Gleneagles (Queen's) - Perth & Kinross - Scotland

In an ideal World for your first visit to Gleneagles you wouldn't have to choose between Brawn and Beauty, and you'd play both Kings and Queens. Complementary in nature, they make a brilliant 36 hole destination particularly if you can spend the night at the hotel (yes 36 - we won't mention the drive thru 18 on the other side of the road !) The Queen's has some very satisfying holes around the hillside, and the way the course wends its way through a valley to its conclusion is beautiful and memorable.

The Gleneagles Queen's course is a delight and even prettier than the neighboring King's course. It is like playing in an arboretum or nature park at times such is its beauty.

It is not a real golfing challenge due to the lack of length on many of its holes and the lack of truly punitive bunkers, but nonetheless it is a joy to play and one should play it if they are staying at the hotel for 2-3 or visiting the area for that length of time.

The green complexes, in general are not quite as strong as on the King's course but the greens themselves are the equal.

I particularly liked the 4th, the 6th (with those magnificent views), 8th, 10th, the pretty short 13th with the loch, the long 14th and the fabulous green on 17.

It might be the prettiest inland golf course in the world, if you ignore some in New Zealand.

I agree with Ed Battye, the Queen’s course maybe the best course in the world under 6,000 yards. Can anyone propose a better one?

Yes, Gleneagles is expensive but you get what you pay for. I’d play the Queen’s ten times rather than subjecting myself (again) to the PGA Centenary.

Some box tickers ignore the Queen’s in favour of playing the King’s, listed by some in the World Top 100, and the infamous Ryder Cup course. Who doesn’t want to play a modern Ryder Cup course once? I’d happily circle around the Queen’s and play it over and over again.

Sometimes there’s no rhyme or reason. Yes there are a few “ordinary” holes but anyone who can’t appreciate “Drum Sichty” where the views become mesmeric and “Pint Stoup” with its green set enchantingly in a little dell, are comatose.

If the outrageous green complex at “Hinny Mune” (the 250-yard par three 17th) and the elevated tee shot over the little loch on the home hole do not stir your soul then you are officially departed.

Another Braid design the Queen opened in 1917. It is not long but it has character. I would describe the first hole as welcoming, right off the tee is best. The second is a real short par 3, but whatever you do, do not miss left. The 3rd hole is along par four. Plan for an extra club. The next hole of note is the 7th. A short par 5, favor the right side to provide a green light to reach the green in two. The 8th is a birdie oppty, blind tee shot where you should favor the left hand side, The 9th is a long tough par 4. To give yourself the best chance at par favor the right side off the tee and take an extra club for your approach shot. The 10th is a long par 4, Off the tee favor the right hand side of the bunker and on the approach the green sits in a bowl. Errant shots left or right should kick down towards the green, After the 10th you are faced with the ridiculous of a a forced 10 minute break at the halfway house. Crazy, let's make golf take more time? The 11th is a short par 4 dogleg left, favor the right side off the tee the green is protected by 5 bunkers, but definitely a birdie hole. The 12th while it appears to be a long par 4 is misleading. A well struck drive will roll down the hill to set up a 100 yard pitch to the green. Be careful, there is no bell and we almost killed the guys ahead of us. Normally i am not a fan of back to back par 3s but the Queen pulls it off nicely, the 13th is short with a water hazard tight and 14 is an elevated multi-tiered green. The 15th is a driveable par 4, a super risk reward hole where a ball left or right can lead to a double. The Queen is a par 68, comfortable but not exciting and sadly grossly overpriced

In my view it is too highly ranked, with 20 courses lower ranked but better. Definitely not as good as the Kings, although a composite course would be the stuff of dreams, with the Queens offering the 6th, the world class 10th, 12th and possibly the 18th (against the wind when I played).

I played the Queen's course on a mild but sunny August day after weeks of rain in Scotland. The course would probably be considered short by most at a hair under 6000 yards, however soft fairways and a prevailing westerly wind make the course feel much longer, especially with seven par 4s over 400 yards and a par of only 68!

My favourite hole is the 421 yard, par 4, 10th ‘Pint stoup’. The tee shot is very open, usually downwind and extremely inviting with the Ochil Hills in the background. The second shot is the fun bit of the hole for me as it demands an accurate shot to a green positioned in a bowl between two copses of pine trees. I hooked my drive a bit left into the light rough, but then felt great satisfaction from lifting a floaty seven iron shot over tall pines on the left to within 15 feet.

Many of the other long par 4s including the 6th, 9th, 12th and 18th are great holes, although may play tough for the average golfer who may find they love them if they score well, but hate them if they become a bit of a slog. I actually particularly enjoyed some of the shorter par 4s which come towards the second half of the round and offer some well earnt relief from the trickier holes. The 8th, for example, is fun little hole that seems to naturally guide the drive for a nice approach spot. The 252 yard 15th is a great risk and reward, driveable par 4. The 378 par 4 16 also great fun to drive on as the natural contours from the bunkers can easily kick a good drive forward towards a small wedge shot.

