The Island in Ireland was once on an island. It’s now attached to the mainland but it’s still an isolated peninsula-like spur of links land, sandwiched between the Irish Sea, the beach of Donabate and the Broadmeadow estuary.
Few people know about The Island Golf Club, despite the fact that the course is over 100 years old and has featured in numerous ranking tables over the years. One leading UK golf magazine once commented: “The best course in Ireland you have never heard of. Play it and tell no-one.”
Bernard Darwin was certainly aware at the turn of the 20th century because in his book, The Golf Courses of the British Isles, he wrote extensively about Royal Dublin and Portmarnock and said: “It would be unfair to omit some mention of Malahide – ‘the Island’ – where there is golf to be had, which may legitimately be called sporting in the best sense of the word.”
Ten Irishmen, known as the “Syndicate”, founded the club in 1890 and they needed a ferryman to take them from Malahide across the estuary to play golf. When they were set to return to the mainland, they would hang a large red and white disc from the clubhouse wall to signal that they were ready for pickup by the water taxi. A “Syndicate” of ten ran the Island Golf Club until the late 1950s and since then, the club has opened up its membership.
This is a no-frills golf course. There is nothing artificial, it’s simply harmonious and in tune with its surroundings. Some of the most shaggy, rugged and looming sand dunes imaginable provide natural and distinct amphitheatres for many of the holes. In the summer, if you are unfortunate and wayward enough to find the dunes, be careful to avoid trampling on the wild dune flowers. The club is quite rightly proud of its flora. Expect to hear the hypnotic song of the lark – there are plenty to be heard and the skylark is the Island’s club emblem.
It is unclear who originally laid out the course, but the Island has been revised by Fred W. Hawtree, Eddie Hackett and more recently by Martin Hawtree. The challenge invariably comes from the wind and the ability to find the greens; these putting surfaces are some of the very best around. There are some great holes to choose from, but the signature hole and our favourite is the long par three 13th, measuring over 220 yards. There is a bail-out option short of the green to the left, but the brave will take on the beach, hoping that they strike the ball cleanly and that they have the right club in their hand.
Dublin is certainly awash with outstanding links golf courses and the Island is right up there with the very best. No trip to Dublin would be complete without a pint or two of the black stuff and a round at the Island.
Here’s a list of important tournaments recently hosted by The Island Golf Club: Irish Qualifying Competition for The Open Championship 2005, European Youths Amateur Team Championship 2004, Irish Ladies Close Championship 2004, Irish PGA Championship 1999, Irish Close Championship 1998. Darren Clarke holds the professional course record with a 63.
Mackenzie & Ebert were engaged to produce a master plan for the club in 2016 which resulted in the club reworking the bunkers on five holes (5th, 6th, 10th, 15th and 17th) over a couple of winters, changing the revetted style to a larger, rougher-edged shape. An old additional par three hole (completed during a Martin Hawtree renovation a few years ago) was then introduced as the new 4th hole with a raised tee in 2019. New tees for the new 5th (old 4th) were then bought into play and the green for that hole moved closer to the clubhouse.
The green for the old 7th was then pushed to the right and this hole became the new 8th, before the old 8th and 9th were combined to make a strong par four that plays 436 yards into the prevailing wind to a new green located in the carry of the original par three 9th hole. Like the 8th, a few new dunes were created around the green and along the fairway to blend the holes into the rest of the course. The old 9th is now a new short game area, next to the clubhouse.
I have just been lucky enough to have played 23 of Ireland's finest courses during the last fortnight. In conversation, most people asked are you playing Carne, Lahinch, Ballybunion, County Down, Portrush? Nobody mentioned the Island. It's probably a stretch to call the Island a hidden gem, sitting deservedly in Ireland's top 10 as it does, but it did feel like The Island flew under the radar somewhat before I had the pleasure of playing it.
