Berkshire (Red) - Berkshire - England

Absolutely love this place. Beautiful piece of ground with some tremendous holes that stick in the memory and brilliant conditioning.

The terrain here is perfect for golf with crisp sandy soil and terrifying heather lining each fairway (it looks beautiful but is impossible to escape from).

I agree with some of the earlier reviews in that due to the amount of land here and the dense tree-lined fairways, it often feels like your fourball is the only one on the course and this isolation really adds to the special feel of this place.

There aren’t many weak holes but a few of my favourites were:

4th - a great uphill par 4 with trouble left and plenty of bunkers around the green to swallow any wayward approaches.

6th - tough dogleg right where the elevated tee always tempts me to try and bite off more of the corner than I should!

8th - a stunning dog leg right where the ground all slopes left followed by a tough uphill approach into the undulating green.

10th - all of the par 3s are great here but 10 is something special. A hole I could play over and over.

11th - stunning short par 4 from an elevated tee (a truly great driving hole).

17th - a great dogleg right par 5 with a semi blind drive and beautiful approach into a green surrounded by the forest.

I agree that the par 5s are all quite short but I don’t think having the odd birdie opportunity detracts from the quality of the course. Others may disagree though. 18 is perhaps a weak finishing hole, being the weakest and least memorable of the 6 par 3s but when the 17 previous holes are as good as this, you can’t really complain.

Yet to play the Blue course so cannot compare but a 36 hole day here is something I can’t wait to book.

The Red is the better layout of the two course at The Berkshire with its unique balance of holes six par 3, par 4 and par 5’s holes which makes it more score able than its counterpart The Blue.

The terrain The Red is set upon is more interesting than The Blue with more elevation changes and angles from the tees combined with superior green complexes gives it the edge. The par 5 holes are relatively short which gives the golfer a number of birdie chances but this is countered with some difficult par 3 and par 4 holes. Holes 7 and 10 which are brilliant par 3’s both tough requiring good club selection and accuracy to walk away with pars. The 14th is a brute of a par 4 followed by the 16th another long par 3….I hit driver the day we played here. There are a number of special holes on The Red course, the par 3 2nd is a cracking short par 3 which plays uphill to a green protected by bunkers. The 6th is a 90 degree left to right dogleg that challenges the player to cut the corner from the elevated tee before a short approach to the green. The 17th is magnificent par 5 which curves from left to right it will take two almighty blows to reach this two-tiered green with your second shot. I cannot think of many better inland courses than The Red course at The Berkshire, it is playable for golfers of all levels, every hole provides a unique challenge and has wonderful green complexes …what more could you ask for!

How the Red isn't in the world top 100 is beyond me.

One of my favourite course, up there with Sunningdale Old and Swinley Forest. The 6 par 3s, 6 4s and 6 5s design creates a fantastic layout plenty of birdie chances. The start and finish are brilliant, and more courses should follow this template. It starts par 5 3 5, and ends 5 3 5 3.

Quick run down of the best holes:

2 - fantastic uphill par 3. Only a short iron. If you miss the green you'll know about it

4 - often overlooked, a great long par 4 with amazing bunkering

6 - one of the best holes on the course. Doglegs right around the trees. Very simple design

8 - gorgeous dogleg right par 4, downhill tee shot then uphill the the green

10 - best hole on the course and my favourite par 3 in golf. 190 yards all carry over a huge heathery ravine

11 - beautiful short par 4 off an elevated tee

15 - short par 5, but if you miss the fairway you will make 6

16 - one of the best par 3s in England. 220+ yards to a big green which looks tiny due top the massive bunkers short of it

A great course for both strokeplay and matchplay, with English Pinehurst No.2 vibes.

A day spent playing both courses at The Berkshire is in my top ten list of private clubs with two courses. This excludes resorts such as Pebble Beach, Bandon Dunes, Barnbougle Dunes, Trump Turnberry, Gleneagles, Streamsong, etc. While The Berkshire is not at the level of Sunningdale, Baltusrol, Winged Foot, or Walton Heath, it is in the conversation due to the joy one has with the walk and variety of golf holes placed in front of you from both courses. The beauty of the golf course is also at the same level of some inland courses in England due to the trees, flowering bushes, and heather.

