An interesting course, quite stark in places. Reminded me somewhat of Connemara in Galway, Ireland. Barely a tree or scrub around and a desolate look and feel to it. Naturally these are great ingredients to have in a golf course. A rollicking course played over massive undulations and hills. Not really a heavily duned course and the blind shots are quite obvious – usually they are on long drives with the marker post maybe a 100-200m ahead of you so no real need to guess too much what you need to do. Some heavily sloped fairways means holding the ball on your intended line is impossible, especially in the fast, dusty conditions the summer of 2018 has presented.
The par 3s are tough with some long accurate shots required, otherwise run offs will severely punish any mis-hit or mis-clubbed shot. There are no poor holes and some great ones. The finish, like Pyle & kenfig, is long but with two of the last three holes par 5s, if you are not too tired from the walk, you do have some great opportunities to finish with a score.
This is the last course I have played in my 11 day tour of all links courses (except for Royal Porthcawl which was closed for a tournament and Swansea bay) and whilst not quite the best it was a strong course to finish on. Perranporth was the massive surprise packet and Weston – super-Mare and Channel course the disappointments. For the interested the following is my ranking of these 15 courses. Warren from Aust
1. Saunton East
3. St Enodoc
6. Saunton West
7. Burnham & Berrow Championship
10. West Cornwall
15. Burnham & Berrow Channel
Everyone loves a good list - thanks for sharing yours.
What a great (and pretty unique) trip you’ve completed.
Shame you couldn’t get on at Royal Porthcawl (did you tell them what you were up to? If so, it would be pretty cold-hearted not to have squeezed you on).
Where would you rank P&K amongst all these courses?
Yep, love a list. I did play P&K and it is in between RND and Ashburnham. Royal Porthcawl was off limits due to British Seniors Amateur Open.
An excellent list which reminds me there are a few on here that I haven't played and personally I would be trying to edge Pennard and Saunton West a little higher. Royal Porthcawl would go straight in at nr 1 (as the layout is fantastic) provided the greens were in good condition (not always the case). Swansea Bay is worth playing and has some good links holes but a bit like P&K there are some non-links style holes (on the clubhouse side of the main road). DB
Ah Pennard, you’ve truly found a place in my heart. What a stunning location. Situated 200 feet above sea level and offering glorious views across the Gower Peninsula and out to the Pill Estuary and Three Cliffs Bay, Pennard is every bit a true and genuine links. Set perfectly immersed within dunes, every single hole has an abundance of personality.
I admit that Pennard will divide opinion. Sure, the course may be a little agricultural in places, livestock can be found wandering the course at certain times of the year and although they weren’t erected when I played, I understand that a select number of greens are sometimes surrounded by fencing to guard from straying cattle. It’s not immaculately maintained in the way that Open rota courses are, but what a supreme layout this is. It may even be the best piece of land across which I’ve ever played golf.
Pennard shares lots of similarities with James Braid’s other designs at Perranporth and Brora which are also wonderful golfing landscapes and the course feels untouched and as Braid intended. Most holes are played blind, hitting towards marker posts to infinity fairways and hidden green sites. Wickedly undulating fairways merge into heavily contoured greens and the holes themselves are played across an assortment of directions. The course will cause confusion to most golfers experiencing the links for the first time; the 3rd tee for example, with no directional marker post in sight on this dogleg hole surrounded by shallow dunes, the fairway and green are largely hidden from view.
The 4th hole is where you’ll get your first real sight of the wonderful views on offer at Pennard. Don’t become too distracted though as this short par five asks questions of the golfer to find the right angles on each shot if you’re hoping to avoid an early meltdown. The plethora of humps and hollows that are a feature throughout the course begin to come into play on the 6th whilst the 7th, a hole that features a church wall to the left and ruins of a castle to the right has the most wonderfully awkward green complex. Making par at the testing 9th hole is a wonderful score whilst the par five 10th is characteristic of the eccentricities you’ll face at Pennard. Another hole that left me scratching my head on the tee to the point where I had to walk the first hundred yards of the fairway until I was sure of my strategy before hitting my tee shot. A six-iron from the tee followed by a hybrid-three into the elevated green ended up being the perfect play and an extremely satisfying birdie ensued. Quirky as this hole may be and surely not to everyone’s appetites, taking my bias from making birdie aside, I still found Pennard’s 10th to be an absolute beauty.
After this, the drama doesn’t let up and if anything gets turned up a notch. The 11th green is simply perched onto the side of a hill but approach with caution as this tiered green, complete with false front will spit the ball back at you if you’re not accurate for distance.
