on the back nine. Highly recommended as a "breather" round between the courses noted above - or for less accomplished players not wishing to spend the day searching for errant drives in 10" rough. The pro shop and restaurant staff are also first rate, with the town of Dunfanaghy itself offering comfortable lodgings and great local seafood.

I returned to Narin & Portnoo for the first time since 2008 and was delighted to see that a weak opening hole and a few back nine quirks have been rectified by the Gil Hanse redesign. I understand that some level of this effort is ongoing, though a modern clubhouse now serves visitors rather than the prior trailer. I would encourage visitors to make the effort to reach this club, which winds through majestic seaside duneland. Though I played on a largely sunny day, the wind was quite strong during the back nine. This evidently is not unusual. As is the case on many courses, the golfer would benefit from the knowledge gained by playing Narin & Portnoo several times. I found the conditioning of the course to be first rate, and the clubhouse staff is extremely helpful. Make this trip!

Having played the previous configuration of "links front nine and hill second nine" in 2004, and not really caring for the latter, I was very pleased with the new nine links holes currently playing as the front nine at Old Tom Morris. It really makes the course a more authentic experience in my opinion. While some courses are forced to feature both links and non-links holes due to a lack of available duneland, that is happily not the case here. The resulting Old Tom Morris course is by no means a letdown compared to the other two Rosapenna gems, featuring great conditioning and shot variety. This trio of links courses, possibly combined with a trip to nearby Portsalon (30-40 minute drive) or further afield Narin & Portnoo and/or Ballyliffin (36 links holes) will form the basis of an extremely stout Irish golf trip. Interestingly, a longtime Rosapenna Hotel employee informed me that the redesign of the back nine at Old Tom Morris was required by busy Summer traffic conditions which caused long delays in crossing and hitting over the local road adjacent to the course (original links on one side and the hill on the other).

I played Sandy Hills in October 2022, after having played the course previously in Spring 2008. The recent changes to make some of the fairways more generous and bunkering less severe were executed beautifully. There is still ample trouble awaiting a poor shot, but the player isn't quite holding his breath on as many shots as before. Conditioning was excellent and the variety of holes made for an interesting round requiring the full bag. A must-play for this area, as are the other two Rosapenna links.

I played St. Patrick's in light rain and cool wind in early October 2022. Rather than quibble about the course's relative rating, let me state that I found it strategically challenging and interesting, as I have with other Doak efforts (Cape Kidnappers in NZ and the Memorial Park redesign in Houston). Some settling in is still occurring (certain greens and the paths between greens and tees for example), but this is not surprising for a course which opened during the COVID summer of 2021. Given the conditioning of the other two Rosapenna courses, there's little reason to think that the newest addition won't settle into similar consistency. The St. Patrick's greens have some slope and complexity which will need to be respected as the greens continue to improve. The price of both golf and lodgings was reasonable and the fact that three excellent links lie side-by-side makes this small town a must-visit golf mecca. Both the comfortable Rosapenna Hotel and the main Golf Facility (pro shop, bar and restaurant) add to the experience, with a friendly and efficient staff. Although somewhat remote, Rosapenna remained busy with golf groups in early October (as I'm told was the case throughout Summer 2022). Several suitable hotels lie in nearby Downings if the Rosapenna resort hotel is unavailable during high season.

I played this recently revamped course in July 2018, during sunny and windy conditions. The area had received very little rain during the summer, resulting in very fast fairways and lots of roll. I give the recent <img src="/images/portmarnock-hotel-and-golf-links-golf-course-review-PORH072.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Portmarnock Hotel & Golf Links - Photo by reviewer" title="Portmarnock Hotel & Golf Links - Photo by reviewer"> upgrade high marks, as the tee boxes, traps and greens were generally in very good condition. Particularly in the wind, it will be important for mid-handicappers to select the correct set of tees, otherwise some par fours will not be reachable into the stiff breeze. As has been noted, the dunes are more dramatic on the back nine, resulting in more nuanced, interesting hole layouts and green complexes. Very convenient to the Dublin airport and a great, reasonably-priced addition to a Dublin area golf trip (Portmarnock, The Island, Royal Dublin and perhaps the European Club). Pat M., Houston, TX

I've played this highly under-rated track three times, most recently in July 2018 on a day of overcast skies and some drizzle. Given the quality of this course, it is mind boggling that the weekday green fees are only <img src="/images/royal-portrush-valley-golf-course-review-ROPV017.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Royal Portrush (Valley) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Royal Portrush (Valley) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> 42 GBP. The holes are skillfully carved into a valley of dunes, with excellent greens and nice variety from hole to hole. The recent redesign unfortunately came at the expense of a very long par three (formerly hole #6), but the slightly revised layout is still top notch. It should be played either in tandem with a trip to the adjoining championship Dunluce links (entrance roughly a half mile away), or as a cost-effective, slightly shorter alternative. Pat M., Houston, TX

I spent a perfect Spring day at Coombe Hill in April 2018 (coincidentally, the warmest April day in London in 70 years) - and can honestly say it was one of the most pleasant experiences of my golfing life. This course may lack the one-through-eighteen "teeth" to be considered a <img src="/images/coombe-hill-golf-course-review-COOM018.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Coombe Hill Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Coombe Hill Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> true championship test, but if offers a wonderful variety of old-school holes and design values, not to mention perfect conditioning. Similar to classic Abercromby layouts at The Addington and Knole Park, there is a lot of uphill and downhill shot variety at Coombe Hill, as well as at least one blind tee shot. Not every modern golfer seems to favor this type of quirkiness, but these features are a welcome and integral part of the Coombe Hill experience. Do yourself a favor and play a round at this classic course!

