The Crail Golfing Society may be over 200 years old but they do know how to move with the times. Due to the pressure of an increasing number of visiting golfers, a decision was made in the mid 1990s to acquire a relatively modest 114 acres of land next to their Balcomie course and transform the cliff top setting into a modern, seaside golf course.
Many eyebrows were raised when American Gil Hanse, an unknown architect in the British Isles, was appointed to design the new 18-hole layout. His small firm was established in 1993 following his departure from Tom Doak’s Renaissance Golf Design team and he set out to design courses that were “simple and elegant in appearance yet sophisticated in strategy and interest.”
Hanse may have been a surprise overseas selection as architect but he was no stranger to UK shores as he had spent a year during his Cornell studies with the famous English golf course design firm of Hawtree so he was well aware of what would be expected of his inaugural design in Britain.
His interpretation of a Scottish links is very good, despite the fact that the terrain is more pasture and headland than true sandy soiled links land. An interesting challenge for Hanse was to incorporate several stonewalls – and one of particular archaeological importance, “Danes Dyke” – into the design. This elevated track cuts across five holes, presenting a formidable barrier from the tee on the uphill 11th hole and creating a blind approach to the green at the 15th hole.
It’s obvious that some earth moving was carried out on the property – particularly, for example, at the 2nd where an almost island green has been created at a 45-degree angle to the fairway – but the finished holes never appear out of sync with their surroundings.
The most striking design elements at the Craighead are the bunkering and green complexes. The bunkers were created under the watchful eye of Walter Woods, a former green keeper on the Old Course at nearby St Andrews. So it should come as no surprise that some have likened them in quality to those at Muirfield. Putting surfaces were constructed to USGA standard, running very true and fast, with many contoured greens providing a real test for putting skills.
It’s a mystery as to why the Craighead did not feature in any golf course ranking tables since it came into play in 1999 until we first ranked it in 2008 – are golfers so enthralled with playing at the traditional links along the Fife coast that they are overlooking a genuine, modern day golfing gem that is staring them in the face?
It seems impossible to review Craighead without comparing it to Balcomie. I am clearly not alone in preferring Craighead. I really like the varied challenge of the holes, especially those along the clifftop. Balcomie is one of Scotland's more over-rated tracks in my opinion. Golf World's most recent ranking places it at #52 in Scotland with Craighead not featuring in their top 100! I believe both these placings to be wide of the mark. Were I to make the journey to Crail I would certainly prefer to play Craighead. While it is undoubtedly more demanding it is also more interesting.
If you only have time for 18, I'd play the Balcomie instead of the Craighead. However, this course is still very nice and enjoyable. It won't beat you up, and it's a nice easy walk with great views of the sea.
Gil Hanse has done a very good job with the land that he was given, and while it's impossible not to be aware of the flat location Craighead is a very good golf course. Personally though, I'm not a huge fan of "strategic" seaside courses where the shots you have to play are felt to be more important than the environment and golfing experience. The cliffside holes are beautiful, the old walls are interesting, and the overall quality is excellent at a great club. If it were anywhere else I would probably rate Craighead more highly than I do. It's definitely worth making an effort to play but one can't escape the feeling that there are more fun courses to play within a very short drive (or even a walk over the entrance road.)
Anyone travelling to Crail for the first time will be aiming to play a round on the balcomie course, the oldest of the 2 courses you can find at the golfing society.
However it is fair to say that Craighead is a much more interesting course than the balcomie and offers very challenging & scenic holes. Desinged by Gil Hanse, it is his first course out of the USA. The results is a splendid links that any golfer will enjoy.
Loved both 18's AND the view from the clubhouse here.
Both courses have some great holes wsome with an unusual twist.
I played Craighead for the first time on New Year’s Day - actually putting out on the first as the sun came up over the North Sea. There’s no shortage of great courses in the area but it’s well worth finding time to fit in a round here; Gil Hanse has done a great job creating a fun and challenging course to complement the old Balcomie links.
As others have written, the back nine is definitely the highlight, making full use of the more interesting ground closer to the sea; the short par 4 10th and the longer 14th, running along the cliff edge, stood out for me, but the truth is that there isn’t really a week hole on the course. Even on the front nine, much of which is over the less promising ground, strong bunkering and interesting greens make for a good test.
I finally got round to visiting Crail last month, playing the more exposed Craighead in the morning and the Balcomie in the afternoon. Gil Hanse has created a modern design that beautifully compliments it's historical older sibling next door and although Craighead is considerably longer and tougher, there is more than enough width to the fairways to make it very playable for everyone.
After a gentle par-5 opener, the excellent dogleg 2nd requires some thought and is possibly the best hole on the front 9. Although not particularly long, accuracy from the tee is crucial if the best line of approach is to be found to a raised and heavily defended green.
The not-so short 5th, a par-3 measuring 211 yards from the yellow tees, is a rather bland hole in all honesty and my least favourite on the course but the other par-3's are all stand-out holes. The 7th and 13th are well defended, attractive cliff-top holes and the 17th contains the most wickedly undulating green of them all.
The pace picks up considerably on the back nine, kicking off with a brilliant drive-able downhill par-4, with anything played too far right running the risk of being gobbled up by a large gorse bushes. From here onwards much of the course is bordered or crossed by attractive stone walls which certainly add to the challenge and aesthetic charm. The downhill 12th offers another opportunity to drive the green for the better players and the 14th,16th and 18th are all solid par-4's late in the round.
Both courses deliver an interesting round of golf as well as panoramic coastal views but the quick, undulating greens and excellent bunkering on Craighead makes it the one that I would choose to play. Brian W
During our second golf trip to Scotland, we visited Fife. After we met the ultra nice head pro Graeme Lennie and his assistant David, we decided to play both Crail courses that day: Crailhead in the morning and Balcomie in the afternoon.
It was a bit of a grey start of a busy day at Crail, but the pace in the morning was still OK-ish.
Crailhead offers a very decent opening nine, good turf and greens, but I was not overwhelmed by the plot of land the holes have been laid out: it did not give me the feeling I was playing a links course. Luckily the second nine has links character by the dozen, starting with a charming short par4 and ending the round with a testing, long par4. We found the course in excellent condition, despite the fact that Fife had been extremely dry the weeks before and during our visit.
The clubhouse offered a welcomed lunch & tea and promising views of the course we would play in the afternoon, Balcomie.
If you decide to travel up to Crail to shoot some golf, I can recommend to play the Crail combo in this order: it will give you a decent golf warm-up in the morning and a links adventure in the afternoon. You will not be disappointed.
I hope Mr. Lennie is not offended to much by my reviews of 'his' courses at Crail....
Most of the greens on the Craighead, in complete contrast to the Balcomie Links, are very undulating. On the back nine some are also raised with mounds toward the centre. This makes it difficult to get close to the flag, even more so in the wind.
A deliberate design feature at Craighead is that there are no two consecutive holes running in the same direction. This will keep you constantly guessing if, as I did, you play in what our member friend said was a “7 out of 10 wind”.
There are some tough par fours here with three of them being in excess of 450 yards. The par threes were a real feature with the 13th and 17th being outstanding. The 160-yard 13th plays to a green with a gully and then then a steep cliff very close to the left edge. The 197-yard 17th features the best bunkering on the links.
This review is an edited extract from Another Journey through the Links, which has been reproduced with David Worley’s kind permission. The author has exclusively rated for us every Scottish course featured in his book. Another Journey through the Links is available for Australian buyers via www.golfbooks.com.au and through Amazon for buyers from other countries.