The slopes at Pennard aren’t subtle, typified by the 12th fairway that will repel any ball away to the right rough. In these burnt out Summer conditions, I could see no way of finding the fairway and this would be my one main criticism of the course with the 18th fairway also being similarly angled. Yet another severe slope greets you on the 13th, this time a par three so only the poor shots go punished here, but no matter what the quality of your tee shot, breathe in the wonderful views of the clifftop campsite and beach in the distance that will surely soften the blow of any poorly timed golf shot.
Signature holes then keep coming head-on, 14 with its massive humps in the fairway, some of which are over 10’ high, playing sharply uphill to a raised green. Then 15, a par three on top of the hill that plays to a tremendous peanut shaped green. 16 is a stunner and the first of two back to back par fives playing out to the corner of the cliff whilst the scenery from the 17th tee is equally breath-taking. I had to wait for the group in front here to clear so was able to soak in the soft afternoon light across the sea and watch horses go trotting along the beach. What a sight.
Once ready and when the group in front rings the bell, you’ll find that the 17th snakes in a double dogleg shape around gorse. I found myself out of position with my tee shot here and discovered the hole to be overly penal; it’s tight, blind and unforgiving. Plop; into the gorse my ball went and my first lost ball. It was the end of my score, but it didn’t dampen my spirits about the quality of this wonderful course. There’s just nothing pretentious about Pennard, and that’s why I loved it. Pennard speaks to my tastes; it’s absolutely my cup of tea, and make that a big mug of welsh brew with a chocolate biscuit on the side.
Pennard might well be known for being the “Links in the Sky” but even that description alone doesn’t quite do the course justice, Pennard is as beautiful as it is dramatic and, in my opinion, one of the finest links courses in the UK.
By the way, did I mention the views?
nice review ! fab course .. should it be higher in the top 100 UK rankings ?
I'll leave that to better educated folk than me to decide David, but I'd have it in my personal top 10 and the equal of some World Top 100 courses that I've played.
Pennard Golf Club is also referred to as ‘The Links In the Sky’ and with good reason given its lofty location 200 feet above sea level on the rugged and picturesque Gower Peninsula. We teed off on a sunny afternoon just after 2pm in mid May with the cows looking on intently to our blind approach to the 1st green. A strong opening hole off our chosen (white) tees of the day was followed by a gentle par 3 before the real test began. SI 3 third hole was a dog leg left that had two sucker bunkers on the tiger line, one of which I found and it was a typical penal Braid bunker. The par 3 fifth hole really needs an accurate tee shot to secure a par, my ball started left with a hook and sadly might well have ended up on the beach. ‘Castle’ 7th hole has an inviting tee shot but I ended up behind the old church wall pulling off a Seve esk approach only to three putt but fear not the breath taking view from this green towards the majestic Castle ruins perched on the hill more than made up for it. The approach to the ninth was typical Braid in that he offers you different ways to play the shot, knock down or fly it, I got caught somewhere in the middle and paid the price with another bogey.
The tee shot at the par 5 tenth hole must be thought out given there is a bottleneck of a landing area before the hole turns left and the start of a thee club hill to the green. Not my favourite hole on the course but then again if its good enough for Tom Doak, (who is a big fan of the course), then who am I to argue. As much as the 10th hole divided opinion we were equally in agreement that the par 3 eleventh is a classic. Braid typically desired that holes should be laid out as suggested by the land, well this green fitted perfectly into the Gower sandhills. Tough green to hit given it is only 13yards wide and has a massive false front to-boot. Although we played it on a calm day I would image having the prevailing SW wind on the tail to be helpful when it does blow up from the Bristol Channel. The next stretch of holes offered up a good mix of short and long par 3 and 4’s before the breath-taking par 5 sixteenth. Generous fairway, (I still missed it) and lay-up to wedge distance that again offers multiple ways to play the shot. Seventeen is a double dog-leg that rewards you hitting the fairway by allowing you to go for the green, miss the fairway and it is a three shot par 5.
Eighteen is a difficult fairway to hit but if you do, yes I managed to find one, it will offer up a short iron approach that with the pin up front it was best to fly it on the day before bringing the house down with a birdie for the returning herd of cows from the 1st.
It’s an old school course with rolling fairways and has its little quirks with wired fencing protecting the greens from those cows but it truly is a gem of a course. The par threes are strong with the standout hole being the 11th and still thinking hard to determine if I have every had a friendly welcome to any golf club either side of the Irish sea. Finally a word of advise for anyone with a Garmin Approach S2 in that you best update the latest mapping as I could not get a look in. That said the course planner is value at £5 with tips each hole from the Sean Pearson the resident pro since 2015 and only the fourth pro since the club was founded in 1896.
Like I said a total gem of a course and one I would highly recommend to go play.
M. J. Smyth
If there's anything in golf more important to achieve it's "fun golf" and you see that dimension front and center when playing at Pennard. The location of the course high on the Gower Peninsula gives the course a geographic location of distinction. The wind can blow violently at times but when the weather cooperates it's hard to take issue with what the course provides time after time.
