The resort at Celtic Manor was conceived and developed by Sir Terence Matthews. In the late 1970s, Matthews bought a near-derelict manor house and turned it into a small hotel. The hotel became popular and successful, winning the Egon Ronay Best Hotel in Wales award five years on the trot. Matthews’s long-term vision was a golfing complex and no doubt he thought the piece de resistance was the Wentwood Hills course, which opened for play in September 1999, designed by Robert Trent Jones Jnr but we doubt that even in his wildest dreams could he ever have imagined that Celtic Manor would host a Ryder Cup.
A bit of Augusta, a bit of Florida and a lot of Wales, was how they referred to Wentwood Hills and they were absolutely right. There was a coalition of British and American features, which Trent Jones Jnr described as “a true championship course that combines a hilly landscape with the more traditional links-like features of an estuary. There's great variety here”. But all that was before Celtic Manor became the chosen venue for the 2010 Ryder Cup when a decision was made to create a new course for staging golf’s greatest team event.
In July 2007, the first course to be built specifically for the Ryder Cup opened its tees for play. The course, aptly called “Twenty Ten”, is the result of collaboration between the European PGA, golf course architects and tour pros; the objective was to create a unique Ryder Cup venue.
The new Twenty Ten course measures a beefy 7,493 yards with par set at 71. It features nine dramatic new holes that have been routed through the Usk Valley, as well as nine holes from the former Wentwood Hills course that have been extensively re-fashioned. The new design ensures not only that each hole is an exacting test but also that there is an amphitheatre for great spectator viewing.
With water hazards on half of its holes and no fewer than six signature holes, Twenty Ten represents a serious test and also plenty of risk-and-reward challenges. Variety is a keyword of Twenty Ten, where a number of holes on the outward nine have a links-like feel before you enter the lake-lined middle section prior to reaching the elevated closing stretch of four holes which witnessed plenty of memorable Ryder Cup drama.
Wentwood Hills was a formidable championship layout but Twenty Ten is perhaps even more frightening, especially if your game is off tune. If you are a lover of all things traditional, then Celtic Manor is probably not for you. But if you are seeking thrills and an exciting and tough challenge, then Twenty Ten will fit the bill perfectly. Celtic Manor are allowing limited public play on the Ryder Cup course, so make the most of it before they close their tees for the sole enjoyment of the new prestigious Twenty Ten Club members.
Is it possible for a course to be very good, but at the same time very over-rated? The old Wentwood Hills layout was, in my opinion, much better and a more slick design. The 2010 kept some of the old layout, and these are the best holes on the course, the newer ones are almost without exception... long.
There just is no subtlety to the 2010, its a "hit ball long" "hit approach over water" type of course. Its not a bad course, quite the opposite, its just so manufactured as a golfing challenge that it belongs on a video game rather than as a must play.
I have marked it as good, as it is very clearly a championship golf course, both in style and presentation, and the Celtic Manor know how to treat guests, no issue with anything other than the course for my money, and even then, if you take it for what it is, you wont be disappointed.
Host and built especially for the 2010 Ryder Cup, this course is built on farmland not too dissimilar to that of The Belfry, albeit with more elevation. As you would expect for a course built specifically for a Ryder Cup, the scale here is large, and the main design consideration was to challenge the worlds best golfers.
This is done with two main things- distance and water. The course plays a staggering 7,493 yards from the tips, and there is water everywhere. Therefore playing from the correct tees is crucial to having an enjoyable round.
With it being designed for pros, there are lots of forced carries which could definitely see an amateur player come unstuck. Also, despite all this winter there aren’t any particular memorable holes that I find myself thinking back on months later.
The course claims to have 6 signature holes, and whether this is true or not, the following are hoels that I enjoyed. The par 4 5th had a nice approach shot, with a stream short of the green (used a lot here). Following this, the 6th is a cape style par 4 which means there is a strategic, risk/reward tee shot.
Aside from the course, the general facilities here are top notch, with lockers engraved with players from the 2010 Ryder Cup, and the brilliant halfway house. Straight after the halfway house, there is a good par 3 with a slopey green and some pot bunkers.
The last is a good matchplay hole, similar to 18th at The Belfry, forcing players to decide whether to lay up or try and reach the green in 2. Overall, I would say the architect probably did a good job of building a course suitable to hold a modern Ryder Cup, but that doesn’t mean it’s a course I would want to play every day.
A good course thats always in good condition. Gets more credit than it should because of its Ryder Cup pedigree. The hospitality is great, and it's worth playing for the right price, just for the experience.
However there is much better golf to be found not far away on the south coast at Southdown, Pennard and Porthcawl.