Speaking to Members, they raved about the new Scottish Head Greenkeeper Neil Ballingall and the improvements he has made in a short time since starting. I found the course enchanting, teeing off as the sun rose over the Irish Sea. The 4th is a picturesque par three and epitomised the front nine which meandered through the dunes with a sense of benign seclusion from all other golfers. The back nine is more open and closer to the water - there we find the two contenders for the course's signature hole imo. I was left with no doubt playing the long par three 13th that this would be the outstanding hole, until I stood on the 14th tee. At just over 300 yards, it doesn't look jaw-dropping on the card but the golfer is faced with reputedly the narrowest fairway in Europe, water all down the right and rough and dunes on the left. Fortunately there was little or no wind when I played it and my driver (should have hit 5 iron!) thankfully found the slither of fairway but I shudder to think how this would play on a typically blustery links day with a nasty left to right crosswind. The 18th is a fine two shotter finale to a raised green, an honest but enjoyable hole which sums up the Island nicely. Whilst the dunes are not as dramatically large as Tralee or Ballybunion, there is a confident, understated feel to The Island - be in no doubt however, The Island is a superb course and the welcome from the staff (Connor, Keith, Nathan and others) was equally high-standard. I would definitely recommend adding the Island to an Irish golf trip and given it's close proximity to Dublin airport it is in an ideal location even for a weekend golf break where you could throw in Portmarnock, Baltray and even The European slightly further South to your itinerary.
Hard not to enjoy The Island. By links standards, it is an easy walk. The dunes are not as large as you will find in the West/Northwest, but they shape the holes beautifully. The par 4-18th hole is an absolute monster of a closing hole.
The easy access from Dublin makes The Island a must add to any Ireland golf itinerary. The course is only 15 minutes from the airport.
It has been a little while since I last played the Island. I revisited last week and it's better than I had remembered. They redid the 8th and 9th into a single hole and that was spot on what should have been done. There are a number of fantastic holes here. It's my opinion that this is the best golf in the Dublin area. A beautiful natural setting with a diverse selection of playing fields. Fabulous.
The Island GC – there are four brand new holes on the renovated front nine, which has broken up the original flow of 8 par 4s and a par 3 to finish the outward half. The 3rd hole has been extended to a par 5 with new tee boxes, the 4th is a brand new par 3 carved out of the massive sand-dunes, the 5th has been extended into a long dog-leg left to right. Furthermore, the 8th and 9th holes are brand new long stellar par 4s which have been shifted in from the driveway. No real changes to the back nine. The Island oozes quality and is an absolute must-play. It is firmly among the best in Ireland.
The Island has always been one of my favorites and now I have even more reason to return. Thanks for the update Fergal.
The Island: Fresh from its makeover in early 2020 by renowned architects Mackenzie & Ebert the Island has stepped up a notch from its well placed ranking # 8 in Ireland with a nice mix of holes on the front rather than the older format viz., eight par fours in a row! The opening hole is located in beautiful high dunes so this sets the scene for the astute player to decide on their strategy over the entire course. The course starts at a relatively nice pace over gentle terrain before gaining in momentum and excitement with a great mix of short and long holes. The new design now has great variety with different configurations, hazard placements, green shapes and green contours.
The new third is a par five followed by the fourth a par three which is a treat ‘postage stamp’ size with a great view over the Irish Sea but longer than 7th in Pebble beach which transitions you nicely through more dunes to the new lay-out holes. There are some great golfing holes at 5th, 8th and 9th replacing the short blind holes that persisted before the very welcome new routing with the ‘2020 vision’ of Ebert. One sensational hole follows another. Your enjoyment of the new front nine where you can open up will get you in good mood for the coming challenge of the back.
The 10th starts with the ‘road hole design’ reminiscent of 17th at St Andrews which invites the player to cut the corner on the right to shorten the hole. Players must play good golf to score well particularly on 12th, 13th, and 14th the most memorable/devilish trio of holes on the back. The 13th is not unlike the par three Calamity in Portrush at 220 yards with trouble on the right. The 14th fairway looks very narrow but it’s a short par four so being brave take out your driver and rip it - you will get your reward -- if you pull it off! The 15th is a beautiful par five – aim for the white disk afar in the distance and then wind your way down through some of the most spectacular secluded dunes anywhere.