I played Knole Park on a perfect April morning in 2018. The course lies on rolling - even hilly - ground, and the hole designs inevitably reflect this fact. There is a lot of "up and down" on this course, which makes for a nice variety of both vistas and golf shots. Since the course lies near (or within?) a game preserve, you'll be sharing your round with dozens of deer, <img src="/images/knole-park-golf-course-review-KNOL024.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Knole Park Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Knole Park Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> but I saw no evidence of destruction on the greens or in the bunkers, so this presented no problem. Conditioning was excellent (I've yet to run across poor greens on ANY London-area course) and I found the layout of the holes to be very natural and old-school (recognizable to any golfer familiar with Abercromby's work at Addington and other masterpieces). This is not the easiest course to find, but is sufficiently convenient for visitors to greater London. As vacationing U.S. golfers continue to pour into Scotland and Ireland to play the admittedly wonderful and iconic links courses, it strikes me that the sheer depth of courses across England (links, parkland and heathland) - many of them reasonably priced - is generally underappreciated. Knole Park is a great example of this fact.

I played the New course under clear, but windy and fast conditions in April 2018. This course has a nice blend of shorter and lengthy par fours, and windy conditions (as well as gorse and perhaps heather, which were <img src="/images/walton-heath-new-golf-course-review-WALN031.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Walton Heath (New) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Walton Heath (New) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> fairly tame in April) put some real teeth into the longer, more challenging holes. Good shots are well-rewarded, but a "swing away" approach might result in too many trips to the gorse to allow decent scoring. The greens were in excellent condition - and fast - but not unreasonably so. All things considered, the New course offers a "big boy" golf experience which shouldn't be missed. (I recall many of the same experiences from the Old course at Walton Heath several years ago.) It is not a coincidence that Walton Heath has hosted many significant championships during its history.

I played early on a wonderful Spring morning in April 2018 and was treated to a wonderful layout and scrupulous course conditions. The fairways are rather generous and the average length of hole is not too demanding for the reasonably accomplished golfer. This results in a very <img src="/images/stoke-park-colt-and-alison-golf-course-review-STOK054.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Stoke Park (Colt & Alison) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Stoke Park (Colt & Alison) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" rel="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;"> relaxing and enjoyable experience for the recreational (i.e. non-elite) player. Having said this, there are many challenging approach shots and tricky greens at Stoke Park. The famous par 3 seventh hole, often compared to the sixteenth at Augusta National, is a good (but by no means exclusive) example of the precision often required at Stoke Park. Even aside from the Goldfinger connection, this course is a "must play" for golfers visiting the greater London area. The staff is very welcoming as well.

I played Hankley Common on a warm, still - but threatening - Sunday in April 2018 as a single. The Pro Shop was nice enough to encourage me to tee off before an afternoon competition, which made the round much more enjoyable at an unrushed 3-1/2 hours. Although I played much of <img src="/images/hankley-common-golf-course-review-HANK038.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Hankley Common Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Hankley Common Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> the back nine in steady drizzle, this fact did not really impair a terrific afternoon of golf. There is a lot of gorse in play at Hankley Common, including a number of forced carries off the tee. (I'm sure that playing the layout in April was easier than a round in, say, August, when the gorse is higher and more threatening to wayward shots.) This course has very interesting and varied holes and the conditioning was at a very high level, especially for April during what had been a cool, rainy Spring in Surrey. I was reminded somewhat of the excellent Woodhall Spa course, in that a 10-14 handicap has a chance to score reasonably, and without constant threat of lost balls. Having said that, there are many challenging tee shots and approaches at Hankley Common, which belongs on any visiting golfers "must play" list.

I had the pleasure of playing Huntercombe on a temperate, sunny day in mid-April 2018. Fortunately for me, this perfect day was described by many locals as "the first day of Spring", since it was preceded by weeks <img src="/images/huntercombe-golf-course-review-HUNR001.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Huntercombe Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Huntercombe Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> of wet and chilly weather. Course conditions were surprisingly good, considering the lack of recent sunshine. There were a few soft spots in the otherwise lush fairways, and the greens lived up to their excellent-but-tricky reputation. I would describe the course as more parkland than heathland, as trees lining the fairways were much more of a shot-making and scoring factor than the modest patches of yellow gorse (which might be more prominent later in the summer). The level of challenge was perfect for my low double-digit handicap. A highly recommended course, and a convenient ~90 minute drive from LHR airport.

I played Seacroft on a clear April day and was very glad that I made the effort. This is a classic, old-school links course which plays hard and fast, <img src="/images/seacroft-golf-course-review-SEAC013.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Seacroft Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Seacroft Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> with excellent greens. Many interesting and challenging holes, and no poor holes that I can recall. Due to its location, roughly an hour away from Woodhall Spa, this course can be readily added to a larger golf itinerary for a player who doesn't mind an hour or two of driving to reach his next day's challenge. Very good golf is available both to the north and south of Seacroft, and can be readily researched on the Top 100 website.

I played Seaton Carew on a blustery April afternoon, accompanied by two club members (thanks for the round Mick and John!). Although surrounded <img src="/images/seaton-carew-golf-course-review-SEAT019.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Seaton Carew Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Seaton Carew Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> by heavy industry and the Teeside nuclear power plant, the course is a wonderful links which tests all aspect of your game. Course conditioning was very good, with the greens especially in excellent shape. Located a reasonably convenient driving distance from Ganton and the moorland courses outside of Leeds (Alwoodley et al), Seaton Carew forms a very distinctive cog in a golf trip to NE England. The green fees are very reasonable, while the staff and membership are extremely welcoming. Put this one on your list if you enjoy links golf!

