Gullane No.3 may well be dwarfed by the neighbouring No.1 and No.2 courses of Gullane Golf Club but it is still a superb little links in its own right, providing plenty of pleasure for members and visitors alike since its introduction in 1910.
Length off the tee will never be a major issue on a course that is only 5,252 yards long. Strategic greenside bunkering and slick putting surfaces – on a par with the other two Gullane links – certainly are issues to be considered. The Standard Scratch Score is two under the par of 68 so this is as near to recreational golf that you will get at a serious golf complex.
The conditioning is every bit as good as you will find on the No.1 and No.2 courses so don’t think that playing No.3 course will mean you are golfing at an inferior venue – far from it. It is plain and simply a tighter, scaled down version of all that exists on its bigger golfing siblings next door.
The first and last three holes are played on the flat around the visitor’s clubhouse with the 4th to the 15th holes set out over and around Gullane Hill. And what a vista awaits after the steep climb up the 4th hole to the 5th tee at the top of the hill!
The full splendour of the Gullane courses spreads out before you as you look down to the southern shores of the Firth of Forth, with the other two Gullane courses to the right and Luffness New on the flatter ground to the left. Beyond Luffness, on the other side of Aberlady Bay, you can just make out the Kilspindie and Craigielaw courses.
And, as if that were not enough, there is the tantalizing distant view of those other great golfing destinations, Leven, Lundin and Elie on the other side of the Firth. Is it any wonder that many seasoned Scottish golfers believe this to be one of the most inspiring vantage points on any golf course?
Only one of the twelve par fours on the card is over 400 yards, indeed two of them – the 3rd and 4th – are under 300 yards in length. All are comfortably in range after the tee shot is played so scoring well on Gullane No.3 is all about approach play and putting.
There is only one par five on the card – even that is only 443 yards long – and of the five par threes, the pick of these is the 176-yard 15th hole which plays back down Gullane Hill to a green way below tee level near one of the opening holes on No.2 course. It is a genuinely thrilling way to finish an excursion up, over and around the hill that began a couple of hours earlier.
Gullane No. 3 the final part of this golfing trilogy for me, played in a howling zephyr like breeze fuelled by a golfers salad consisting of scotch pie, chips and beans. The course while not as long as it's siblings certainly had the feel of more severe and penal rough, clever bunkering and excellent green layouts again presented in tip top condition. Whilst the conditions did not help scoring this was as enjoyable as it can be, and there is not. There is not a paper width between all three courses all delightful
Feel a bit bad only giving the course 3.5 but that's how it sits in comparison to the ratings of the others in the area. That isn't to say by any means it's a poor course, in fact the two of us who played there really enjoyed it. The course was more what I would define as holiday golf with much shorter yardages to contend with and much less windy than the No 2 course we had played the previous two days. It actually made a nice change and we managed to play 36 holes on it during the day without it feeling a slog in any way.
A nice mix of holes and some quirkiness thrown in for good measure which is sometimes missing from other longer layouts. You still have to be on your game though to score on it.
Probably more of a warm up course for No 1 and 2 but very enjoyable in its own way.
I've been to Gullane a couple of times to play no2 and no3. Although I fancy playing no1, it is hard to justify spending so much more when 2 and 3 are routed over the same terrain and appear to offer only a slightly inferior experience. As a complex, including the children's course too, Gullane is golfing heaven, and it must be an amazing place to learn the great game. The only drawback is that the weather can be brutal: I've only played there in summer and it has been wild, wet and windy.
No3 is a bit of a treat. It makes a welcome change from tough championship links golf. The greens are small, but still the conditioning is great. Maybe this is what it feels like to be Dustin Johnson and have a wedge into every green.
I wouldn't make a pilgrimage to this course, but as a bolt on to a round on one of the championship courses, or a warm up round for a golf tour, this is a great option.
Great course, the shortest of the 3 and equally as pretty as no.2 which we played the same day. Having walked and carried in the morning we hired trikes from the pro shop which added a fun element to an already amazing place. The par 3 16th is a real treat hitting down the steep hill in strong wind makes for an interesting hole.
Gullane has the absolute luxury of three great and challenging courses. With them all running from the town and up, over and around Gullane Hill, before coming back to the town. I have played all three and although they are all similar in style and layout there is very little difference in the quality and when the cost is factored in the third and least promoted course is actually the best value in my eyes. It is the shortest and currently plays to a par of 67. I think the 18th has been converted from a par 4 into a par 3, so the practice area could be expanded.
There are six par 3's, one par 5 and the rest are par 4's.
In calm conditions the course does play short but with the normal breeze it certainly is a fair test.
The land in this area, which supports so many courses, has excellent turf conditions, a pleasure to play form and I have never seen it in poor condition, through winter as well.
The greens are all challenging and play at a good pace year round, the putts run very true and you cannot blame a poor 'dance floor'.