The Island is now masterpiece both technically and visually, particularly if you’re a fan of dune land. It is an almost perfect case study of how you can use the natural lie of the land to frame holes instead of relying on expansive fairway bunkers. The holes pose a variety of risks and rewards and equally test length, accuracy and finesse. Players will finish on the great par four, index one, where you can see in the distance the flag 460 yards away from the elevated tee. If you have played it before and liked the old layout you will love the five new holes on the front. You’ll yearn to go round once again to see if you can improve... Expect the ranking of # 8 in Ireland and # 51 in UK & Ir. will be revised upwards before long. 9/10. pd
No golf excursion to the Dublin area is complete without a trip to The Island Club. While visiting the Emerald Isle last year, I had time for one last round to sneak in before catching my flight in the morning back to the United States. I hopped onto online forums and asked people at various stops--and back at home, as my father recommended the track--on the trip where I should bring my sticks for the final time. I gave a radius of 50 kilometers to include all of the Dublin area's best links. The overwhelming answer I received: The Island Club.
The round was like something out of a Ireland golf fantasy: joining me on the front nine were two members north of 70, who explained to me the history and importance of the course on a local scale. Said one of the elders: "I'd rather play here any day than Portmarnock."
Sporting small fairways, the course itself is tighter than most links, and there's elevation changes galore. Interestingly enough, the first eight holes are all par fours but the routing never grows tiresome and no two holes look the same. The fifth, a blind, downhill tee ball, is more forgiving than it looks. The two members noted to me that if you try to drive the green on the eighth hole, make sure you're able to fly the fescue that sits about 50 yards shy of the green. The back nine, a more traditional routing with two par threes and fives, is no slouch either. The three-hole stretch beginning on the 13th is one of the strongest I've ever seen on a golf course. The 13th is a long par three with a carry over the beach that surrounds the majority of the property is a mammoth test as views to the west captivate your eyes. The 14th is perhaps the hole The Island Club is most known for, with the skinniest fairway you'll ever see on a par four.
I didn't play Portmarnock, and I chose not to tee it up at The European Club or the K Club either. I never regretted once my decision to forgo these three, as The Island Club provided a unique and special Irish golf experience. Each hole is distinctive, and you'll be hard pressed to find a more affordable value. It's a must play in the area.
This review is now fiction as the 8 hole was dug up on 13 May 2020 as were most of the eight par 4's in a row.
Members telling you they less prefer Portmarnock are suffering from 'my beautiful child syndrome'.
One of the most important lessons I received came from some Irish insiders who advised me a round at The Island would be one I'd never forget. I've heard such talk over the years during my global forays and usually I simply acknowledge the "insights" and go about my merry way.
The Island proved itself to be even greater than the promotions I received.
The respective holes have been bandied about by others and my verbal inclusions won't likely add much.
The constant adjustments are front and center when playing. You also have a routing never allowing you to get too comfortable. As others have stated -- The Island is ever quick to apply some serious pain for the wayward. When in doubt if one's driver is misbehaving -- be resolute and select a club can find the shortgrass.
What fascinated me is you face eight consecutive par-4s at the outset and how each differs in terms of the challenge provided and the routing each takes. One can quibble and cite the fact three of the outbound par-4s turn left in the drive zone, but I dare say that's really being persnickety. I am a big time proponent of courses that call upon players to "work the ball" as the round warrants. The Island is quite finicky in this regard and that requirement is what elevates the experience in terms of identifying the talented from the less so.
The inward half is consummate mixture -- you have opportunities to score with the par-5 10th leading the way. Unlike so many par-5s you'd best realize no birdies are likely without the execution to back it up. Just be ever mindful of losing one's second shot a bit too far right!
The par-3 13th is clearly brilliant and has been highlighted, quite rightly, numerous times. It's great to see a long par-3 testing skills with the longest of clubs to a target that repels sloppy execution in the same manner that Superman does with bullets. The 13th has the goods to be front and center as a member of any all-star grouping of holes on The Emerald Isle.