I played Lindrick on a calm April afternoon, after a morning round at nearby Notts. Lindrick is a classic British design, featuring several blind shots, <img src="/images/lindrick-golf-course-review-LINR050.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Lindrick Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Lindrick Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> redan greens and other features sadly missing from more modern layouts. Course conditioning was excellent, with wonderful greens (firm, with true reads). The holes were routed through varied landscape, and included a number of memorable challenges (the blind approach par five #4 and the lengthy par three #18 are examples). While I'm happy to play these uncrowded courses before the touring golfing public "wakes up" to their quality, visiting Americans are crazy to miss playing classic English layouts like Lindricks, which has hosted both the '57 Ryder Cup and the Ladies Open.

I played Notts as a first-on-the-course single on a beautiful April morning. This is a simply delightful course, with a wonderful variety of holes winding there way through a series of beautiful settings. I found the course <img src="/images/notts-golf-course-review-NOTT049.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Notts Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Notts Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> challenging, yet not punitive off the tee and on approach shots. Perfect for the low to middle handicapper looking for a nice test of skills, but not numerous lost balls. I was told that I was the first American visitor during 2017 at Notts. This suggests to me that many American visitors are ignoring the tremendous degree of depth which exists in English golf courses. After you get beyond the Open rota, there are dozens of high quality English courses which welcome visitors with reasonable green fees and terrific traditional golf layouts (e.g. Woking, Addington, Formby, West Lancashire, etc., etc.). My day concluded with a round at the stellar Lindrick course, roughly 20 miles away, and offering much of the same hospitality and quality golf.

I played Ganton on a cool, windy day in April. After a gracious reception by the staff, I found that the course very much lives up to its reputation as a tough but fair examination from tee to green. Fairways are well-bunkered and often lined with stands of gorse....as are the greens. The greens were <img src="/images/ganton-golf-course-review-GANT049.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Ganton Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Ganton Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> in outstanding shape. As noted in the James Finegan book, the course provides a constant sense of pressure on your swing (or at least the swing of a low double digit amateur). I found myself playing the longer par 4s as par 5s in order to stay out of trouble off the tee and around the well-trapped greens. None of this is intended as a criticism, just as a reminder of why this course has hosted many significant championships....a high level of play is required to score well. I'm told the wind I experienced is more or less the prevailing condition, resulting in a hard, fast track. I thought I had salvaged a memory during an otherwise mediocre day of scoring on the ~230 yard par 3 17th, but my three wood rolled over the green and I failed to get up and down for par. Still, a real treat for a serious golfer with a sense of the game's history. Would visit again in a heartbeat.

Played the Hotchkin course on an overcast, relatively calm April day. Course conditioning was excellent and the staff was friendly and helpful. <img src="/images/woodhall-spa-hotchkin-golf-course-review-WOOS055.jpg" style="float: right; margin: 0px 0px 10px 10px;" alt="Woodhall Spa (Hotchkin) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer" title="Woodhall Spa (Hotchkin) Golf Course - Photo by reviewer"> The Hotchkin fully earned its status as a classic, must-play layout. The degree of difficulty was significant, but not to the point of discouraging an occasional bold shot. Fairways are the "right" width in terms of requiring some precision off the tee (often carrying 100-150 yards of gorse), but not overly punitive. Fairway and greenside bunkering is plentiful, but again reasonable. Greens were in great shape, holding well-struck irons and providing straightforward "reads". Petwood Hotel is a great option in this town.

I played the Red/Blue on a clear breezy day in May '15.  The golf and hospitality staffs were both very efficient and welcoming.  The course itself was a textbook of classic heathland design, including tee shots which were less hazardous than they appeared from the tee, elevated greens requiring careful club selection (and execution!) and clever bunkering (both greenside and oftentimes 50-75 yards short of the green).  Lots of up and down walking to the tees and greens, so being in reasonable shape isn't a bad idea.  I felt like I'd climbed Everest after my round, but happy to have done so.  Very good greens and fairway conditioning.  A real treat for the serious golfer, and frankly a bit under the radar compared to some of the other renowned British courses around London.  Well worth the L135 visitor green fee.  Not the easiest place to find, even once you're inside the security gate of the posh George's Hill residential community, so allow time to get there!  The clubhouse is easily one of the most impressive in the world.

The last of the Three Ws is certainly no disappointment, starting with the decades old wisteria bush winding its way through the pillars on the restaurant terrace.  What a classic venue, and well worth the effort to find it down several country roads!  After a short par 4 opening hole, the balance of the course provided a good balance between comfort and challenge.  I was annoyed with myself for butchering the 351 yard 18th hole after a perfect tee shot, but there is plenty of peril both left and right of that water-threatened green.  Modern course designers could learn a great deal by playing this course and other turn of the century heathland layouts around London.  Short holes which can either be birdied or double bogeyed and deceptively long par 4s which require a lot of swing confidence on the approach.  Conditioning was excellent on the day I visited, and I suspect this is not the exception.  Great staff as well.  do yourself a favor and visit.

I played Worplesdon on a sunny May '15  Monday morning, mainly accompanied by a delightful longtime female member who joined me around the 5th hole.  In addition to being a very pleasant playing companion, she was also invaluable in terms of directing me to my next stop at Woking GC (tricky to find).  Regarding Worplesdon, I found the course very well designed and maintained, with the right level of challenge for my 10+ handicap.  Difficult to pick a favorite among the Three Ws, but you cannot go wrong with any of them.  Having picked up on the fact that perhaps Wentworth and The Berkshire do not overly encourage visitor play (no singles allowed or paired with others, high green fees), I can heartily recommend this layout as a classic English heathland classic.  Play it!