A technical course, specifically built to challenge the modern tour pro. This means it has lots of length, lots of sand, and lots of water. As everything has been artificially created, the hazards have been carefully positioned to test the best golfers in the world. Staggered bunkers pinch in the fairways at driving distance, do you lay up, skirt them, or try to carry them? Forced carries over water are everywhere, with many fairways angled across you so you have to choose how much of the carry to take on. The site is fairly exposed, it felt like the wind was funneled through the valley and made a huge impact on shot selection. The greens were quick, immaculate and well guarded.
It's not a beautiful course, or even a classic course, however there is a good mix of holes and a balance of risk and reward, and I liked the way this course has been built with thought to match play. Only thing missing for me is a short par 3. This course asks a lot of questions, and really tests your ball striking.
Practise facilities and clubhouse are top notch as you would expect.
Course was in superb condition especially considering it was winter.
REALLY enjoyed my round here.
Great to play such a suddenly famous course.
Typical Ryder Cup course....everything is big, but really enjoyable challenge.
Those venturing and looking for pampering on the level of a Royal Family visit will certainly get that when going to Celtic Manor Resort. The attention paid by staff in assisting guests is clearly front and center. However, the golf side is more of support function rather than a lead role.
Hosting a Ryder Cup clearly put Celtic Manor on the world stage. Being the first facility to lay such a claim in Wales will always be a part of the history books.
The Twenty Ten course has been described by a few as being an "Americanized" and frankly the amount of water that players come in contact with reminds me of Florida golf, albeit on a hillier site. The holes are predictably dull with mindless large bunkers and greens -- more cosmetic addition than strategic calculation.
Playing a Ryder Cup course will mean a good deal to many and those who see golf as just a part of their time at Celtic Manor will likely enjoy their stay. Golf connoisseurs will more than likely leave disappointed and wondering what all the fuss is about and have paid a hefty sum to draw that conclusion.
There are many people who see the "golf experience" as one including a whole slew of elements. How did the staff respond to your needs that day? Was the food and drink exceptional? How comfortable were the towels and how immersive were the shower heads and so on and so forth. These inclusions, for me, are the sideshow -- they have a role -- but more in the shadows than the stark daylight of the course's architecture.
Celtic Manor is about the creature comforts. To use the American expression - the golf dimension is clearly the tail wagging the dog here.
by M. James Ward
Having seen the course on television a number of times it pretty much delivered exactly what I was expecting. It’s a course set up for modern day championship golf with large bunkers and lots of water being the main obstacles to avoid. Some years ago it would have been called an ‘American’ style design but we now have a number of these types of courses in the UK.
Playing some of the holes, especially over the closing stretch on the higher part of the course, brought back memories of the 2010 Ryder Cup and it was amazing to be able to play the same holes as the super stars of both the USA and European teams. On arrival you are also allocated a locker in the clubhouse which was used by one of the players, mine was that of 2009 Open Champion Stewart Cink. A nice touch.
Everything was in excellent condition out on the course; from the tees to the fairways to the greens and especially the aprons. The welcome and service, from arrival to departure, was outstanding…. as you would expect from a five-star resort!
Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.
Having walked the Twenty Ten during the days of the Wales Open it was time to play the course and an Open pairs betterball in October provided an ideal opportunity. A well organised event with everything off-course excellent. Course was in good condition although winter rules were in operation (balls did collect mud) and greens were a bit slow; interestingly one heavy shower resulted in a flooded green but compared to other reviewers we had good conditions following a dry spell. I'm not a great lover of modern style courses but was pleasantly surprised. Course reminds me of Machynys except more interesting and water more in play. A good solid start to the course, including the heavily bunkered par 5 2nd and short 3rd over water. Gets going at the 5th (which is an excellent par 4) and the 6th with water all down the right hand side and a right side pin making an exciting shot over the water. From here until 13 a series of good holes, with water on holes 12 and 13 very much in play. Hole 14 is a fantastic golf hole, one of the best I have played; a sort of double dog-leg and having played to the fairway left of the water, you are then faced with an enticing shot over the water to the green and if you area just a couple yards short of the green you roll back down the bank into the water (which i managed). After that I found 15 a bit disappointing; not really a risk and reward hole off the yellows as not much trouble beyond the trees if you take the straight route. Unlike previous reviewers (and it is all about opinion) I thought 16 and 17 were a bit bland and generally thought after 14 the course just petered out a bit. Holes 5 to 14 were really good though
Played the 2010 as part of a Society stay and play trip to Celtic Manor which was great fun - nice hotel with first class facilities. Good nights out in Caerleon and Cardiff. The club house is great, as are the shuttle and practice areas. However...in a wet Summer the course was extremely damp and very slow, with the memorable holes left until the end by which time we were frustrated and a bit bored. The least enjoyable of the 3 courses.