My main disappointment rests with the much talked about short par-4 14th. I just don't see the merits in having a walking path as one's fairway. How much better would the hole would be with a wider fairway that gradually tapers down the more one seeks to propel the tee shot down the fairway. The green site is every good and I just view the overly narrow fairway as a contrivance -- no doubt, it's a contentious issue with proponents on both sides. The 14th is more of a talking point for the 19th hole and almost a distraction to the sum total of what The Island truly provides.
The final quartet of holes is exceptional as stated by a number of others. Each is a stern test and only the most resolute of players showcasing tenacity of the highest order will succeed.
I read a comment made by one earlier reviewer concerning how playability is more present with County Louth than The Island. I can't disagree with that salient point. The issue becomes one of balancing "playability" and "challenge." The Island is a links with teeth -- County Louth more so on the side of subtle architecture. Neither is wrong on what each seeks to do. The Island puts a rightful onus on one's tee game. You have temptations throughout the round to use the big stick but it takes ample dexterity to reap the rewards in doing so.
The Island is also one of those few courses where intrinsic beauty aligns so well with the architectural dimensions. In all of Ireland, there are few courses merging such a marvelous intersection of both elements. The firmness of the turf and the overall routing keeps the golf at a high level. You revel in the well-played shots you accomplish but even when you come up short -- you eagerly await the next opportunity to see if your game has what it takes.
Architecture aside -- the location is also meaningful because being in Malahide you are so near to all the action -- the restaurants, hotels, scenery -- you name it. That is -- if you can pull yourself away from what The Island clearly provides on the golf front. Given my numerous visits to Ireland over the years, The Island is among the Emerald Isle's top ten and a prime candidate for top five membership.
Lofty no doubt -- but The Island clearly stands apart. No golf visit to the Dublin area is complete without a rendezvous there.
M. James Ward
Please note my review is based on the layout that existed before the work that commenced in October 2019 following plans brought forward by the architectural firm of Mackenzie & Ebert.
Among the highlights are a new par-3 4th -- played from an elevated tee with the sea behind. The hole uses a greensite added as a 19th hole a few years back. This allowed for a new back tee and straightening of the former 4th turning the short dog-leg left par-4 into a more demanding 467-yard hole played into the prevailing wind. The plan also provides for a dramatic improvements including the elimination of the short par-4 8th and par-3 9th holes. Those two holes have now been combined into a lengthy par-4.
In addition, the previous 7th green has been moved so that the hole now plays now as a slight dog-leg right.
The "new" Island will feature these inclusions for the 2020 season and getting comments from those sampling the finished efforts will be of immense interest given the considerable standing of the course.
Wonderful true links with charm & character! Always rising on top rankings!
Despite being played over similar rugged terrain no hole feels even remotely the same and this is its biggest asset; 18 individual and exceptional holes where the array of golf on offer is superb.
Despite being located next to Donabate Estuary and bordered by water on three sides we do not get to see much of the sea from the links but the views towards Malahide – from where golfers used to boat across - is a captivating horizon for long periods of the round with aeroplanes regularly taking-off from and landing at nearby Dublin airport.
There’s no denying that if you are offline you will be punished at The Island with either a lie that requires a hack-out, or a lost ball in the mighty sandhills, but there is just about enough width to get away with it although the penal nature of the course counts as a slight black mark against it.
Tough but fair would be a description The Club may feel was accurate. However, playing Baltray on the same day it was noticeable how much more playable County Louth was and all the better for it.
Overall there’s very little to dislike at The Island and so much to love. There are a couple of holes where there are some clear gather points on the fairway, riddled with divots, but that goes with the territory at courses with such rumbling terrain. And there is no denying it is a tough course, however, there is just so much to admire that these minor points are easily forgotten.
Green-fees start from around the €150 mark which is a lot of money for a game of golf and there are few courses I would ever advise anyone to pay this sum for hitting a little white ball over some sandy ground, but I think you get good value at The Island.
Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.
The first time I played The Island, both of our groups walked off the course with three holes (7-9) to play due to slow play which had us on pace for a 5 ½ hour round. We were at 4:45 when we walked off. Much to our surprise, the offending people were Irish. I do not know if they were members or locals as they came in as we were having some drinks and snacks. The experience was so disappointing that I was not sure I wanted to go back. Based on this experience as well as at a few other courses in Ireland, it served as a confirmation in my mind at that time that golf in Ireland and Northern Ireland was for golfers who wanted to spend a day at the club. Who can blame them?