I played the course on a pleasant Sunday afternoon in May '15.  Several members confessed to being horrified at the condition of the post-winter greens, but I didn't find this to be much of an issue.  A very enjoyable course to play with a nice variety of holes in a terrific wooded setting.  Not brutally difficult, but not easy by any means either.  Pace of play was a bit slow, but I teed of late in the day in perfect weather on a Sunday, so no surprise there (at least for an American).  This is the easiest to find of the Three Ws, as Woking in particular requires some local navigation ability.  I really cannot elevate one of these three courses above the others, as the styles are similar without being identical.  West Hill is perhaps a bit flatter than the other two, but still challenging (at least for a double digit handicapper such as me). Course conditioning was very good overall and the staff couldn't have been more accommodating either.  Take my advice:  play all three and decide for yourself.  You WILL NOT go wrong.

I've played this wonderful course twice, roughly five years apart, and in each case during mild Spring weather.  The course is maintained in very good condition.  After a rather average uphill par three opening hole, most of the remaining holes ranged from memorable to extremely memorable.  I've also  never been a big fan of the short par 3 near the turn, but otherwise The Addington provides wonderfully designed holes requiring a wide variety of shots, several of them blind.  The course is not overly long, but clear thinking and shot execution are much better rewarded than bombing away indiscriminately with a driver off each tee.  This is definitely one course where the visiting golfer is well advised to drop five pounds on the strokesaver book.  In addition to several blind tee shots, several of the back nine par fives require good planning and precision on the second shot to avoid disaster. The long par 3 13th, as advertised, is a truly great inland long par 3 hole.  Not known for welcoming visitors in prior decades, I found the current staff very friendly and accommodating.  Parts of the London skyline (e.g. The Shard) are visible from several back nine fairways.  I'll be back in the future!

I played in nice weather in September 2013.  True to reputation, this course is an unheralded gem, limited only by it's somewhat remote location near the Scottish border.  Greens and fairways were both in excellent shape, with a series of holes requiring longish, accurate shots.  Three members joined me during my round, and one made the point that the course would be a viable entrant into the Open rota if it were 500 yards longer and locational logistics were more favorable.  Hard to argue with that assessment, as the course does compare favorably to Lytham, Turnbery, Hoylake and others.

I played Nefyn on a (luckily) perfect day in July 2012 and came away charmed and impressed.  As noted, the physical setting is magnificent, while the course layout contains 6-8 strong holes and the rest closer to average.  Not a championship/Open rota-style challenge, but also priced WELL below that type of course.  In other words, a very worthwhile day of golf for any serious player.  Actually worth playing twice or more, expecially in the case of the quirkly 12th hole, where finding the proper landing area on the drive and second shot probably require gaining some experience.  Don't forget to stop at the pub after the 12th or 15th hole for a quick pint.  There are a lot of walkers on a nice day, and this does require some patience for the sake of safety.  The 'death-or-glory' approach shot on the 11th hole somewhat reminded me of the first hole at North Berwick or the par 3 at Shiskine.  Enjoy this classic old course!!!

Despite the parkland-links contrast between the front and back nine, the parkland nine was not without interest and challenge.  In other words, the parkland holes were far from perfunctory (i.e. "muni course" quality) in nature.  And yes, the back nine is a great set of links holes.  Due to the relative paucity of links land, this bifurcation is unavoidable on many courses (Panmure and Portstewart come to mind).  In no way should this discourage golfers from giving Porthmadog a fair shake.  I think it should be rated a bit higher in the Welsh 100.  Friendly staff as well.

I played North Wales on a morning in early July of 2012, and unfortunately caught a very rainy day.  (Rained out at Conwy during the afternoon, which was actually closed due to conditions - an apparent rarity).  Conditions aside, I found the course challenging and interesting, with the right hint of design quirkiness.  By no means a pushover, expecially with the rough "healthy", as it was in Summer 2012.  Fairways and greens well tended.  I intend to return for a 36 hole day at North Wales and Conwy under better conditions, as the courses are only 10-15 minutes apart and are therefore easily played in a single day.  Convenient to Llandugno, a pleasant overnight stay.

A wonderfall golf experience across the board:  a  classic, straightforward links design; excellent course conditioning (fairways, greens, traps); a full variety of shots required; and, (esp. in the wet summer of early 2012) penal rough.  You really don't want to leave the fairway too often on this championship-level course, and short hitters should definitely choose the appropriate set of tees to avoid a very long day.  No tricks involved in playing Birkdale, just the requirement of continuously hitting strong, straight shots.  (Middlle-level handicappers may want to play the stronger par 4s as par fives to avoid constantly hitting 200 yard second shots to well-guarded greeens.  The greens putted very true and good approach shots held nicely.  Staff is friendly and the clubhouse is chocked full of golf history.  Excellent value for the admittedly (but appropriately) steep price.  A real treat for the serious player with a sense of golf history.

I played here on a perfect sunny/breezy day in July 2012, with a very friendly member (thanks, John!), several days after Open qualifying had taken place.  I find it hard to believe that the Old Links are not ranked among England's top 100.  Though the the course is rather flat as noted, it required strong shot-making in order to score well and the rather penal rough (a function of both recent rain and the set-up for the aforementioned Open qualifying) put a premium on accurate driving.  Course conditioning was top rate and the green fee was quite reasonable.  Many strong holes, with the par3 #9 especially memorable and well-designed.  Committed players might want to consider palying this course and Royal Lytham as part of a 36 hole day, as the courses are quite close to one another.  Friendly staff (thanks Ann!) as well.

