Steve MacQuarrie

Steve has played more than 600 golf courses on three continents and in all 50 states, including over half of this site’s Top 100. Despite his mediocre abilities as a golfer, he has at least a broad basis for comparison. His favorites are Cruden Bay, Oakmont, North Berwick, National Golf Links and Royal Melbourne (West). Steve’s partial to firm and fast conditions, to the line of charm, to running approach shots, and to contoured greens. He prefers walking…and playing at a brisk pace. If these are also your interests, you may find his reviews informative.

A resident of New England, he belongs to three clubs there as well as the Donald Ross and Seth Raynor Societies. He tries to review courses that have not been heavily covered here.

When he’s not playing golf, Steve’s other interests include sailing, hiking, skiing and curling.

Reviews


Sort by Rating Filter by country

Royal North Devon 18/09/2018

2nd Devon - Best in Area 53rd England Ranking
England’s oldest course is a museum piece. Little has changed in over a century and the entire experience is history lesson. The golf almost keeps pace, though I found to...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Saunton (East) 17/09/2018

1st Devon - Best in Area 16th England Ranking 40th Britain & Ireland Ranking
The closer one gets to the hole, the better the golf is at Saunton. The green complexes are the strength of the course, with plenty of contours to challenge one’s putting...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Evian 01/09/2018

5th South East France - Best in Area 25th France Ranking
Of a dog walking on its hind legs, Samuel Johnson is reputed to have said, “The wonder is not that it’s not done well, the wonder is that it’s done at all.” The same coul...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Country Club of Orlando 06/05/2018

48th Florida - Best in Area
Ron Forse changed everything but the routing here in 2017………and for the better. While Forse’s specialty is course restoration (he’s done 39 Ross restorations), the bigges...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Hammock Dunes (Creek) 03/05/2018

Gem USA - Best in Area
Though the Creek course touts the fact that no real estate can be developed anywhere on the property, the course still has a lot of the feel of a Florida cartball-only la...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Streamsong (Black) 19/04/2018

6th Florida - Best in Area 95th USA Ranking
“Which of the three Streamsong courses is your favorite?” my caddie asked me as we approached the 18th green. I didn’t answer quickly. It’s an interesting question, but t...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Deerfield 16/04/2018

9th Delaware - Best in Area
Legend has it that when William Gordon was asked to design Stanwich Country Club’s course, he gave them three options and they chose the toughest. Gordon’s work at Deerfi...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

North Palm Beach 09/04/2018

47th Florida - Best in Area
I asked a long-time member if he remembered Seth Raynor’s original design before Jack Nicklaus blew it up to design a completely new layout. “There wasn’t much Raynor lef...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Rustic Canyon 09/01/2018

16th California - Best in Area
When Ventura County officials hired then-unknown golf course architect Gil Hanse to design a course for them in 2001, they probably expected to get an ordinary course not...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Sedgefield (Ross) 13/12/2017

20th North Carolina - Best in Area
One of my rating shortcuts is that courses one sees on television tend to be overrated. (Another is that the quality of a course is in inverse proportion to the size of t...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Woodlands Club 26/11/2017

13th Maine - Best in Area
According to the USGA, the Woodlands is one of the dozen most difficult courses in New England……at least if one considers slope rating as a good criteria for difficulty....

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Old Town 25/11/2017

2nd North Carolina - Best in Area 36th USA Ranking 40th North America Ranking 76th World Ranking
I’d heard all about Perry Maxwell’s “rolls”, but had never seen any until I arrived at Old Town. They might better be called hillocks as most are little humps providing a...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Glenwild 29/09/2017

2nd Utah - Best in Area
I thought I might have been in Brora. On the third hole, two course workers were surrounding the green with an electrified fence. It seems a herd of elk like to use the b...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Paa-Ko Ridge (1st & 2nd) 28/09/2017

1st New Mexico - Best in Area
Paa-ko Ridge has it all…….all the things I don’t like about much of golf course design in the latter half of the 20th century. Walking is possible, but not recommended. I...

Read More >>

TaylorMade

Teton Springs (Headwaters) 28/09/2017

6th Idaho - Best in Area
I didn’t find any springs here, but there were 10 water hazards to contend with. And despite being surrounded by mountains, the course is quite flat. I coulda been in Flo...

Read More >>

TaylorMade