Yet what I saw of the course on those 15 holes was enchanting. I did not expect to find massive hills and dunes. It is a course that seemingly built on prior hole with the next hole being a superior hole, I could not prove that to be the case since I had skipped three holes, but what I did see was so compelling that I knew I wanted to return.
I did go back on a day when a top professional was playing the course as part of his preparation for The Open. After being politely asked to allow him a 45 minute gap before we teed off (only 15 minutes behind our scheduled time), our two groups set out. Although there were about eight or nine people in his entourage, we only saw them once on the golf course and our two groups played in 3:40.
I did have a chance to reacquaint myself with The Island, with the exception of those three holes. The two times I have played it, I have started on the back nine, which to me is often not that big of a deal.
I like The Island a lot. On my personal list of golf courses that I have played, it is just outside my top 100. I like the uniqueness of it, its quirkiness, the wonderful smooth greens, the routing, the green complexes and the defenses. I like the visual look of it with the rolling naturalness of it, the higher dunes that appear more like small hills, fall offs and valleys, and of course the view back across to Malahide. This is a golf course that I believe is under rated. Perhaps the complaints one can make regarding the golf is the absence of more strategic bunkers, many of the bunkers are not deep enough, and there is a similarity of holes on yardage and bend on the front nine. But as stated, I really like the holes seem to get better and better as you play through one’s round. I also like how the seemingly easier holes tempt you to perhaps try some shots you really have no business trying nearly always resulting in adding an extra shot instead of saving one. Once in trouble, there is a lot of fun on this golf course in trying to figure out how to resolve the situation as to not embarrass oneself. As they say, sometimes there are “good” bogies.
I also very much like the “island” feel to the golf course. It can feel pretty alone here even if one often hears sounds all around you whether it is birds, boats, or noises from across the Malahide bay.
Of the courses near Dublin, I tell everyone to play Portmarnock Championship, followed by County Louth and then The Island. I rate The Island higher than County Louth but I recommend County Louth because nearly all of the Americans I talk to have now heard of The Island. As for slow play, when I follow up with them after they have played The Island, they tell me its sometimes slow, but not agonizingly slow as the first time I played.
This course is as natural as Ballybunion Old and Lahinch Old. It really offers everything such as elevated greens, sunken greens, shots along the water, shots in the dunes, shots to flat greens, twists and turns, undulated fairways, valleys, and fantastic greens. As I said, I do not believe it has a truly weak hole for anyone who is a mid-length hitter and plays from a 5 to a 25. The back tees are now above 7100 yards so even the longer hitter and scratch player is going to find a challenge here.
The first hole sets one off beautifully down a wide fairway on this straight hole with a narrowing fairway arriving at a green sitting between the dunes on this mid-length par 4. The green is very good as it is raised and slopes slightly back to front. Bushes surround the green but are set back a bit. The green has a smooth putting surface. It is a good indication of the quality of the greens to follow. There are no bunkers on this hole and there probably should be a few in the fairway as well as at the green. It is a visually very pretty golf hole and likely one of the best starting holes in the UK and Ireland.
The second is a slight dogleg left to a severely sloping green as a shorter par 4. Three bunkers guard the front of the green and catch a lot of balls that are hit short. I like the narrowness of the hole, the large dunes to the right, smaller dunes to the left and the rumpling of the fairway as you near the green with small and large swales. I particularly like the green complex with the two deep bunkers right and one left but with added grass bunkers and fall offs around the green leading one’s ball into fairly deep swales. This is a good golf hole.
The third hole is a very long par 4 at over 500 yards. One is tempted to swing hard to get the ball as close to the green as possible but high grass and water awaits down the right side although there is a ridge line that serves as a buffer. The fairway itself is relatively smooth. It is a straight hole but a short approach shot and even landing on the green moves the ball to the right so play in is to the left or center of the green. There is a somewhat hidden bunker to the left of the green (you can see it if you are forced to hit a short club in for your third). The green is two-tiered and slopes to the right. It is a brilliantly difficult, but fair golf hole which for many players I suspect a par is secured if they can make only one putt. This is a hole where for visual purposes only I thought some bunkers should be added, not so much for defense but to put some doubts in the mind of the player who is trying to play the hole too conservatively. This is highlighted as one of the best holes on the golf course and I certainly agree.