I narrowly prefer the Blue course over the Red, which is contrary to what I read or hear. The reason is that the Red is quirkier with six pars of 3/4/5’s while the Blue is more standard. I also find the Blue course to have a few more “better” holes than the Red. Both courses have a weakness in most of their par 5’s lacking sufficient challenge. Both courses succumb to a few too many short par 4’s as well. Both the Red and Blue have very good par 3’s. One of the best debates I have had is which course is the superior as one can be easily convinced for one course but then suddenly remember something else about the other course that changes the winner of the debate.

Both courses are cutting back the trees which make the fairways seem wider although they are not. But the beauty of the course is more evident.

Herbert Fowler wonderfully routed the Red through terrain with ditches, swales, fall-offs, uphill shots, gullies, etc. to consider. The Red has the slightly better terrain than the Blue. The routing for the Red is lacking in length at less than 6500 yards despite a par of 72. One recommendation I would have is to change two of the shorter par 5’s into long par 4’s and change the overall par to 70. While one should try to record a total score rather than a comparative score to par, for some very good players their score to par is important. Making this change might determine how one plays those two holes. Would a player hit a different tee shot to a long par 4 rather than a short par 5? The likely candidates are the ninth, thirteenth and fifteenth. There is room to lengthen these holes although one would have to ensure it does not change the character of the holes perhaps too much into while requiring a large amount of tree removal.

If not lengthened, the par 5’s should have more defenses that make the better player consider the penalties for a poorly executed shot. I feel most of the par 5’s could use bunkers in the fairways and nearer the greens. The first has no bunkers and despite a strongly tilted green, needs more defense than a small stream crossing the fairway. Fifteen could be an excellent par 5 if the green surround looked more like the eleventh green.

The par 3’s are adequately bunkered, albeit some bunkers could be placed closer to the green. One wants to meet Mr. Fowler and ask, “did you make the par 5’s easier to balance the par 3’s as the more difficult holes?” It is interesting to me that Tom Simpson did not address the imbalance of the par 3’s versus the par 5’s.

The highlight of the Red course are the slopes and tiers of the greens. Much like the more famous nearby courses, the greens have good slopes, tiers, bunkers, and nearby fall-offs and humps. This is a difficult golf course to list my favorite holes because I liked the shape and complexity of nearly every green. Some of the holes are stronger than others from a visual perspective as well as length yet an excellent green transforms what seemingly is a weaker hole relative to ones just played all of a sudden to a very good hole.

I make various notations and notes on my scorecard to designate the quality and memorability of the hole I have just played. In the case of The Berkshire Red course, I had many notations for the greens.

My favorite holes are five, eight, ten, fourteen, and sixteen to eighteen. It is not that the other holes are not good or weak; they are fine golf holes.

On five, a slightly downhill par 3 of 178/166 there are two bunkers that are somewhat disguised. Despite this being one of the less sloped greens is a compelling tee shot.

The eighth is a slight dogleg right, par 4 of 428/412 with two fronting bunkers and a green sloped sharply back to front. I very much like the look of this hole from tee to green.

The par 3 tenth at 188/148 has a sharp fall-off on the right side and a bank on the left side. It is one of the prettier holes from the tee and one of the more punitive holes if one misses the green.

Fourteen is a longer par 4 at 434/428 with another green sloped to the left so the ideal approach shot should be center or right, yet on the right side of the green are two fronting bunkers. I do wish more of the holes, particularly the par 5’s had this type of shot-making to consider.

Sixteen is the longest par 3 on the course at 221/205 to a green that has two bunkers on either side but well short of another tilted green. This is another visually pleasing golf hole.

Seventeen is the longest hole on the Red course at 562 yards and plays longer as a dogleg right. The green has two tiers and fronting bunkers. If only the other par 5’s were equal to the challenges posed by this hole.

Eighteen is a par 3 of 175/163 and is uphill back at the clubhouse with another two-tiered green. It is not as beautiful as other holes, but it is a substantial challenge and likely decides the outcome of a match.

The club could make the player have more decisions to make with the addition of more fairway bunkers and moving some of the greenside bunkers closer to the green. Many of the green side bunkers are merely “eye candy” to distract one from the green but actually are not very close. It is clever, but likely makes the course a bit easier than the original architects intended.