The rather flat layout and modest scenery probably keeps Hoylake from meriting a full six ball rating, but this course requires very strong shot-making in order to score well. A premium on long, straight driving, at least when the rough is up - as it was in July 2012 after weeks of rain. (Nothing like conditions during the 2006 Open). Very good conditioning across the board (fairways, traps, greens), and evidently a welcoming member base, as I had the pleasure to play with 3 delightful older members. The internal out of bounds on several holes did not detract from the layout, instead giving it a strong individual personality. A committed golfer might want to strongly consider playing Hoylake and the nearby (and very worthwhile) <A href="/golf-course/wallasey" target=_self>Wallasey</A> as part of a 36 hole day. At any rate, don't miss the opportunity to play this classic.

I played Panmure on a rather blustery April day in 2012, with significant wind, intermittent rain and temperatures in the 50F range. These conditions made the course play longer than the "card" distance. Despite the early spring date, I found the conditioning of the course to be first rate. Panmure features a series of consistently strong holes, with several truly excellent holes such as #12. Many challenging approach shots with a strong risk vs. reward relationship. Unlike others, I am not put off by the parkland start and finish, with classic links holes comprising the middle of the layout. Overall, I would say that Panmure deserves more prominence among visitors to Scotland than it may currently enjoy, especially given the green fee rates (below $100) compared to <A href="/golf-course/kingsbarns" target=_self>Kingsbarns</A> and several notable newer layouts. The pro shop and clubhouse staffs could not have been more pleasant and accommodating as well. I would strongly encourage U.S. visiting golfers to give a fair hearing to courses such as Panmure (e.g. <A href="/golf-course/moray-old" target=_self>Moray</A>, <A href="/golf-course/lundin" target=_self>Lundin Links</A>, <A href="/golf-course/montrose-medal" target=_self>Montrose</A>, etc.) which are not on the Open rota but offer comparable challenge at half the cost (or less).

This is a great choice for the golfer seeking a Scottish links experience, but at a lower cost and with a less punitive layout than some of the longer, narrower links courses.  A number of very strong holes and a very welcoming staff.

A very scenic and challenging test of golf, with many strong holes in addition to the formidable 18th. A great example of a traditional club which visiting golfers need to give a fair shake, rather than blindly traipsing to the <A href="/golf-course/st-andrews-old" target=_self>Old Course</A>, <A href="/golf-course/carnoustie-championship" target=_self>Carnoustie</A> and <A href="/golf-course/trump-turnberry-ailsa" target=_self>Turnberry</A> - then leaving. Excellent value and a very welcoming staff. I had the good fortune of playing with several long-time members who were recruited by my hotel owner to accompany me during my round. The Links Lodge located 100 feet from the first tee is a must-stay hotel, as it is run by an extremely nice family and offers comfort and an excellent breakfast!

I played Lundin Links during dicey weather conditions (cold, rain, wind) in April 2012 and still came away with an extremely favorable impression of this classic old layout. The course offered wonderful variety throughout and fantastic views from the elevated holes on the back nine. A number of memorable and challenging holes and few if any weak holes that I recall. Despite the relatively short "card" yardage, the weather conditions (and my game?) made Lundin seem like a full-sized test of golf. Greens and bunkers were in great shape and the fairway provided an excellent hitting surface. The clubhouse and pro shop staffs were very welcoming. I would strongly recommend that visiting golfers from the U.S. look past the "prestige" layouts (<A href="/golf-course/st-andrews-old" target=_self>Old Course</A>, <A href="/golf-course/trump-turnberry-ailsa" target=_self>Turnberry</A>, <A href="/golf-course/muirfield" target=_self>Muirfield</A>, <A href="/golf-course/royal-troon-old" target=_self>Troon</A>, etc.) and give a fair shake to the literally dozens of high quality links courses which abound in Scotland, especially within 75 miles of Edinburgh on the east coast (where courses literally run almost in series up and down the coast). Not to imply by any means that visitors shouldn't play the Open rota courses, but Scottish golf does not begin and end with these classics.

I played on a rather cold, windy Spring day in 2012, with intermittent rain.  The greens had been sanded rather heavily the day before (?) and therefore did not allow for normal putting conditions.  Having said this, the course is certainly a classic, must-play layout, with one strong hole after another.  Nice variety and no holes that I recall as being weak.  Bunkering is excellent and provides the expected difficult risk-reward decisions on approach shots and off the tee.  The course played a bit long due to the weather, and scoring conditions are no doubt somewhat better under dryer and warmer weather conditions.  This provides a perfect excuse for a return engagement, as does the excellent hospitality provided by the pro shop and clubhouse!  An easy drive on the close outskirts north of Aberdeen.

I played the course in good weather during early April 2010. Addington is an outstanding collection of interesting holes, including the always-admired par threes. A very traditional, old world, unspoiled feel, with the layout dictated by the interesting heathland ground rather than bulldozers and tricked-up hazards. I played Addington the morning after playing <A href="/golf-course/walton-heath-old" target=_self>Walton Heath</A>, and I'm surprised Addington's international profile isn't a bit more prominent than it is, since I judged it to be in the same league as the more well known Walton Heath (perhaps a function of the '81 Ryder Cup). At any rate, Addington certainly belongs on any London area golf itinerary.