The course is obviously hidden in among its immediate neighbours, let alone the ones slightly further afield (Muirfield and North Berwick etc). However considering the cost and the quality of the course I would not hesitate to recommend it to anyone. Well worth a visit!
Gullane is wild and windy so the short #3 course offers a manageable test when the gusts are at their worst. It has some bland holes, some real fun and memorable ones, and plenty of great views.
The more mundane holes are on the clubhouse side of the road. They sort of connect you not just to the road but the sprawl of land beyond and the bleak Gullane hill which dominates the landscape. There always seems to be the silhouette of a golfer on the horizon, probably with his bag blowing over.
I think of links golf being relatively flat but Gullane is anything but. Once over the road the fun and funk starts, there’s a nice mix of lengths, elevated tees and interesting par 3s. My favourite was the 11th, the green’s carved into the hill and anything short falls backwards. The par 4s usually offer options where you can choose iron or driver from the tee, there was some thick rough but nothing too nasty. I guess the worst of it’s up at #1.
The turf across Gullane is amazing, maybe the best I’ve played on. As an introduction to links this is an ideal course, and if you’re a veteran you can get round this in a couple of hours plus it’s excellent value. It can get cold and gnarly but the views across the firth more than make up for it.
Great review Phil. I will be playing #3 and #2 in just over a week as part of the World Hickory Open Championship.
Cheers, Gullane's an ideal place for hickories. Have a brilliant time!
Gullane No. 3 is the shortest of the three courses at Gullane Golf Club. Designed by famed golfer Willie Park Jr. and opened in 1910, this true links layout offers small greens, narrow fairways and thick rough. The back tees only measure out at to 5,259 yards but this par-68 will certainly test your patience and accuracy when the wind kicks up – as it usually does. No. 3 is a tricky little course with plenty of bunkers and much more elevation changes than most others in the area.
Some of my most memorable holes were the 4th, a straight uphill par-4 into the prevailing winds where each of my shots rolled backwards. The 6th hole is ranked the toughest. It’s only 342 yards, but it is uphill, into the prevailing crosswinds, with one of the largest and more contoured greens on the course.
The most stunning view is from the 7th tee blocks. You are now perched on the highest point on the golf course with panoramic views of Aberlady Bay and the Firth of Forth beyond. At 311 yards, this straight downhill par-4 is driveable but buyer beware as there is four pot bunkers protecting the front of the green to keep you honest.
The most controversial hole must be the 15th hole, a straight downhill par-3 where you need to land your tee shot about 35 yards in front and watch it trickle down to the green. It felt more like a toboggan run and almost impossible to hold the green. Thank goodness for the amphitheatre mounding on the back side to prevent my ball from rolling onto the street.
This a perfect course to play with hickory clubs and still a challenge with modern equipment. Even though it is often over shadowed by its older siblings, this course will give you the true links feel without the punishing distance.
To read more about Dave Finn's golf travel adventures visit www.golftavelandleisure.com
We finally had the chance to "complete the set" at Gullane, as always an enjoyable place to visit and play golf. It was probably more than a five club wind, drivers out of the screws were going 150 yards into the wind. As such thank god we were on number 3, we ran round in 2.5 hrs rather than the ordeal that 1 or 2 would have been. The greens were excellent yet with no oscillations, but we had generous gimme rules otherwise it would have taken longer! For pure fun it can't be beaten, my downwind teed up putter on 15 went through the back, and at £28 exceptional value. It might be the first gullane we return to.
The No.3 course has a certain charm and character to it. Not that the other two don’t but this, the shortest of the three, has a few more eccentric holes. The greens are smaller and even though you are often going in with a short iron they are still tricky to find and as equally well bunkered as the other two courses.
In many ways this course makes a refreshing change to the relentlessly strong championship golf that No.1 and No.2 serve up and provides lots of fun shots. It’s also the perfect length to make it an excellent choice for those looking to play two courses on the same day and still have the energy to enjoy some food and a beer in the clubhouse.
In terms of the stand-out holes; the second is a delightful short par three to a tiny green and surrounded by bunkers where only the most accurate shot will find the putting surface. There are a string of excellent short par fours throughout the course but especially on the front nine with the 3rd, 7th & 9th particularly standing out.
Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.
Like many of you, I have been to this area sampling the links golf delights many times without giving Gullane no. 3 a second thought, maybe thinking it would be OK to play with the kids if they ever came along. How wrong I have been!
This time, it found its place on our itinerary on a relatively windless Saturday morning and what a delight it was. All of a sudden it was not a brutal game of survival from the tee onwards, but a sophisticated game of cat-and-mouse with the course. On almost every tee, you have a choice between playing long or short, right or left and every option will give you a very different perspective on the green. They say that Augusta is a second-shot course. Not having played there I cannot opine, but Gullane No. 3 certainly is and very much the kind of firm-and-fast golf which it is worth travelling to experience, so next time, ignore your skeptical friends and put this course onto the itinerary. At the very least, they will thank you afterwards for throwing in some variety!