As mentioned, if one wanted to critique The Island for similar holes, the next three holes would serve as their basis. Holes 4-6 are relatively short dogleg left par 4’s with the sixth being the shortest. If someone wants to critique The Island for this sameness in the routing, that is understandable, yet this is what the land called for between the dunes. In my opinion, the holes have a good variety to them in look and also vary in the green complexes.
The fourth hole is a lovely shorter dogleg par 4 with a single bunker at the left turn in the fairway and two near the front right of the green. Perhaps this hole could use one additional bunker at the green, which is relatively thin and elevated surrounded on the right by mounds and on the left has a fall off. It is a beautiful green complex.
The fifth is a blind tee shot to a very rippled, rolling fairway with swales of different sizes. One never knows where the tee shot will finish given the mounds and valleys in the fairway. The green is well defended with three bunkers fronting the green. Although similar in length to the fourth, it looks and plays very differently. You are actually abutting Corballis Links Golf Club as you walk off the green to the sixth tee.
The sixth is the second shortest par 4 on the golf course and it is fun beginning with an elevated tee, the highest on The Island. For those trying to drive the green there are two nasty pot bunkers on the right and a fairway bunker fronting the dunes on the left. The large dune on the left blocks the view of the green. The green is sloped so that a shot into it can be difficult to stay on the green so distance precision is higher on this hole. This is a sharper dogleg than the two holes preceding it. For a short par 4, this is a very good golf hole and one that I always struggle on because of its temptations.
While the seventh is technically still a dogleg left, it is only a slight turn and as the hole is much longer than the previous three holes, it does not seem to play as a dogleg. It is a wide fairway which narrows and then widens again fronting the green. The green is one of the best on the golf course. The green has a big fall off on the left side and has bushy thorns on the right side and back of the green that will likely lead to a dropped shot. The miss on the hole is to be short right where the ball will run off a bit but one still has a chance at recovery. This hole has no bunkers on it and it is one that I definitely would add some, as many as six because six and eight are meant to be “easier” holes the front side should have a very difficult hole on it and it really does not.
The shortest par 4 on the golf course is next. The tee box is situated back inside of vegetation on either side. There is a rise in the fairway before another very good green which is one of the more undulating greens on the golf course. The other defense to the hole is the out of bounds right for a road. The green sits down in almost a punchbowl or dell. It is a brilliant short par 4; one you might expect to find on North Berwick West such is the uniqueness and naturalness of the setting of the green.
Perhaps it is a little odd that the first par 3 comes late into the round, but the ninth has another good green complex and green itself, which slopes back to front and has four bunkers at the front. Looking back at my first visit to The Island, I was really annoyed about missing seven and nine in particular due to the slow play on that day. For whatever reason, usually it feels odd to me to finish a course on a par 3, (Pasatiempo comes to mind), but when one starts on the back nine resulting in a finishing hole being a par 3, it does not seem odd at all.
The front nine is the scoring nine on the golf course as the bar gets raised on the back nine due to added length and more difficulty sometimes in the tee shot and sometimes with the second. Some very difficult holes await on the back nine which is 250 yards longer despite having two par 3’s as opposed to only one on the front side; this is due to the only par 5s being on the back nine.
As mentioned, I have only ever begun on the back nine at The Island. It is actually quite a thrill to start on such a compelling hole as the tenth. There are temptations on this hole but a poor shot will typically result in losing a shot or more. It is a nice-looking mid length par 5 that is a dogleg right. It seems like it should be a neasy par with a fair chance at a birdie. The look from the tee tempts one so much to try to go as right as possible even if there is no reason to do so. The two fairway bunkers on the left at the turn also want to force you to play down the right side. As you approach the green the fairway has a substantially sized valley on the right. There is a large and deep bunker left of the green that is there to catch the person trying to make the green in two. Another smaller pot bunker in on the left back closer to the green as well as one in front and both are very much in play. Dips and swales are on the back and right of the green. There is a fair amount of vegetation on the right side as you play up to the green as well as the shot hit far too long will find the water behind the green. The hole has a very nice green, one of the smoothest on the golf course on the times I have played.