I read other reviews that stated that one should play here before the three “W” courses (I am assuming Worplesdon, Woking and West Hill), but I would add to that Wentworth as well. For me, playing both of these courses the same day is a superior day to one round at those courses, or two rounds on the West and East at Wentworth, even if those courses might be superior. In sum, The Berkshire is never a grind: it is always fun. Mr. Fowler created yet again another wonderful golf course. He is often an under-appreciated golf course architect.

Absolute gem of a course and probably the most balanced members’ club around London with a great membership, two top courses and a great lunch. I visited a few weeks ago after being away for five years. The club has done some commendable work recovering the heathland feel of the course. Thousands of trees have been removed, heather restored and the fairways and greens were in impeccable shape. This is a world class golf course which never seems to get out of the shadow of some of its better known neighbours. In my opinion, after the recent work, the Red should indubitably be considered in the same category as Swinley, the Sunningdale courses and St. George’s Hill; yet the Red rarely features in world top 100 rankings. Perhaps the members are just content to keep this wonderful course to themselves and that would be completely understandable.

What is there not to like about the Red course at the Berkshire ?. A very good Herbert Fowler designed course, easy to book, reduced winter green fee, friendly, no air's and grace's, breakfast in the snack bar ready and waiting, quiet (no one in front and no one behind), understated and doesn't seem to have changed much since my list visit over 15 years ago. Very well presented and the hand cut greens were of excellent pace for November. Fairways reasonably generous but miss them at your peril because the heather is very penal; I imagine the abundance of heather when in bloom looks a picture.

No poor holes, although I thought the back nine (starting with a really nice run of holes from 10-12) was more interesting than the front. Standout holes for me were 4, 6, 8, 11, 12 and 14 (all the par 4's !) which were excellent and I can't help feeling a couple more would have been ideal. Par 3's were good, with the pick of the six for me being the 10th, 186 yards over a ravine. Best par 5 of the six was I think the 17th which would have been an excellent finishing hole, especially as I thought the 18th was possibly the weakest of the par 3's. Mix of holes on the Red course is often mentioned and for me (and this is only a personal opinion) I think possibly too many par 5's and par 3's; however that is the way the Red course is designed so I'm not complaining. Comparing with other courses I would say St.Georges Hill would just nudge it because of it's quality par 3's, very comparable with Beau Desert (another Herbert Fowler design and one of my favourite courses) and I would also say a touch behind Parkstone (slightly prefer the balance of Parkstone which only has five par 5's and five par 3's!).

Strength of The Berkshire's was that it was an absolute pleasure to play. .. an over-riding memory is of a couple of mixed groups of golfers rocking up onto the Blue course with their dogs (best behaved ever) and seeing them wandering around the other course at various times during our round .. quintessentially english !

The Red course at The Berkshire is every bit as beautiful as many of its peers in the local area. This is a serene, picturesque course with lots of land movement, rolling through birch and pine woodland all making this a beautiful setting for golf. As most acknowledge when writing a review of the Red course, its USP is that it has the highly unusual feature of having the same number of par threes, fours and fives through its card which means the challenge on the tee never feels repetitive. Appearance wise, there are many similarities with its near neighbour Swinley Forest, or nearby St George’s Hill. Greens with banked shoulders and bunkers with heathery surrounds are a regular feature, and the feedback from some critics that the trees encroach too much on the playing characteristics of the course were visibly being addressed during my playing of the course where the clearance of trees and shrubbery was being carried out. This should open up some of the wonderful vistas from the higher ground and make the undulating land features that the course is blessed with more prominent.