Overall, a great course that is by no means easy, but which offers some good birdie opportunities.

It’s possible, and most likely probable, that the Queen’s at Gleneagles is the best golf course under 6,000 yards. Not just in Scotland but anywhere.

Yet don’t be fooled into thinking this is a short layout which can be overpowered or that it’s a fiddly little thing lacking any real substance. The par of 68 (SSS 69) ensures that the 5,926-yard James Braid masterpiece, played up and over large natural ridges, through wooded valleys and occasionally across tranquil lochans, is more than a true test of golf.

Indeed the first six holes all head roughly in the same direction and play into the prevailing wind. There is nothing short or easy about any of them with three of the four two-shotters topping the 400-yard mark. The best hole of this opening sequence is undoubtedly the sixth, a gloriously beautiful hole of 437-yards, which plays through a valley before rising up to a green sitting proud on an angled ridge plateau.

If you’ve come through the opening third of the course unscathed (I didn’t) then you do have some opportunities to put a score together over the next few holes as well as on the much shorter inward half but there are certainly no gimmies and still a couple of card-wreckers to follow.

The weakest holes on the course in my opinion are the first, 11th, 13th and 18th but they are by no means poor holes. The other 14 are either very good, excellent or in the case of the sixth, 12th, 15th and 17th truly superb.

Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.

The Queen’s Course is one of the prettiest courses you will find anywhere on your travels and makes for a great 36 hole day along with the majestic King’s course. With seven par-4’s measuring over 400 yards and only one par-5, the layout is far from the easy round that many people expect. Add in the wonderful scenery at every turn and it’s difficult not to be distracted from the task at hand. The afternoon before our game a storm of epic proportions hit the resort closing all three courses for the remainder of the day but the following morning there were no after effects whatsoever. The fairways were dry, bunkers raked and the greens putted beautifully. The five par-3’s are not only very attractive but great fun, the 13th and 14th by the loch being particularly good holes. The 13th is a little beauty and the 14th a bit of a brute, 180 yards uphill with a wickedly tiered green awaiting. The 17th is another cracker, over a valley with anything short right being gobbled up by a large bunker. As well as the longer par-4’s, the 10th being my favourite, dog-legging left to a green tucked away behind trees, there are also a number of shorter ones. The downhill 8th and 11th being excellent birdie chances and the 252 yard 15th offering you the option of having a crack at the green if you dare. The 18th is a memorable finishing hole, driving downhill over an attractive water hazard towards the welcoming clubhouse. During your round don’t forget a quick stop at the well appointed halfway house. We spent 20 minutes there as there was a gap behind us and still strolled round in less than 3 and a half hours. With the PGA course offering a different style of golf and the Academy nine adding even more options Gleneagles is undoubtedly one of the world’s best golf destinations. Brian W

Played Queens early June. Fairways springy greens firm but not overly fast. A typical misty wet morning didn't dampen our spirits with view of some stunning natural holes cut into the glen. A nice array of longish par 4's going out mixed in with a plateau green par 3 second and a reachable par 5 seventh (which I did followed on by the obligatory three put) alas! The back nine is arguably better highlights include back to back par 3's around a lake. Followed on by Real risk reward 280 yard par 4, push your tee shot and you will rack up a big number! Overall a spectacular par 68 not a push over by any means but willing to reward good play (shot an 80 off a 14 h'cap) . Must lastly mention the whole experience , I've been lucky enough to stay at Gleneagles half a dozen times and no other resort comes close.

I played this venue in consecutive days with the King's and also watched some holes at the PGA Centenary during this year´s JW Championship, so comparison can be done with no risk to be unfair. I believe the Queen's Course is less challenging than the King´s but a lot more true, with less blind shots and with nicer views although the three courses have very similar landscapes. The course itself is very fun to be played, with a lot of risk-reward holes but one thing I really don´t like is the lack of par 5s, the only one is number 7. But in the back nine you have three excellent par 3s (actually for most golfers 14th can be a par 3.5) and a very nice reachable par 4 (15th), where you can birdie or double bogey easilly, if tee shot is pushed the magic word "reload" will be heard. and after 10 days in Scotland, hole number 12th may be one of the best of the week, where if you are conservative you will face a long tough second shot, but if you take risk the approach can be a wedge. The course was in excellent shape despite some rain and the greens rolled very true and fast. If you travel to Scotland, you have to go and play as many links courses as you can, but a visit to Gleneagles (an amazing hotel and great staff) will for sure pay the bill, don´t miss it!