While a number of so-called "championship" layouts overdose on undue length and inane heights of rough just off the fairways -- at Pennard you get an appropriate test for the masses so that success for different levels of handicaps is clearly present. Mind you -- Pennard doesn't give anything away easily. The demands are there but the degree of the test rests on how bold and how much risk the player wishes to take on throughout the round.
The par-4 7th is certainly a gem of a hole - aptly named "Castle." I especially like the par-4 9th which calls upon two solid strikes to get near the long par-4.
For those who need ideal turf conditions a round at Pennard will be a test of one's patience. Fairway lies can be uneven in terms of overall quality and while the ensemble of different animals roaming the grounds is part of the allure -- it can be a bit much to have the menagerie moving about like a lost episode of Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom with Marlin Perkins.
Pennard excels in having holes that don't repeat what is needed to succeed. Superior design is about adjustments -- not falling into predictable patterns that make a test of golf far less so.
I have always been a firm believer that no less than 60% of any superior golf course is tied to the land the layout occupies. Pennard is a visual treat to the eyes. The land moves in all sorts of directions and when concluding the round it's likely you'll be yearning for another crack at the track.
by M. James Ward
We played on a glorious sunny if breezy day. Pennard is a very tough and dramatic course, featuring some long carries. it requires you to bring your A game . The course offers lovely views, and is a real links, that is some long rough, blind shots, and you will want to have played before to know where to hit it. Boasts some great holes, the 10th an awesome dog leg par 5, and great variety with quirky short par 4s.
Mmm a very difficult review to write ! Played on a sunny breezy day. Absolutely loved the course and the experience, just great fun and to a certain extent eccentric. From a purists perspective, it is a good course – there are too many slight negatives to be a great course, such as 1/. No really “great” holes. There were some that were “great” off the tee, but lacked in some way thereafter eg 7th. Others had world class approaches but off blind tee shots eg 9, 14 and 17. 2/. 7 dogleg right to left holes against 1 slight left to right moving hole. 3/. The par 5 10th is not a good hole. With the severe slope from the tee and the fairway running out of room at 260, it is a 5 iron off the tee, and everyone is left with the same length shot for their second shot. In summary though, there is far more to love and enjoy (the views (6th fairway, 7th green and approach to 16 (wow), the quirkiness, variety of par 3s, the friendly welcome, proper links turf
Pennard is one of those fantastic links golf courses that has a little bit of everything.
Its remote and rugged location on the Gower Peninsula mixes strategy and quirkiness to good effect and boasts a handful of truly excellent holes. The high cliff-top setting also provides some of the best views you're likely to see from a golf course.
The par three holes at Pennard are particularly strong with the fifth and 11th both contenders for the best hole on the course. The former is played downhill to a delightful green, bunkered on both sides, with multiple pin locations that change the dynamic of the hole whilst the latter is played over a wide, barren expanse to an angled green with a solitary bunker cut into the hill just short of the green. The slope of the land and placement of the green allows a ball to be fed in from the left for those not brave enough to fire straight at the heart of the green. Holes two and 15 are also sound short holes, the 15th has a wonderfully long green with three subtle levels.
The first and third are both solid enough two-shotters but it is the four holes that complete the front nine which catch the eye the most. Each has varying degrees of right-to-left shape to them and being on the correct side of the fairways is important to obtain the best line into the flag. The fairways at Pennard generally, but on these holes in particular, are littered with swales and hollows creating a feeling of magical golf. The 14th hole on the back-nine is another that matches this quartet for quality and strategy.
Pennard, however, isn't without fault and some of the holes border on unplayable at times when the fairways are baked dry and hard thanks to the undulating fairways.
The 12th is an unusually short par four with a large gathering bunker just short of the green and this is probably the weakest hole on the course.
Dubbed the 'links in the sky' because of its elevated position Pennard is a true links course worthy of a visit and one you are sure to have great fun playing. Just don't expect to find your ball exactly where you think it should be because of the fabulous rising and falling fairways!
Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.
I played Pennard in the clubs Open on 10th September with a friend on what was a sunny Saturday. We had driven all the way done form London & arrived about 15mins before our tee time ( cutting it a bit close!) The friendly welcome from all the members in the club house & the starter on the first tee was 1 class. Lovely people & a great start to any round. As for the course. Well Pennard literally gets better every hole. Some of the views, partially on the back 9 are stunning.
The links fairways are in fine condition as our the greens. Amazing views abound of the coast & the castle. I’ve seldom played a course with such a great variety of holes. Each one had great personality. I am a member at Blackmoor golf club in Hampshire & will be recommending Pennard to anyone heading down to Wales in the future.
The greeting after the round was equally good. The members here should be very proud of the quality of their course but equally as proud of a club which obviously has a great feeling of community.