Downfield - Angus & Dundee - Scotland

There are a lot of trees at Downfield - beautiful trees admittedly (it’s a bit like playing in an arboretum) - but, for me, there are too many holes that feel similar and not enough stand-out moments. That said, it’s a very strong course - you can see why it’s been used for professional and top amateur events over the years - and it’s certainly worth playing, but in such a strong area for golf, there are lots of other options that I’d put higher.

One real oddity that’s been mentioned before is the ordering of the nines. There must be a reason why it’s the 9th rather than the 18th that finishes right in front of the clubhouse, but I can’t think what it is. It also means that the finishing four holes comprise the three shortest par 4s and the shortest par 3, and that the first six par 4s you play are all between 407 and 434 yards. Very odd.

Hard when playing Downfield to believe that you are but a few miles from Carnoustie and the sea.

Tremendous tree lined track with plenty of ball losing opportunities for golfers like me !

Well worth a visit. Very playable, well designed and well kept. One of my favourite courses, doesn't have the same beauty or potential as Letham, and not quite as good all round as Rosemount but better than all the other local parklands.

This is certainly an excellent parkland course, but with respect to the club and its designer, the layout is wrong. The 9th finishes right in front of the clubhouse windows, providing entertainment for the clubhouse spectators and a nervy approach for players, but the 18th finishes in complete obscurity at the back of the car park. It would be easy enough to switch the course around!

Oh dear! What has happened to the condition of this wonderful course. Played it yesterday and the greens were very poor bumpy and slow. I know it has been a difficult winter but it is now mid May and I would have certainly expected better and greens on other courses in the local area are excellent. Hope this is just a temporary blip.

Had not played Downfield for a few years so yesterday on a lovely autumn day presented the perfect opportunity. I think I had forgotten just how good a course it is. Like many of the reviewers I am not a great lover of parkland golf but this is on exception. It was in beautiful condition with well-defined fairways and excellent greens for this time of year. From the demanding opening hole through to the terrific 18th this is a delight. The huge trees that line every hole are simply beautiful in their seasonal hues - how can there be so many different shades of green and brown? So many excellent holes: the par 5 4th has been improved with the addition of a pond lurking just to the right of he green, 11 and 12 are great holes and they are followed by two splendid long holes. I can't quite go to six balls for Downfield - five-and-a-half would be just right - so it will have to be five. But get there if you can (and their green fee in October is under £25.) Downfield should be much higher in the list; it is a far better course than nearby Rosemount which has an unaccountably favourable reputation. The only parkland course as good is Newmachar.

I played Downfield on Friday 20th August and found the whole experience fantastic. I have heard friends mention what a great course it was and that I should try to play it. The chance finally arrived on the 20th and I was not disappointed. Having played the Championship course at Carnoustie in the morning it had a lot to live up to and it did. There are some stunning golf holes. You need to be able to control your ball around the course. All areas of the course were in first class order and would have been able to grace any golf tournament. Particular favourites were the 4th with its great views, 9th long par 4 that test driving and your approach shots, 11th with its pond and burn in front, 16th magical stroke play hole and 18 which is an excellent finishing hole. If you get a chance to play you must. It is a truly great parkland course and is now my no1 in the area ahead of Rosemount.

Many many moons ago, before I discovered the “Links effect” I was a parkland golfer. There, I have said it, my dirty golfing secret is out, and confession is indeed good for the soul. But thanks to PG Wodehouse and Jim McCann (who sometimes dresses like Bertie Wooster, see our Shiskine page if you don’t believe me) I have now clutched links golf firmly to my bosom, and it is now my first love.

Sometimes however, I feel a tug of the old heartstrings that encourage me to return to my golfing genesis. That journey took me on the road and the miles to Dundee, to play Downfield. I have been aware of Downfield for decades as I can remember Peter Alliss hosting a programme from there in the 1970’s so it has always been on my playlist. First impressions of the place were extremely favourable with the Pro offering to put back our tee time to allow us a bit of respite from our 2 hour drive from Glasgow. Such was our eagerness to play the course however, we decided to press on.

The first thing that struck me about the place was the proliferation of trees, more than Percy Thrower could shake a stick at, an arborists dream, all colours, shapes and sizes beautifully sited to assist in the shaping and framing of holes, just wonderful. One disappointment was that the 4th and 5th holes were still on winter greens with the 4th, in particular a fantastic hole, c’est la vie. This was more than made up for by the quality of the rest of the course with the 13th and 15th the only holes that I didn’t really enjoy. The rest I found good or very good (2,7,8,14 and 16) but my 2 favourite holes were the celebrated 11th, Paddler’s Joy a 434 yards dogleg from the regulars with a double greenside water hazard and the 12th, an aesthetically pleasing short par 3, together giving Downfield a mini Amen Corner if you like. So in the end I didn’t really miss the links land too much as Downfield was worth every minute of the 4 hour round trip for 3 guys who simply revelled in going back to their roots. MPPJ.

Enjoyable but not overly demanding inland track which was in excellent condition when I played in late May 2008. Afforded very warm welcome from both staff and members.

Played 36 holes here on 20 April 2007 for excellent value of £49 (includes coffee & bacon rolls on arrival & soup and sandwiches at lunch). The course has many excellent holes - with perhaps the 11th being the pick of the crop. There is a good selection of par 3s - a very long 3rd, the 6th and the 12th stand out. This is not an easy course with many tight driving holes - and the sound of balls clattering into the trees was an all too frequent sound for our group. To score well, you certainly need to be straight off the tee. It's not overly long - so if you do hit the fairways, you will be rewarded with a good score. Our only gripe was the poor condition of the greens. Bearing in mind this course is a final qualifying course for the open this year at Carnoustie - I hope they get sorted - but when we played they were in a dreadful state - and this marred our enjoyment. Had the greens been as good as say, Blairgowrie, then I would have given it a much better rating - I'm sure that in the summer when the sun is shining the greens will be excellent - so if you intend to come and play, it might be worth paying a visit here in the summer/autumn. jbwt