Although seemingly often criticized or faint-praised (holes too similar, par fives not tough enough, etc.), I found Hunstanton to be an extremely worthwhile links course. The conditioning was excellent, a variety of shots were required and there was just enought quirkiness (a blind par three on the backside) to represent a "true" links experience. I visited in April 2010 and played in sunny, windless conditions. Play was a bit slow due to a youth tournament in progress, but I played in just under four hours, so nothing to really complain about. The greens were in top shape and putted very fairly. My only warning to fellow players is that the water described (in the strokesaver books) as behind the green on the par five second is actually a burn running along the left side of the green. This led to an unneeded double bogey after playing pretty much the shots I tried to. I'll have to come back and make up for this blemish! Hunstaton and <A href="/golf-course/royal-west-norfolk" target=_self>Royal West Norfolk</A> make a great one-two punch (and don't forget <A href="/golf-course/royal-cromer" target=_self>Royal Cromer</A> and <A href="/golf-course/sheringham" target=_self>Sheringham</A> in the same area).

I played on a sunny and windless morning in April 2010, and doubt these conditions are replicated too often!  As a result, the course probably played a bit easier for me than is the norm.  Overall a wonderful, old-style, quirky links layout, with positively Olympic bunkering on several holes.  Holes #8 and #9 have been widely and rightfully praised for their unique tidal flat character.  Many other holes are memorable as well.  After teeing off as a single, I wound up letting a group of four playing alternate shot golf pass through me just to be able to play at my "slower" pace (roughly three hours for 18 holes, so not dawdling badly) and drink in the traditional surroundings.  The clubhouse is a trove of golf history and the members proudly showed me some memorobilia such as the century old Suggestion Book.  A must-play course for any trip to this area.

I played on a perfect April morning in 2010, teeing off as a single but later joining a very welcoming and humorous threesome of local players. Many excellent holes among the eighteen, and I don't recall any outright weak holes. Conditioning was excellent and the course is located on a piece of seaside clifftop property which is roughly the equal of <A href="/golf-course/pebble-beach" target=_self>Pebble Beach</A> in terms of grandeur. On this basis, I'm really surprised that Sheringham doesn't enjoy a bit wider and more enthusiastic reputation among international golfers. This course and the nearby <A href="/golf-course/royal-cromer" target=_self>Royal Cromer</A> are both excellent additions to a golf trip aimed at the more well known <A href="/golf-course/hunstanton" target=_self>Hunstanton</A> and <A href="/golf-course/royal-west-norfolk" target=_self>Royal West Norfolk</A>. Both courses are strong in there own right, not mere trip "filler". Staff is also friendly and helpful.

I played Walton Heath fresh off an overnight flight to Heathrow in early April 2010.  The weather was sunny and mild, which is fortunate, since the area received constant rain during the weeks leading up to my visit.   A wonderful, no-tricks layout which often places a premium on accurate tee shots.  Although the heather was cut back severely for winter during my visit, I can imagine this hazard comes into play much more often as the summer progresses.  I'm sure I saved several or more strokes by being able to both find and hit my ball out of what is ordinarilly quite punitive.  The greens were a bit spongy as a result of the recent spring rains, but overall the putting surfaces were of high quality.  The traditional design of Walton Heath required me to hit every club in my bag.  The overall layout was more one of consistent high quality, with subtle demands, and just punishment of poor shots, rather than flashy design features.  Getting in and out of the small parking lot was also a challenge, but the club staff was very welcoming.  Highly recommended for fans of the traditional gentlemanly game.

I played RSG on a clear, windy day in mid-April 2010, teeing off as a single on the 10th hole.  The course was in good condition and I found it to be a very straightforward and fair test.  Most of the trouble was clearly visable, so my challenge (even as a first time visitor) was confined to executing often-lengthy shots around the fast layout (i.e. not guessing where the greens or danger lay).  Greens and fairways were both firm, and well-planned shots were required to get near the pins.  Greens were in great shape and putting presented a fair test of nerves, as many putts were lengthy and/or downhill.  As is usually the case, a second trip around the course would have been welcome in terms of utilizing better strategy.  I'll definitely make time for a return in the future.  The staff was pleasant and efficient, and despite the stature of the course, I was never made to feel unwelcome as a visitor.

Played on a calm, clear Saturday morning in October 2009 and was very glad I made the effort.  A number of very challenging holes, and either a caddy or a second round would have saved some trouble on several blindish shots over dunes.  I agree that this in one of the real classics -  much better priced than Open venues such as The Old Course, Carnoustie, Troon and Turnberry - but equally essential (along with the glorious Prestwick and Machrie) in terms of fully surveying old-fashioned Scottish links.  As noted by others, a round at the nearby, shortish Dunaverty Golf Club near the Mull of Kintyre in Southend is a worthwhile second round in this area.  Basically an executive course layout, with terrain equal to Pebble Beach (or Cruit Island in rural County Donegal, Ireland).  Dunaverty would be a $200 green fee in the U.S. based on scenery alone.

I played Prestwick as the last of seven rounds in October 2009, and it was well worth saving for last. I lucked into a clear, calm somewhat cool morning, and had the course to myself at 8:30 a.m., due to a charity event with a scramble start beginning at noon the same day. The Secretary's suggestion that I hire a caddy (the very helpful and friendly Andrew) was a very good one, as some shots are blind, with real trouble lurking. The classic quirky holes (e.g. #1 Railroad, #3 Cardinal, Himalayas, Alps) completely lived up to their reputation, but I'd be hard-pressed to name a particularly weak hole, aside from the oft-noted short #18. Though catering was suspended due to the afternoon event, I had a quick beer in the history-soaked clubhouse, full of photos and trophies dating from the Old Tom/Young Tom days of the Open to the era of Tiger, Diana and Sandy Lyle. Do yourself a favor and play this course, which I believe is more reasonably-priced (and perhaps more welcoming???) than, for example, <A href="/golf-course/royal-troon-old" target=_self>Troon</A> or <A href="/golf-course/muirfield" target=_self>Muirfield</A> (duh...).