There are enough inherent qualities to The Berkshire’s Red course to make it potentially worth consideration for a World Top 100 list. At present, I’d probably say what holds the course back in this respect is that the individual holes themselves maybe lack the memorability to achieve that status. It remains to be seen whether the tree clearance has the desired impact to elevate the course’s ranking, maybe some feature bunker-work and mounding would also help. However, what it perhaps lacks in individuality it gains in strategy. Herbert Fowler did a great job here with many of the holes having a more obvious side of the fairway that needs to be struck from the tee to get the easier angle of attack into the green. To reference the individual holes, the clear standout for me was the par three 10th that shares many similar characteristics to the 17th at Royal Portrush, the Calamity hole. The quality of this middle stretch of the course is reinforced by the excellent back-to-back short par fours at the 11th and 12th; the former with its raised green guarded with sand embedded into the climb to the green, and the latter, doglegging slightly across heather to a rising fairway with a green that stands proudly, semi blind above the golfers approaching it. The short par five 13th with its raised tee and mid-fairway dip, recently improved strong par three 16th and the wonderful five shotter over the stream at 17 round off why I felt that the back nine just edged the front in terms of quality, but frankly there is no weak spell across the whole course.

Before mine, there have only been seven reviews of the course since 2012. I was surprised to read so few reviews for a club as prominent as The Berkshire so I’m not sure whether this is a reflection of a relatively infrequent number of visitors’ rounds or the club being passed by due to the quality of the competition on its doorstep? The Berkshire is less private than Swinley, less expensive than Sunningdale and better than each of the three Ws. A tour of the heathland belt west of London needs to include a day at The Berkshire or you’re truly missing out on a real gem. This is one of England’s best heathland courses.

Berkshire has some fantastic courses and this is definitely one of them. From the very first hole you know you're in for a great round and one that you will enjoy regardless of how you play. As far as heathland courses go this is well up there as one of my favourites, absolutely no weak holes on this golf course and its simply fabulous. The condition of the course is amazing, fast greens, great looking fairways, fantastic bunkers, everything is perfect. Its a very interesting course with six par 3s, six par 4s and six par 5s which makes it very fun and not feel like too much of a slog.

The first is a fairly short par 5 with a ditch up slightly to the left and plenty of heather either side of the fairway. The green also has 2 tiers and is very undulated so important to get the right club with your approach shot. The 2nd is a short par 3 playing about 160 yards with bunkers short right and heather leading up to the green. When you get to the par 3 7th hole you are met with a fantastic view overlooking the blue course. This is a great par 3 playing about 210 yards over a lot of heather and has a very complex green, all of us managed to 3 putt on this one! The 9th is a beautiful finish to the front with a great looking drive and another good shot required to reach this green in 2 on the relatively short par 5.

The back nine I seemed to enjoy even more than the front and the 10th hole was a great way to start. A 200 yard par 3 with a big quarry filled with heather all the way short of the green. Go right and you'll be lucky to find your ball. The 11th is the best driving hole on the course, a 350 yard par 4 with an elevated tee providing you with a stunning view. The finish to the red course is a tough one as there are 2 par 3s in the last 3 holes. 16 is a 200 yard par 3 with a tough green, 17 is a long par 5 and 18 is a 170 yard par 3 surrounded by bunkers short, left and long.

One thing that I liked about the Berkshire is that every hole was stunning and you would be rewarded with straight drives as it wasn't crowded with fairway bunkers unlike other heathland courses such as Woodhall spa which has plenty of harsh fairway bunkers. The Berkshire is truly a great course and made better by how friendly and peaceful it is, a great experience and a real joy to play. Cannot give this course anything other than 6 balls.

The club itself remains entrenched in the mid fifties with a rather sniffy feel. The course on the other hand is every bit as good as the reviews suggest . The condition all round is top notch with some great holes. Avoid the heather and it's possible to score well here if you don't expect some big numbers

Some people are in fact split on which course they prefer but I thought the Red was a clear notch above its sibling; both created in 1928 by Herbert Fowler.

As you might expect on this superb piece of terrain the par threes, of which there are six, are all very high quality with the second, tenth and 16th the best.

Unusually there are also six par fours and six par fives. And it is this equal distribution of par that helps dictate an exciting tone throughout the round. None of the three-shotters are overly long and as a result even the modest player will be presented with some birdie opportunities. The par fours offer a good variety with a few medium length holes and a couple of longer ones. The sharp dog-legging sixth, the exacting eighth and the uphill curving 12th stood out for me.

The Red course is arguably more scoreable than the Blue and has slightly more width from the tee but this is negligible in the grand scheme of thing. The design and set-up of both courses add to the appeal for an enjoyable day out as opposed to a demanding and mentally draining slog over 36 holes.

Ed is the founder of Golf Empire – click the link to read his full review.