Next is a mid-length par 4 plays a bit like a double dogleg but ultimately it is a slight dogleg right where one should try to stay left for a better shot at the green as the right side of the fairway leaves a trickier shot. Another nice green awaits here but one cannot go too far right at the green or you find scattered bushes and trees. The miss at the green is clearly to the left side.
For me, the next seven holes are the best stretch on the golf course and there is no let up. While I have yet to play the routing as intended, I can only imagine the rush of adrenaline as the course builds and builds to its finish.
The twelfth is a dogleg left with a valley fronting an elevated green. Much like the previous hole, the best line into the green is on the left but it brings a hill into play that typically leads to a chip back to the fairway or a fair amount of courage to try to reach the green. There is a pond far left that should not come into play. There are no bunkers on the hole and I go back and forth as to whether it needs some. Adding bunkers on this hole would raise the challenge but it is already a fine hole although the green is flat.
A long par 3 follows requiring courage to take on the green with water down the right side and eating into the tee shot a bit. There is a large dip for a grass bunker in front of the green that I do not find to be difficult as I watched others play out of it. The dip is preceded by a rise fronting the green. The safe play is to the left side but saving par is unlikely due to the green; at least no one in our groups have ever done so. This is one of the two unique holes for me because it looks different to the eye than other holes that are built the same way; maybe it’s the view of the boats in the water, the lawn and croquet club and the town across the water.
Next is one of the most unique golf holes ever, the mid-length par 4 with likely the narrowest fairway one will ever play, particularly since the bay awaits down the entire right side of the fairway. I have read it is only 15 yards wide and I have read it is only 28 feet wide. I think it varies a bit here and there but overall including the light rough on either side I think there is about 22 yards of width. A miss slightly to the left will likely kick the ball into the fairway. There is a bit of room between the end of the fairway and the water but if the wind is going left right this must be one of the most daunting tee shots in all of golf. On a windless day this hole is not quite as terrifying as I have made birdie here. It is a nice long slightly undulating green waiting at the end but again you cannot miss right and long is also not a good option due to the taller grass. There is a fall off to the right of the green for its entire length.
The fifteenth is a longer par 5 and I hole that is my favorite on the golf course. From the tee to the green there is so much going on in the terrain that it is a visual feast. The better play to the green is down the left side yet three fairway bunkers are on the left. A dune rise on the right side of the fairway presents additional difficulty. At the green there is a single bunker on the left. This is a lovely green site set at the base of the dunes. It is a large but flat green. You are heading back into the dunes on this hole and away from the water. One friend of mine suggested that they should have moved a bit of earth here and put the green slightly higher up in the dune but I like the green as is.
The sixteenth is a longer par 3 requiring an additional club as it plays to an elevated green. It is a difficult par as the green is well bunkered with two bunkers each in front of the green on either side and will likely catch every ball struck too weakly. These are some of the more difficult bunkers that are near the green. You can land a lower struck shot short of the green and it will still go on.
The second or third most difficult tee shot awaits on the seventeenth as it is narrow (but not nearly like the fourteenth) with water once again on the right. Two fairway bunkers are on the right which can often be more of a blessing to find them. The fairway slopes to the right nearly all the way to the green. There is a large grass bunker left and smaller depressons. The hole has another very smooth and undulating green with a steep, but not deep fall off in the rear of the green.
A long par 4 finishes The Island. The tee shot is intimidating as the drive must go through a valley with dunes on either side that seem to narrow the size of the fairway. The fairway rises slightly as you approach the large, deep green which is fronted by two bunkers. You cannot yank the tee shot to the right or it will find taller vegetation but the fairway is wide enough that it should not happen. If The Island added some fairway bunkers on this hole and perhaps another one at the back left of the green, this would become one of the finer finishing holes that one would every play.