I played on a perfect sunny breezy day in October 2009, after driving from my overnight flight to Glasgow. The round was intended as a warm-up to some of the tougher and more noteworthy Ayreshire courses, and on this basis I can highly recommend WKGC. Not particularly tight, long or difficult, but the course offers nice vistas to Arran and a welcome tuneup for links-style shots. To be clear, it does not compare with championship tracks like <A href="/golf-course/trump-turnberry-ailsa">Turnberry</A>, <A href="/golf-course/western-gailes">Western Gailes</A>, <A href="/golf-course/royal-troon-old" target=_self>Troon</A> or <A href="/golf-course/prestwick" target=_self>Prestwick</A>, but the green fees are much lower as well. Friendly staff in the pro shop and bar. Great location for embarking on the Ardrossan ferry across to Arran

I played the course under very poor conditions (gale force rainstorm; numerous slow four-balls ahead of me in a local competition) - and still loved it.  The many blind shots off the tee and approaching greens make this a course you need to play several times to appreciate.  Course maintenance was very good and the greens were terrific.  Not the easiest place to get to, but the staff is welcoming in its own quirky way.  Highly recommended for all links golf fans - and essential for true afficianados of traditional Scottish golf.  As a side note, the starter shack appears to be an unofficial shrine to busty models from the UK men's magazine "Nuts".

I played on a windy Sunday afternoon in October 2009. The course was pretty crowded, unfortunately including several truly clueless groups shooting high scores and devoting Nicklaus-like attention to each of ~120 shots per man. (Fast play is usually a given on Scottish courses, so this was disturbing. Some firm marshall intervention would have been useful). That aside, the layout is consistently interesting and well worth playing. A great and varied group of par 3s, with nice variety among the par 4s and 5s (short and long, dog-legs, etc.) as well. Not the easiest place to find (several miles inland), and not on a par with classics like <A href="/golf-course/trump-turnberry-ailsa" target=_self>Turnberry</A> and <A href="/golf-course/prestwick" target=_self>Prestwick</A>, but well worth your time if you're playing a number of courses in Ayrshire.

I played Shiskine in perfect fall weather in October 2009.  Since I had the course to myself on a Sunday morning, it only took 2 hours to complete a "full" 12 holes.  Very scenic and roughly half the holes were memorable, notably the blind #3 Crows Nest.  A great value and good fun.

I played this course in June 2007 with several very accomodating members who took obvious pride in the course and were happy to provide assistance to me (keep your drive to the left, hit more club than you think etc.). Pennard is a rather uniquie layout, and includes some delightfully idiosyncratic holes. Highly recommended, along with better known Welsh tracks such as <A href="/golf-course/royal-st-davids" target=_self>St. David's</A> and <A href="/golf-course/royal-porthcawl" target=_self>Royal Porthcawl</A>.

As an overseas member (the best $5 grand I ever spent), I'm naturally inclined to love both the Old and <A href="/golf-course/ballyliffin-glashedy" target=_self>Glashedy</A> courses. Not sure I have a preference, as each has its own style and a number of very strong holes. As noted, the Old Course is a bit shorter, wider and perhaps easier. The pro shop and clubhouse staffs are both extremely friendly and helpful. I've played each course on calm sunny days - and each under stormy conditions. I would strongly suggest targeting the former scenario, and avoiding the latter! Short of a hurricane, tornado, or volcano, it's hard to imagine more natural fury than that of a true Irish squall. Nothing like NAILING a drive 45 yards into a gale wind, or 345 yards with the same wind at your back. While the package tour trade seems to target "name" Irish courses like <A href="/golf-course/lahinch-old" target=_self>Lahinch</A>, <A href="/golf-course/ballybunion-old" target=_self>Ballybunion</A>, <A href="/golf-course/royal-county-down-championship" target=_self>County Down</A>, <A href="/golf-course/waterville" target=_self>Waterville</A> and <A href="/golf-course/royal-portrush-dunluce" target=_self>Portrush</A> (admitedly all fantastic), lesser-known Northwest tracks like Ballyliffin, <A href="/golf-course/castlerock-mussenden" target=_self>Castlerock</A>, <A href="/golf-course/enniscrone-dunes" target=_self>Enniscrone</A>, <A href="/golf-course/county-sligo-championship" target=_self>Rosses Point</A>, <A href="/golf-course/donegal" target=_self>Murvaugh</A>, <A href="/golf-course/portsalon" target=_self>Portsalon</A>, <A href="/golf-course/rosapenna-sandy-hills" target=_self>Rosapenna</A>, <A href="/golf-course/carne" target=_self>Carne</A> and <A href="/golf-course/narin-portnoo" target=_self>Narin & Portnoo</A> are just as deserving of your time. (Also the "9 hole Pebble Beach" - <A href="/golf-course/cruit-island" target=_self>Cruit Island</A>). On second thought, I'd just as soon have the tourists (and their six-hour rounds) stay away! P. McGarey Side note: After your round at Ballyliffin, visit the northernmost pub in Ireland, Farren's Bar at the tip of Malin Head.

I was privileged to play Royal Dublin in October 2008, after playing (and quite liking) the course eight years ago (before some recent hole re-disigns).  The new holes (7 and 8?) are welcome additions to an already-strong layout, on which a series of long, relatively narrow par fours are often buffeted by strong winds.  Course conditioning and pace of play were very good, and the setting on Bull Island is rather unique.  (A virtually domesticated fox came to join us on one tee box, looking for handouts of chocolate).  Side note:  After reserving a tee time as a single,  I was taken under the wing of a very kind member  - and good golfer - who, after picking up my lunch tab (!), insisted that I join him for his earlier tee time.  We played 18 enjoyable holes, as forcasted storms held off, and we watched a European Tour event in the clubhouse afterwards (where he scoffed at my attempt to pick up a round of drinks).  Thanks again Eugene!  Any questions on why I love playing golf in Ireland???  P. McGarey

I played this course in June 2008, several years after playing Rosapenna's <A href="/golf-course/rosapenna-old-tom-morris" target=_self>Old Course</A>. I would have to give Sandy Hills the higher ranking of the two, since the Old Course is a mixture of a handful of GREAT links holes on the front nine and too many (non-links) holes on the back nine with a "cheap muni course" feel. Sandy Hills is tight, and laid out through monumental duneland. Hitting the ball straight off the tee will save you much grief and many strokes - but isn't that always the story in links golf? My round was played during somewhat of a drought, so the rough is probably even tougher than what I experienced. I'd like to stay at the hotel next time, since it looks marvelous. Not the easiest place to get to, but worth the effort. P. McGarey

A great course and a great story (a labor of love for the well-known Irish golf course architect, Mr. Pat Ruddy). A physical setting on a par with ANY classic coastal course (<A href="/golf-course/pebble-beach" target=_self>Pebble Beach</A>, <A href="/golf-course/ballybunion-old" target=_self>Ballybunion</A>, <A href="/golf-course/trump-turnberry-ailsa">Turnberry</A>, <A href="/golf-course/royal-portrush-dunluce" target=_self>Portrush</A>), with a challenging, varied layout and great conditioning. I find the criticism of some of the quirky features ("burn" in front of #18, 125 yard deep green, two auxiliary holes) misguided. While there can be a fine line between gimmickry and idiosyncrasy in course design, the latter is an essential element of classic links such as <A href="/golf-course/lahinch-old" target=_self>Lahinch</A>, <A href="/golf-course/north-berwick-west" target=_self>North Berwick</A> and <A href="/golf-course/st-andrews-old" target=_self>The Old Course</A>. I don't begrudge Mr. Ruddy these personal flourishes. Play this course, which is a bargain compared to most comparable "Top 50" tracks - and certainly compared to many vastly inferior courses. P. McGarey

Not on a par with classics like Ballyliffin, Murvaugh, Portstewart or Castlerock, but well-priced and good fun.  Good for a warm-up round to get the links "feel" going before tackling one of those monsters.  Pat McGarey

Though not as well known or "classic" as neighbors like Baltray, The Island and Portmarnock, Seapoint is a very worthwhile addition to any golf intinerary along Ireland's east coast.  A great warm-up round en route from Dublin airport before tackling County Down or Royal Portrush.

I've played The Island twice, in April 2004 and October 2008, and found the course in excellent shape both times.  It is very easy to reach from the Dublin area and the layout includes a perfect links course balance of long/tough/narrow par fours and quirky holes (i.e. the back-to-back tough par 3 13th and narrow-fairwayed 14th).  The redesign of the par 5 10th is a real success, and removed perhaps the only weak hole on the course.  Possibly realizing that this course suffers a bit of a prestige deficit relative to Portmarnock and other masterpieces (unfairly, in my judgment), the price of green fees is significantly lower at The Island Club, and the staff is more eager to please.  All in all, this course is NOT to be missed by anyone who loves links golf passing through Dublin.

I played the course in perfect weather, sunny and with a light breeze. Having played most of the highly ranked Irish links courses, I can honestly rank Enniscrone on a par with better known courses such as <A href="/golf-course/lahinch-old" target=_self>Lahinch</A>, <A href="/golf-course/donegal" target=_self>Murvaugh</A>, <A href="/golf-course/ballyliffin-glashedy" target=_self>Ballyliffin</A> and others. Why this course doesn't enjoy the same notoriety as the others is a mystery, since the duneland on which the course lies is some of the most dramatic I've seen (HUGE dunes define many of the holes). Perhaps like <A href="/golf-course/carne" target=_self>Carne</A>, it may be considered out-of-the-way, or hard to reach. (Actually, the fact that the course is a relative unknown is probably to be cherished, as anyone who's ever played a six hour round on tourist-clogged <A href="/golf-course/ballybunion-old" target=_self>Ballybunion</A> can attect). The course conditioning was exceptional, with excellent putting surfaces. A real test off the tee, with long, straight drives rewarded and several wayward ones severely punished (i.e. re-tee). Anyone playing Murvaugh, <A href="/golf-course/county-sligo-championship" target=_self>Rosses Point</A> or the numerous links gems in County Donegal should make a point of playing Enniscrone as well. As it lies within roughly an hour of Rosses Point, these two can be played on the same day.

When I visited in June 2007, I really enjoyed the traditional, old world links feel to this course, including the unfussy groundskeeping, the grazing cattle, electric cattle fences, etc. While the conditioning wasn't prissy and perfect, the condition of the fairways and greens was quite good. The quirkiness (intended in the best sense of that word) of one of the closing holes (16? 17?) a short par four reminded me of <A href="/golf-course/north-berwick-west" target=_self>North Berwick</A>. A classic old links not to be missed, and ingeniously wedged into a small parcel of land. Very friendly and helpful staff in the pro shop and restaurant.